1 00:02:46,060 --> 00:02:47,414 And the drinking? 2 00:02:47,425 --> 00:02:50,237 I've been having a hard time sleeping. 3 00:02:50,394 --> 00:02:53,699 And my husband and I, weren't doing well. 4 00:02:54,685 --> 00:02:56,899 It was a really bad time. 5 00:02:56,971 --> 00:02:58,750 And... 6 00:02:58,993 --> 00:03:03,141 I started having a few drinks to... 7 00:03:03,383 --> 00:03:05,071 Knock myself out. 8 00:03:05,196 --> 00:03:09,768 And when that didn't kill it, I had pain meds. 9 00:03:10,398 --> 00:03:13,171 Your husband said that you were suspended from the bar. 10 00:03:13,207 --> 00:03:15,913 - No, I wasn't suspended. - Oh. 11 00:03:16,038 --> 00:03:17,937 Okay, he mentioned... 12 00:03:17,981 --> 00:03:20,232 I was put on probation. 13 00:03:20,267 --> 00:03:22,101 One morning, I was late to court. 14 00:03:22,127 --> 00:03:26,420 And the judge chastised me... 15 00:03:26,500 --> 00:03:28,516 I just lost it. 16 00:03:28,723 --> 00:03:32,187 I don't know what I said, but... 17 00:03:32,413 --> 00:03:35,859 He ordered a breathalyzer test and... 18 00:03:35,921 --> 00:03:38,864 I was put on probation. 19 00:03:39,188 --> 00:03:41,077 I wasn't suspended. 20 00:03:46,437 --> 00:03:49,604 Must've been difficult for you to tell me all that. 21 00:03:50,775 --> 00:03:52,997 Will it get me my daughter back? 22 00:04:15,839 --> 00:04:17,495 I need another case. 23 00:04:17,558 --> 00:04:18,982 Preferably, one I can win. 24 00:04:19,017 --> 00:04:21,268 Miss McCall, your work here is considered restitution. 25 00:04:21,285 --> 00:04:22,779 You don't get to pick and choose. 26 00:04:22,823 --> 00:04:26,751 One part of my life I haven't completely fucked up is my record in court. 27 00:04:26,833 --> 00:04:28,353 I'd like to keep it that way. 28 00:04:28,398 --> 00:04:31,134 This is a goddamn Habeas case, I'm a civil defense attorney. 29 00:04:31,158 --> 00:04:32,719 It's essentially a civil action, 30 00:04:32,768 --> 00:04:35,480 I'm sure you'll find the rules our victim plead is discoverably familiar. 31 00:04:35,526 --> 00:04:38,292 Come on, you must have people who are better qualified. 32 00:04:38,328 --> 00:04:42,142 We try to provide destitute women access to the very best legal counsel available. 33 00:04:42,156 --> 00:04:46,581 At the moment, the best counsel we have to offer Lacey Stubbs is you. 34 00:04:48,495 --> 00:04:52,786 She was just moved from Valley State to CWCF. 35 00:04:53,304 --> 00:04:54,174 Why? 36 00:04:54,300 --> 00:04:57,256 She was moved after being raped repeatedly. 37 00:04:57,364 --> 00:04:58,875 By her guard. 38 00:05:00,041 --> 00:05:01,776 So you're saying, I can't refuse? 39 00:05:01,811 --> 00:05:03,107 Of course you can. 40 00:05:03,423 --> 00:05:06,670 And I can refuse to recommend you be taken off probation. 41 00:05:11,989 --> 00:05:14,033 You're all set, have a great flight. 42 00:05:15,224 --> 00:05:16,972 When the cops first arrested her, she said yeah... 43 00:05:16,994 --> 00:05:19,601 She and her friend went over to the victim's house with a rope and a butcher knife... 44 00:05:19,726 --> 00:05:21,294 But only to frighten her, and then... 45 00:05:21,328 --> 00:05:25,946 Later, things got out of hands and whoops she accidentally slit the girl's throat. 46 00:05:26,176 --> 00:05:27,550 Hate when that happens. 47 00:05:27,564 --> 00:05:30,242 Later, she changed the story and says the boyfriend did it. 48 00:05:30,270 --> 00:05:31,994 Look at her. 49 00:05:33,080 --> 00:05:34,592 Does she like to play dress up? 50 00:05:34,613 --> 00:05:36,485 It's a fucking freak show. 51 00:05:36,556 --> 00:05:38,887 The DA's got the best friend saying Lacey did it. 52 00:05:38,930 --> 00:05:42,798 The boyfriend saying Lacey did it, even the victim said Lacey did it, right before she died. 53 00:05:42,820 --> 00:05:45,951 - The mind is like... - It's a loser. 54 00:05:46,283 --> 00:05:50,334 Come on, Cate. You're doing great, you really are. 55 00:05:50,459 --> 00:05:52,138 I feel like shit. 56 00:05:52,189 --> 00:05:53,570 You're all set. 57 00:05:53,585 --> 00:05:55,615 - Thank you. - You're welcome. 58 00:05:55,997 --> 00:05:58,629 Feelings aren't facts. 59 00:05:59,298 --> 00:06:01,393 Give me a hug. 60 00:06:04,712 --> 00:06:08,591 Just call me, everyday. Okay? 61 00:06:08,835 --> 00:06:10,455 Yeah. 62 00:06:48,270 --> 00:06:50,090 Hold the other gate. 63 00:07:01,897 --> 00:07:02,846 Hey Snow White. 64 00:07:02,889 --> 00:07:04,156 Shut up. 65 00:07:04,206 --> 00:07:06,459 Stubbs, you got a visitor. 66 00:07:08,503 --> 00:07:11,079 You understand what a Habeas Petition is? 67 00:07:11,204 --> 00:07:14,794 I think so, after you lose all your appeals, you go to the... 68 00:07:14,816 --> 00:07:16,463 Essentially you're telling a federal judge... 69 00:07:16,504 --> 00:07:18,866 That you believe your imprisonment was unconstitutional. 70 00:07:18,917 --> 00:07:22,427 Because the state court that convicted You made a legal or factual error. 71 00:07:22,462 --> 00:07:24,860 I've been keeping list of all the mistakes. 72 00:07:24,889 --> 00:07:28,655 You have to persuade the judge that there was significant trial error. 73 00:07:28,698 --> 00:07:30,584 I didn't kill Jen. 74 00:07:32,113 --> 00:07:34,984 Honestly, whether you're guilty or innocent is beside the point. 75 00:07:34,999 --> 00:07:37,655 She went out with my boyfriend when I was pregnant. 76 00:07:37,719 --> 00:07:41,505 I screamed at her, I said terrible things to her, but I didn't kill her. 77 00:07:41,542 --> 00:07:43,782 So, why did you tell the cops that you did? 78 00:07:43,810 --> 00:07:47,258 Because I didn't want to send my baby's dad to the gas chamber. 79 00:07:48,071 --> 00:07:51,270 And then when I found out he lied to me about everything... 80 00:07:52,997 --> 00:07:56,892 Including never loving me or the baby, I had to tell the cops the truth. 81 00:07:57,229 --> 00:07:58,489 Which is what? 82 00:07:58,749 --> 00:08:01,674 Me and Dorrie just went over there to scare her. 83 00:08:01,800 --> 00:08:03,849 But Dorrie just lost it. 84 00:08:05,799 --> 00:08:08,431 She was screaming in Jen's face and pushed her really hard. 85 00:08:08,556 --> 00:08:10,235 Jen hit her head. 86 00:08:11,033 --> 00:08:13,531 And I tried to pull her off, but... 87 00:08:13,905 --> 00:08:15,582 She was just gone. 88 00:08:17,800 --> 00:08:21,708 She was straddling her and hacking off her head with a butcher knife. 89 00:08:22,514 --> 00:08:25,350 There was all this blood... 90 00:08:25,898 --> 00:08:29,794 I ran outside to tell Rusty, he said he'd take care of it. 91 00:08:31,163 --> 00:08:33,367 And a couple minutes later, they came running out... 92 00:08:33,492 --> 00:08:35,862 And told me to get in the car. 93 00:08:35,987 --> 00:08:38,176 So, Rusty killed her? 94 00:08:38,564 --> 00:08:40,324 And why would he do that? 95 00:08:40,449 --> 00:08:43,080 She was telling everyone he raped her. 96 00:08:43,412 --> 00:08:46,094 He was afraid that she'd press charges. 97 00:08:46,138 --> 00:08:47,844 Was it true? 98 00:08:48,174 --> 00:08:50,219 That he raped her? 99 00:08:52,588 --> 00:08:55,582 Rusty, he raped me on our second date. 100 00:08:58,654 --> 00:09:02,488 So why would Dorrie tell the police that it was you? 101 00:09:02,538 --> 00:09:04,230 Cause I told her to. 102 00:09:04,597 --> 00:09:08,186 We were in trailer, and he said that he'd get the death penalty. 103 00:09:08,229 --> 00:09:10,611 And they go lighter on a girl. 104 00:09:13,033 --> 00:09:14,660 Unfortunately, when you changed your story... 105 00:09:14,689 --> 00:09:19,255 You look at me like I'm shit, I'm not shit. Maybe I didn't do everything right... 106 00:09:19,270 --> 00:09:22,163 Or go to college or have a perfect life like you. 107 00:09:22,200 --> 00:09:24,713 But I have a kid out there that I'm not raising because... 108 00:09:24,735 --> 00:09:28,078 My shitty lawyer and the DA fucked me over and gave me life without parole... 109 00:09:28,113 --> 00:09:30,688 When I wasn't even there. 110 00:09:34,504 --> 00:09:36,739 I'll look at your list. 111 00:09:43,612 --> 00:09:45,159 Getting everything organized? 112 00:09:45,200 --> 00:09:47,571 I'm packing. 113 00:09:48,424 --> 00:09:49,737 Taking a trip? 114 00:09:50,994 --> 00:09:52,676 Uh-uh. 115 00:09:54,276 --> 00:09:55,596 Can I come to? 116 00:09:55,793 --> 00:09:59,345 Just me and daddy and blue dog. 117 00:10:01,630 --> 00:10:05,895 I'm gonna have a rainbow room and a fish. 118 00:10:06,845 --> 00:10:08,733 That sounds nice. 119 00:10:08,765 --> 00:10:10,931 We have to take a plane. 120 00:10:10,980 --> 00:10:12,616 To your rainbow room? 121 00:10:12,673 --> 00:10:14,871 For daddy's new job. 122 00:10:15,667 --> 00:10:17,258 Daddy has a new job? 123 00:10:17,308 --> 00:10:20,390 Uh-um, in Seattle. 124 00:10:22,081 --> 00:10:23,904 - You never see her anyway! - I see her! 125 00:10:23,946 --> 00:10:27,071 You're either off having a mental breakdown or you're too busy working. 126 00:10:27,096 --> 00:10:29,302 One of us had to earn some money. 127 00:10:29,327 --> 00:10:32,412 Sorry, I'm sorry. I know I fucked up. 128 00:10:32,477 --> 00:10:34,537 But you can't do this. 129 00:10:34,626 --> 00:10:37,244 You can't take her to another state. I'm her mom. 130 00:10:37,293 --> 00:10:38,995 You'll always be her mom. 131 00:10:39,619 --> 00:10:42,317 I'm just not gonna let you keep hurting her. 132 00:10:47,847 --> 00:10:51,831 While you were in rehab, Josh has de facto sole custody. 133 00:10:53,061 --> 00:10:55,547 We're working against him, and not an unpleasant evidence. 134 00:10:55,605 --> 00:10:57,427 I've been going to meetings. 135 00:10:57,552 --> 00:10:59,970 And working this pro bono case so I can get off probation. 136 00:11:00,011 --> 00:11:03,250 I'm completely fucking sober except a cigarette here and there. 137 00:11:03,283 --> 00:11:04,637 Are you seeing Augie? 138 00:11:04,653 --> 00:11:07,441 I'd be seeing a lot more of her if I had any kind of help. 139 00:11:07,688 --> 00:11:10,584 - This case I'm working on... - Spend time with your kid, Cate. 140 00:11:10,971 --> 00:11:13,859 We need to make you present in her life again. 141 00:11:17,883 --> 00:11:20,258 I'm having a really tough week this week. 142 00:11:20,581 --> 00:11:24,209 Gotta lot of stuff going on, trying to... 143 00:11:24,245 --> 00:11:25,711 You know. 144 00:11:25,783 --> 00:11:28,095 Figure out... 145 00:11:28,490 --> 00:11:31,146 I have a really hard time surrendering. 146 00:11:31,547 --> 00:11:33,103 I've been... 147 00:11:33,420 --> 00:11:36,025 Pretending to give up control, but... 148 00:11:36,067 --> 00:11:40,771 I still want what I want, I still want certain outcomes, you know? 149 00:11:41,164 --> 00:11:43,325 So I start bargaining. 150 00:11:43,719 --> 00:11:46,534 And then I start making deals with God. 151 00:11:47,568 --> 00:11:49,245 "If You do this for me..." 152 00:11:49,370 --> 00:11:52,666 "I will have another month sober". 153 00:11:53,558 --> 00:11:56,437 And then I start feeling guilty about how I'm working my program. 154 00:11:56,463 --> 00:11:59,095 Or how I'm not working my program. 155 00:12:01,491 --> 00:12:05,642 So how's Augie and what has she done? 156 00:12:06,390 --> 00:12:08,923 She accused me of being perfect. 157 00:12:11,896 --> 00:12:15,362 It's nice to know I can still fool somebody. 158 00:12:16,077 --> 00:12:19,583 Hey, are you okay? 159 00:12:22,050 --> 00:12:24,500 I got a text from Wilson George. 160 00:12:25,646 --> 00:12:28,140 Maybe I should just call him, consult my list. 161 00:12:28,169 --> 00:12:31,731 The idea isn't to endangered yourself. 162 00:12:31,856 --> 00:12:34,195 Why don't you just change your number? 163 00:12:34,230 --> 00:12:35,969 I like my number. 164 00:12:36,157 --> 00:12:39,363 Wilson George may have been cleared. 165 00:12:39,384 --> 00:12:42,215 But he is still dangerous. 166 00:12:47,122 --> 00:12:49,765 Had you been treated for alcohol addiction? 167 00:12:49,795 --> 00:12:52,581 Or depression prior to your state clear haven? 168 00:12:52,626 --> 00:12:53,534 No. 169 00:12:54,599 --> 00:12:56,527 Do you want to tell me about it? 170 00:12:57,059 --> 00:12:58,737 Do I want to? 171 00:13:04,389 --> 00:13:06,657 I was working in the DA's office. 172 00:13:07,078 --> 00:13:08,176 This was... 173 00:13:08,449 --> 00:13:10,179 12 years ago. 174 00:13:10,304 --> 00:13:11,649 It was 12. 175 00:13:12,528 --> 00:13:16,304 And I was assigned this... 176 00:13:16,622 --> 00:13:20,276 It was a rape murder of a 6 years old girl. 177 00:13:20,661 --> 00:13:21,954 And I've seen some... 178 00:13:22,242 --> 00:13:26,122 Horrible awful things, but this one was just... 179 00:13:26,380 --> 00:13:27,656 Beyond. 180 00:13:27,856 --> 00:13:31,735 I made it my mission to put this guy away. 181 00:13:32,186 --> 00:13:36,900 And so when I got the conviction, I felt great and then... 182 00:13:37,174 --> 00:13:39,769 When the jury sends him to die... 183 00:13:39,791 --> 00:13:43,268 I felt like I did something right. 184 00:13:43,852 --> 00:13:46,990 For a long time, I didn't really think about it. 185 00:13:47,033 --> 00:13:52,425 Except that I was glad that he wasn't out there hurting anybody. 186 00:13:53,955 --> 00:13:56,604 And so, I was deep into another case. 187 00:13:56,627 --> 00:13:59,036 I'd left the Prosecutors Office a few years before. 188 00:13:59,058 --> 00:14:02,507 And I got a call, they had tested semen samples. 189 00:14:02,632 --> 00:14:04,442 Taken from the girl's sock. 190 00:14:05,391 --> 00:14:07,668 And, I guess... 191 00:14:07,881 --> 00:14:09,704 Technology had advanced to... 192 00:14:09,740 --> 00:14:13,332 Where they were able to determine based on the new... 193 00:14:13,549 --> 00:14:15,271 DNA evidence that... 194 00:14:16,002 --> 00:14:21,085 That it wasn't actually Wilson George and he was innocent. 195 00:14:22,438 --> 00:14:24,175 I felt like... 196 00:14:24,300 --> 00:14:26,606 Everything that I knew... 197 00:14:27,346 --> 00:14:28,912 Everything that I... 198 00:14:29,266 --> 00:14:31,708 Felt good about was... 199 00:14:32,225 --> 00:14:35,580 Was wrong. False. 200 00:14:40,322 --> 00:14:43,644 They got Dorrie's testimony, they got Rusty's testimony. 201 00:14:43,682 --> 00:14:45,637 And they got the victim's pretty stricken mother... 202 00:14:45,682 --> 00:14:48,859 Standing up there saying her daughter's last word was "Lacey did it". 203 00:14:48,888 --> 00:14:50,472 But it's a lie. 204 00:14:50,767 --> 00:14:53,409 My lawyer said he spoke to some medical examiner guy that said... 205 00:14:53,447 --> 00:14:55,419 There's no way Jen could've said I did it. 206 00:14:55,463 --> 00:14:57,482 Because her throat was sliced through. 207 00:14:57,836 --> 00:14:59,189 Who? Ennis? 208 00:14:59,418 --> 00:15:01,693 I read his testimony, that's not what he said in court. 209 00:15:01,724 --> 00:15:04,211 I know, but that's what he told my lawyer. 210 00:15:04,270 --> 00:15:06,693 So there's no way she could say anything. 211 00:15:26,199 --> 00:15:27,913 Dr. Ennis? 212 00:15:28,882 --> 00:15:30,157 Yes? 213 00:15:30,963 --> 00:15:33,468 Do you do consulting work on trials? 214 00:15:33,504 --> 00:15:35,531 Yes, yes that's right. Excuse me. 215 00:15:35,657 --> 00:15:38,613 So, I could hire you to give testimony. 216 00:15:39,057 --> 00:15:40,344 Well... 217 00:15:41,215 --> 00:15:44,282 We work primarily with Law Enforcement, 218 00:15:44,407 --> 00:15:46,710 Police, DA's office mainly. 219 00:15:46,835 --> 00:15:48,045 And they keep you busy enough? 220 00:15:48,070 --> 00:15:49,643 Oh yeah, they keep us really busy. 221 00:15:49,710 --> 00:15:51,905 I'd say 99,9% of our work... 222 00:15:51,928 --> 00:15:53,384 Comes from Law Enforcement. 223 00:15:53,509 --> 00:15:57,755 So, you wouldn't just change your opinion because... 224 00:15:57,785 --> 00:15:59,565 Somebody called you and ask you to. 225 00:15:59,639 --> 00:16:02,978 Like, say one of the DAs who gives you all that business. 226 00:16:03,369 --> 00:16:04,832 No, of course not. 227 00:16:04,876 --> 00:16:08,332 Because 5 years ago, you told Lacey Stubbs' lawyer that... 228 00:16:08,354 --> 00:16:10,094 Jennifer Cole couldn't have spoken. 229 00:16:10,175 --> 00:16:12,636 And then in court you changed your mind and said... 230 00:16:12,681 --> 00:16:16,541 She could've spoken in somewhat slurred less intelligible manner. 231 00:16:16,601 --> 00:16:19,364 Sounds like a pretty big change, don't you think? 232 00:16:19,940 --> 00:16:22,223 Says the DA admitted to calling you and then... 233 00:16:22,267 --> 00:16:26,272 When the judge asked if you felt threatened or intimidated, you said no. 234 00:16:26,508 --> 00:16:27,137 Right. 235 00:16:27,152 --> 00:16:30,766 Even though 99.9% of your business was at stake? 236 00:16:33,128 --> 00:16:34,665 You should leave now. 237 00:16:37,406 --> 00:16:38,868 So they tampered with him? 238 00:16:38,971 --> 00:16:40,774 Sure as hell looks like it. 239 00:16:40,826 --> 00:16:44,672 This isn't a simple appeal, I need to reinvestigate the case. 240 00:16:45,086 --> 00:16:47,724 I don't have a big money firm backing me here. 241 00:16:47,761 --> 00:16:50,932 No in-house PI, no team of paralegals. 242 00:16:51,146 --> 00:16:52,453 I don't even have an office. 243 00:16:52,498 --> 00:16:54,337 There he is. 244 00:16:55,078 --> 00:16:57,538 Doesn't that just scream serenity? 245 00:16:57,605 --> 00:17:00,390 Criminal defense is your world. 246 00:17:02,518 --> 00:17:03,768 You're not gonna answer me? 247 00:17:03,790 --> 00:17:06,131 Was there a question back there somewhere? 248 00:17:06,257 --> 00:17:09,298 I need to find out what rock Rusty Berkhart crawled under... 249 00:17:09,423 --> 00:17:11,793 After he served his whopping 3 months. 250 00:17:11,812 --> 00:17:14,257 3 months for accessory to murder? 251 00:17:14,286 --> 00:17:17,163 Hindering apprehension, DA cut him a sweetheart deal... 252 00:17:17,288 --> 00:17:19,043 In exchange for testifying against Lacey. 253 00:17:19,052 --> 00:17:21,661 And I need to talk to Dorrie Booth. 254 00:17:22,865 --> 00:17:24,394 Are you asking me for help? 255 00:17:24,431 --> 00:17:26,160 Like you're so busy. 256 00:17:26,285 --> 00:17:27,786 What do I get? 257 00:17:28,392 --> 00:17:31,584 My undying love and continue to steam. 258 00:17:31,629 --> 00:17:33,267 Oh... 259 00:17:33,643 --> 00:17:34,840 Fine, I'll blow you. 260 00:17:34,892 --> 00:17:36,599 Now we're talking. 261 00:17:38,176 --> 00:17:41,179 So you know, I supported Josh for years while he was trying to get this... 262 00:17:41,183 --> 00:17:44,831 Video game launched, and that project belt... 263 00:17:45,651 --> 00:17:46,657 Hold on. 264 00:17:48,600 --> 00:17:49,753 Who is it? 265 00:17:49,805 --> 00:17:51,408 Where were you? 266 00:17:55,431 --> 00:17:57,275 Sorry. So yeah... 267 00:17:57,327 --> 00:17:59,832 So, I support him and I'm the dead beat? 268 00:18:00,302 --> 00:18:05,002 It's wrong, and I guess I was hoping that you guys can talk some sense into him. 269 00:18:05,631 --> 00:18:07,061 I don't want to... 270 00:18:07,327 --> 00:18:08,923 Missed you tonight. 271 00:18:09,315 --> 00:18:10,645 I don't want to... 272 00:18:10,697 --> 00:18:13,541 Talk for hours and hours on your machine. 273 00:18:13,666 --> 00:18:15,917 But I love you both. 274 00:18:15,946 --> 00:18:19,035 And hope we can talk soon. 275 00:18:21,527 --> 00:18:23,595 Josh's parents won't even pick up the phone. 276 00:18:23,625 --> 00:18:25,216 I'm ranting on their voicemail. 277 00:18:25,238 --> 00:18:28,881 A meeting is like a raffle, you must be present to win. 278 00:18:29,087 --> 00:18:32,155 Are you trying to make me jump out of the window? 279 00:18:33,240 --> 00:18:34,511 Did you eat? 280 00:18:34,637 --> 00:18:37,475 I had a yogurt, made me feel so much better. 281 00:18:38,968 --> 00:18:41,330 One of my other friend... 282 00:18:41,375 --> 00:18:43,251 Made me a lovely batch of soup. 283 00:18:43,288 --> 00:18:45,583 Seriously, did you just come over here to guilt trip me? 284 00:18:45,621 --> 00:18:46,825 No. 285 00:18:47,039 --> 00:18:50,617 No Cate, I came here to enable you. 286 00:18:51,519 --> 00:18:52,620 Okay. 287 00:18:52,702 --> 00:18:56,746 Both Dorrie and Rusty are still guests of the states. 288 00:18:57,391 --> 00:19:00,674 Dorrie won't talk or doesn't want to talk. 289 00:19:00,763 --> 00:19:02,658 But Rusty is willing. 290 00:19:02,753 --> 00:19:04,516 For a small fee. 291 00:19:04,642 --> 00:19:05,934 Rusty's still in jail? 292 00:19:05,970 --> 00:19:07,050 Yes, he is. 293 00:19:07,072 --> 00:19:10,760 Apparently he and the DA are no longer sweethearts. 294 00:19:15,760 --> 00:19:17,797 Lacey and Dorrie don't agree on much. 295 00:19:17,819 --> 00:19:20,927 But they both said that you drove them to the condo. 296 00:19:21,544 --> 00:19:22,854 Yeah. 297 00:19:24,044 --> 00:19:25,418 I dropped them off. 298 00:19:25,454 --> 00:19:27,675 Lacey said when she came out and told you what was going on... 299 00:19:27,800 --> 00:19:30,241 That you ran inside to take care of it. 300 00:19:32,445 --> 00:19:34,108 Lacey's a liar. 301 00:19:34,137 --> 00:19:36,980 Is it a lie that you raped her on your second date? 302 00:19:38,575 --> 00:19:41,536 Is it a lie that you raped her on your second date? 303 00:19:41,580 --> 00:19:43,585 What can I say? The bitch liked it rough. 304 00:19:43,681 --> 00:19:47,529 Did Jen Cole like it rough too, when you sodomized her in the back of your van? 305 00:19:48,148 --> 00:19:49,516 No. 306 00:19:49,935 --> 00:19:51,845 That was a pity fuck. 307 00:19:55,311 --> 00:19:58,067 So what happened to the deal that you cut with the DA? 308 00:19:58,801 --> 00:20:00,101 I don't know. 309 00:20:00,441 --> 00:20:02,139 - Ask them. - I did ask them... 310 00:20:02,161 --> 00:20:05,437 They said they yanked your deal because you lied under oath at Lacey's trial. 311 00:20:05,489 --> 00:20:08,409 About a list of questions that she slipped you when you're both in county. 312 00:20:08,471 --> 00:20:11,074 Questions that you were good enough to answer in writing. 313 00:20:11,104 --> 00:20:14,740 Question, if I cover up that you helped Dorrie killed Jen... 314 00:20:14,754 --> 00:20:18,192 Do you promise to love forever and never beat my face again? 315 00:20:18,207 --> 00:20:20,117 Your written answer, I promise. 316 00:20:20,139 --> 00:20:21,490 She changed the question. 317 00:20:21,512 --> 00:20:24,273 That's what you said under oath, but the DA knew it wasn't true... 318 00:20:24,303 --> 00:20:27,857 Because their own expert found that the handwriting were yours and Lacey's. 319 00:20:27,959 --> 00:20:30,847 With no changes or alterations. 320 00:20:30,868 --> 00:20:33,469 I don't care what the expert said, Lacey's a liar. 321 00:20:33,491 --> 00:20:34,954 She's a liar? 322 00:20:37,407 --> 00:20:38,722 Are we done here? 323 00:20:38,766 --> 00:20:39,721 Yeah, we're done. 324 00:20:40,536 --> 00:20:41,668 Guard! 325 00:20:43,845 --> 00:20:47,307 And the problem is, I can't get the discovery I need to prove we deserve a hearing... 326 00:20:47,356 --> 00:20:49,187 Until after the judge grants one. 327 00:20:49,312 --> 00:20:50,990 What's "discovery"? 328 00:20:51,034 --> 00:20:52,687 Witness statements... 329 00:20:52,724 --> 00:20:56,471 Police reports, evidence, interviews. 330 00:20:57,045 --> 00:21:00,395 So if they found an earring in Jen's condo with blood on it... 331 00:21:00,453 --> 00:21:02,327 They have to give it to you? 332 00:21:02,701 --> 00:21:05,750 The cops found an earring with Jen's blood on it? 333 00:21:07,384 --> 00:21:08,839 Was it yours? 334 00:21:08,964 --> 00:21:10,845 No, it was Rusty's. 335 00:21:11,080 --> 00:21:13,334 They kept it out of evidence. 336 00:21:13,570 --> 00:21:17,779 My lawyer said it wouldn't helped me anyway cause Rusty told them the earring was mine. 337 00:21:18,006 --> 00:21:22,333 Which never made sense to me, cause if the cops really thought they had my earring... 338 00:21:22,364 --> 00:21:24,350 Which includes blood on it... 339 00:21:24,717 --> 00:21:26,282 Why didn't they use it against me? 340 00:21:26,311 --> 00:21:27,928 That's a good question. 341 00:21:29,834 --> 00:21:31,663 So, we got witness tampering... 342 00:21:31,722 --> 00:21:34,315 Suggest... You have to prove it. 343 00:21:34,440 --> 00:21:36,964 - Perjury testimony. - That's your best shot. 344 00:21:37,199 --> 00:21:39,875 And the fact that the DA knew that... 345 00:21:39,949 --> 00:21:43,225 Half of Rusty's testimony was malarkey. 346 00:21:43,240 --> 00:21:45,483 They didn't even bother to go back and inform the court. 347 00:21:45,535 --> 00:21:46,966 That's not nothing. 348 00:21:47,173 --> 00:21:50,178 Let's just hope that this judge... What's his name? 349 00:21:50,229 --> 00:21:52,675 Sumnter, agrees. 350 00:21:52,947 --> 00:21:54,511 Jameson Sumnter? 351 00:21:54,725 --> 00:21:55,739 Yeah. 352 00:21:56,143 --> 00:21:57,540 Friend of yours? 353 00:21:57,746 --> 00:22:01,147 He was one of my law school profs. 354 00:22:01,213 --> 00:22:03,074 Huge victim's rights guy. 355 00:22:03,103 --> 00:22:04,859 That's not good. 356 00:22:05,248 --> 00:22:07,004 Really bad kisser. 357 00:22:10,279 --> 00:22:12,307 He really liked his students. 358 00:22:12,498 --> 00:22:14,595 Particularly the female ones. 359 00:22:18,394 --> 00:22:20,986 Mr. Barker, you ought to be in a good mood this morning. 360 00:22:21,008 --> 00:22:24,645 I'd like to point out to the court my celebratory Cardinal end goal. 361 00:22:24,667 --> 00:22:27,500 By the skin of their teeth, Mr. Barker. 362 00:22:27,999 --> 00:22:30,342 You're a football fan, Miss McCall? 363 00:22:30,409 --> 00:22:32,678 No, Your Honor. 364 00:22:35,440 --> 00:22:36,970 Do I know you? 365 00:22:37,219 --> 00:22:40,981 I was in your victim's rights seminar at UCLA. 366 00:22:41,106 --> 00:22:43,171 Did you learn a few things? 367 00:22:43,465 --> 00:22:44,801 More than a few. 368 00:22:44,839 --> 00:22:45,970 Glad to hear it. 369 00:22:45,992 --> 00:22:47,434 Mr. Barker... 370 00:22:47,559 --> 00:22:51,988 Apparently I was Miss McCall's law professor, do you have a problem with that? 371 00:22:52,296 --> 00:22:53,413 No sir. 372 00:22:53,464 --> 00:22:57,005 Miss McCall, do you have a problem with my sitting on the bench in this case? 373 00:22:57,071 --> 00:22:59,782 As I recall, you passed me, sir. 374 00:23:00,524 --> 00:23:02,466 I'll take that as a no. 375 00:23:04,060 --> 00:23:07,628 Well, Miss McCall... Your petition raises... 376 00:23:07,687 --> 00:23:13,350 Sufficient reasons to wonder at the quality of justice administered in Miss Stubbs' trial... 377 00:23:13,909 --> 00:23:16,326 I'm going to grant your request for unlimited discovery. 378 00:23:16,369 --> 00:23:20,021 Your Honor, I'm concern that without limits the discovery process... 379 00:23:20,050 --> 00:23:21,601 Would become unreasonably burdensome. 380 00:23:21,623 --> 00:23:22,849 Mr. Barker. 381 00:23:23,261 --> 00:23:26,236 Miss McCall can very well get to the bottom of whether or not... 382 00:23:26,257 --> 00:23:30,106 This case was prosecuted in the manner befitting the grade state of California... 383 00:23:30,121 --> 00:23:34,264 Unless she has all the facts and evidence before her. 384 00:23:34,869 --> 00:23:36,000 Can't she? 385 00:23:36,713 --> 00:23:38,594 The hearing is set forth... 386 00:23:38,630 --> 00:23:40,203 November 7th. 387 00:23:41,775 --> 00:23:44,133 Coupons from Dunkin Donuts. 388 00:23:44,859 --> 00:23:46,534 Dry cleaning receipts. 389 00:23:46,659 --> 00:23:49,443 They're trying to bury us under an avalanche of crap. 390 00:23:49,568 --> 00:23:53,723 You want to hear your horoscope for June 16th, 2006? 391 00:23:53,754 --> 00:23:56,103 Phone leads from 7 other cases. 392 00:23:56,139 --> 00:24:01,018 You'll be on a learning curve as your horizon are broaden. 393 00:24:01,268 --> 00:24:03,230 A memo says... 394 00:24:03,355 --> 00:24:07,914 Police took a statement from a neighbor named CeeCee Claymans, day of. 395 00:24:08,848 --> 00:24:09,620 No. 396 00:24:09,641 --> 00:24:11,243 - No? - Don't have it. 397 00:24:11,581 --> 00:24:12,867 When was this? 398 00:24:13,498 --> 00:24:15,636 Before I lost it. 399 00:24:19,146 --> 00:24:20,667 Did you hear what he said? 400 00:24:20,689 --> 00:24:22,276 No, play it again. 401 00:24:23,382 --> 00:24:24,764 Do you recognize this? 402 00:24:24,844 --> 00:24:25,961 Yeah. 403 00:24:26,593 --> 00:24:28,715 It's my earring. I... 404 00:24:28,751 --> 00:24:30,265 - Rusty? - Yup. 405 00:24:30,941 --> 00:24:33,615 Lacey said she loves it, so I gave it to her. 406 00:24:34,191 --> 00:24:36,277 You gave this earring to Lacey? 407 00:24:36,483 --> 00:24:37,791 When was this? 408 00:24:39,150 --> 00:24:40,804 Before I lost it. 409 00:24:43,794 --> 00:24:45,334 They're coaching him. 410 00:24:45,371 --> 00:24:48,280 - But he still can't get it right. - No. 411 00:24:48,758 --> 00:24:51,265 It's unbelievable. 412 00:24:52,617 --> 00:24:55,989 Do you have any idea why the cops might want to protect Rusty? 413 00:24:57,043 --> 00:24:59,232 They hang out sometimes. 414 00:24:59,467 --> 00:25:01,105 They were friends? 415 00:25:01,451 --> 00:25:06,630 Welch and Rusty played poker together a few times, and paintballs. 416 00:25:06,974 --> 00:25:09,024 Maybe it wasn't so much they were... 417 00:25:09,068 --> 00:25:11,977 Protecting Rusty as they were hurting me though. 418 00:25:12,514 --> 00:25:14,276 Why would they want to hurt you? 419 00:25:18,118 --> 00:25:21,962 If your story doesn't make sense, we're gonna lose, do you understand that? 420 00:25:25,220 --> 00:25:27,681 Why would the cops want to hurt you, Lacey? 421 00:25:30,721 --> 00:25:32,058 I don't know. 422 00:25:41,903 --> 00:25:43,783 How about number 48? 423 00:25:44,159 --> 00:25:46,164 Can you make out what that says? 424 00:25:46,483 --> 00:25:48,489 Yes, it looks like "earring". 425 00:25:48,900 --> 00:25:51,758 Any idea what earring that might refer to? 426 00:25:52,016 --> 00:25:56,042 I believe that was a CZ stud... 427 00:25:56,072 --> 00:26:00,304 Belonging to Lacey Stubbs, which we found in the Cole residence. 428 00:26:00,319 --> 00:26:02,802 If I remember correctly, there was blood on it. 429 00:26:02,839 --> 00:26:05,421 Rusty Berkhart has a pierced ear, also. 430 00:26:05,472 --> 00:26:08,242 Is it possible that the earring might have belonged to him? 431 00:26:08,315 --> 00:26:12,633 I questioned him about it, and he stated that he had given it to Miss Stubbs. 432 00:26:13,111 --> 00:26:16,941 If you had Lacey Stubbs' earring with Jen Cole's blood on it... 433 00:26:17,066 --> 00:26:19,747 Why wasn't it admitted into evidence at the trial? 434 00:26:20,147 --> 00:26:21,344 It got lost. 435 00:26:21,380 --> 00:26:22,431 It got lost? 436 00:26:22,490 --> 00:26:24,231 Yeah. That's right. 437 00:26:25,355 --> 00:26:29,484 Detective Welch, prior to Jen Cole's murder... 438 00:26:29,610 --> 00:26:32,014 Did you know Rusty Berkhart socially? 439 00:26:32,360 --> 00:26:33,623 I'd seen him around. 440 00:26:33,637 --> 00:26:35,239 Ever played poker with him? 441 00:26:35,277 --> 00:26:36,960 No, I mean.... Maybe. 442 00:26:36,989 --> 00:26:39,722 Ever played paintball with Mr. Berkhart? 443 00:26:40,125 --> 00:26:41,136 I don't remember. 444 00:26:41,173 --> 00:26:42,326 What about Lacey? 445 00:26:42,334 --> 00:26:43,098 What about her? 446 00:26:43,120 --> 00:26:45,118 Did you ever see her socially? 447 00:26:46,903 --> 00:26:47,498 No. 448 00:26:47,506 --> 00:26:49,819 She wasn't around when you're playing poker with Rusty? 449 00:26:49,850 --> 00:26:50,789 I have no idea. 450 00:26:50,827 --> 00:26:52,587 You think you might remember if she had been? 451 00:26:52,604 --> 00:26:54,735 She's an attractive girl, right? 452 00:26:54,772 --> 00:26:57,636 - Somebody a man might notice. - This is bullshit. 453 00:26:58,706 --> 00:26:59,933 Did you and Lacey ever date? 454 00:26:59,955 --> 00:27:01,138 I'm a married man. 455 00:27:01,153 --> 00:27:02,467 Is that a no? 456 00:27:03,771 --> 00:27:06,151 I don't know what you're trying to do here, but... 457 00:27:06,202 --> 00:27:08,252 I've never done anything with Lacey Stubbs... 458 00:27:08,290 --> 00:27:09,576 I never said that you did. 459 00:27:09,597 --> 00:27:11,126 I just asked if you've dated her. 460 00:27:11,148 --> 00:27:12,610 Okay, for the record... 461 00:27:12,632 --> 00:27:16,879 For the record, I never talked to her, never looked at her, never laid a hand on her. 462 00:27:16,901 --> 00:27:19,876 - Until I arrested her. - Never laid a hand on her. 463 00:27:19,891 --> 00:27:21,456 Fuck, I'm done. 464 00:27:21,500 --> 00:27:24,071 - We need to take a break. - It's okay, it's all I have. 465 00:27:24,108 --> 00:27:26,976 You can tell that fucking cunt, if she wants to talk shit about me again... 466 00:27:26,991 --> 00:27:28,843 She's gonna regret it. 467 00:27:31,763 --> 00:27:35,165 Lacey, I need to know what happened between you and Detective Welch. 468 00:27:35,524 --> 00:27:37,237 I can't. 469 00:27:37,494 --> 00:27:40,073 He said he'd hurt my baby. 470 00:27:43,613 --> 00:27:45,229 I gotta go. 471 00:27:52,318 --> 00:27:53,177 Hello... 472 00:28:07,939 --> 00:28:09,702 Ma'am, you mind coming with me? 473 00:28:09,724 --> 00:28:11,407 I wasn't drunk. 474 00:28:12,244 --> 00:28:13,347 Somebody hit me. 475 00:28:13,368 --> 00:28:14,977 It's just routine. 476 00:28:15,691 --> 00:28:17,549 Take a nice breath please. 477 00:28:20,383 --> 00:28:22,028 I'm so sorry. 478 00:28:22,057 --> 00:28:23,740 I called your cell a million times. 479 00:28:23,769 --> 00:28:25,106 Are you okay? 480 00:28:25,135 --> 00:28:27,267 I'm okay, my car is destroyed. 481 00:28:27,392 --> 00:28:29,516 Somebody tried to run me over the road. 482 00:28:29,919 --> 00:28:32,550 The police had me file a report, then... 483 00:28:32,587 --> 00:28:34,203 Paramedics didn't want me to leave. 484 00:28:34,232 --> 00:28:36,340 Okay, we'll just... 485 00:28:36,407 --> 00:28:37,862 We'll schedule another session. 486 00:28:37,906 --> 00:28:39,851 No, I'm okay. Please, I'm here. 487 00:28:39,889 --> 00:28:42,475 - Can we just... - I'm sorry, I have another appointment. 488 00:28:47,903 --> 00:28:48,998 Sorry... 489 00:29:36,267 --> 00:29:38,163 If I go and tell the judge... 490 00:29:38,288 --> 00:29:40,472 That the cops framed you for murder... 491 00:29:40,634 --> 00:29:42,309 He's gonna want to know why. 492 00:29:50,076 --> 00:29:53,660 I called the cops, wanted him arrested, he beat my face. 493 00:29:54,653 --> 00:29:57,029 He just went ballistic. 494 00:29:59,043 --> 00:30:02,896 I got the police later, the day before my 18th birthday. 495 00:30:03,579 --> 00:30:08,343 Welch and another cop showed up, asking if I want to press charges. 496 00:30:10,370 --> 00:30:13,139 I said no, cause we already made up. 497 00:30:13,601 --> 00:30:18,404 Then Welch started acting all weird, and asked me if I'm alone. 498 00:30:19,551 --> 00:30:24,016 I got a sick feeling, and tried to keep them outside, but... 499 00:30:24,075 --> 00:30:26,125 They were both on me. 500 00:30:26,250 --> 00:30:28,167 And I could see Rusty... 501 00:30:28,203 --> 00:30:31,325 Staring on me from the yard. 502 00:30:35,008 --> 00:30:39,057 They held me down, and Welch punched me in my face. 503 00:30:39,564 --> 00:30:42,655 He said, he heard I liked it rough. 504 00:30:42,780 --> 00:30:46,703 Cause Rusty told them, that's why he did it. 505 00:30:46,755 --> 00:30:49,451 They took turned. 506 00:30:52,270 --> 00:30:53,401 Why didn't she report? 507 00:30:53,423 --> 00:30:55,297 Who's she gonna report it to? 508 00:30:55,392 --> 00:30:57,215 Her boyfriend rapes her... 509 00:30:57,340 --> 00:31:00,759 The cops rape her, she goes to jail and the guards rape her. 510 00:31:00,973 --> 00:31:02,953 It's amazing she's as intact as she is. 511 00:31:03,011 --> 00:31:04,627 Intact for a murderer. 512 00:31:04,671 --> 00:31:05,935 I don't think she did it. 513 00:31:05,965 --> 00:31:07,111 Really? 514 00:31:07,140 --> 00:31:09,066 Cops needed a guilty party. 515 00:31:09,103 --> 00:31:11,732 They're afraid Lacey will nail them on the rape, and she gets the death penalty... 516 00:31:11,769 --> 00:31:13,811 They kill two birds with one stone. 517 00:31:13,937 --> 00:31:16,782 The DA isn't gonna play along with this. 518 00:31:16,819 --> 00:31:18,207 They didn't know. 519 00:31:18,244 --> 00:31:21,544 They rely on what the cops gave them, the cops fed them Lacey. 520 00:31:21,596 --> 00:31:23,903 It's fucking Deja vu. 521 00:31:57,718 --> 00:31:59,893 We're all waiting, Miss McCall. 522 00:32:00,459 --> 00:32:01,789 Of course. 523 00:32:17,309 --> 00:32:21,519 Lacey Stubbs maybe guilty in having bad taste in boyfriends. 524 00:32:21,612 --> 00:32:23,864 Of being naive. 525 00:32:24,522 --> 00:32:28,914 Of standing by an abusive man and lying to protect them. 526 00:32:30,035 --> 00:32:33,480 But she's not guilty in murdering Jennifer Cole. 527 00:32:34,343 --> 00:32:37,095 When I first took this case, I believed she was guilty. 528 00:32:37,352 --> 00:32:39,419 I'd read the news reports... 529 00:32:39,666 --> 00:32:42,762 She looked like a bad girl, straight out of the tabloids. 530 00:32:42,887 --> 00:32:45,836 But that's not the real Lacey Stubbs. 531 00:32:51,341 --> 00:32:52,761 This is. 532 00:32:53,615 --> 00:32:56,995 This photo was taken two months before Lacey started dating the real killer... 533 00:32:57,120 --> 00:32:58,958 Rusty Berkhart. 534 00:32:59,369 --> 00:33:02,053 Rusty transformed Lacey to his taste. 535 00:33:02,094 --> 00:33:06,654 Attempting to change a girl next door to a dangerous femme fatale. 536 00:33:07,128 --> 00:33:09,528 He didn't actually succeed. 537 00:33:11,256 --> 00:33:15,893 Lacey Stubb is not the dangerous person in this court today. 538 00:33:17,847 --> 00:33:19,205 They are. 539 00:33:24,428 --> 00:33:25,518 Quiet. 540 00:33:26,090 --> 00:33:28,811 It sounds outrageous, doesn't it? 541 00:33:29,396 --> 00:33:32,578 But Lacey's in prison not because she's actually guilty. 542 00:33:32,703 --> 00:33:35,706 But because DA Brinkerhoff and the Hawthorne County PD... 543 00:33:35,751 --> 00:33:40,210 Decided she was guilty and set about fabricating a case against her. 544 00:33:40,855 --> 00:33:42,776 They withheld evidence. 545 00:33:43,638 --> 00:33:45,907 They suppress witness statements. 546 00:33:46,352 --> 00:33:49,215 They coerced the defense witness to change key testimony... 547 00:33:49,251 --> 00:33:52,482 And then they invited the real killer, Rusty Berkhart, to take the stand... 548 00:33:52,525 --> 00:33:54,579 And claimed that Lacey had confessed. 549 00:33:54,639 --> 00:33:55,889 To him. 550 00:33:59,552 --> 00:34:03,095 Police and prosecutors considered Lacey Stubb trash. 551 00:34:03,496 --> 00:34:07,005 And they threw her life away without so much as a backward glance. 552 00:34:08,282 --> 00:34:09,934 If it can happen to her... 553 00:34:10,350 --> 00:34:12,560 It can happen to anyone of us. 554 00:34:13,523 --> 00:34:15,132 It can happen to me. 555 00:34:16,037 --> 00:34:17,468 It can happen to you. 556 00:34:33,072 --> 00:34:35,637 Guess you can't keep a good woman down. 557 00:34:36,816 --> 00:34:38,328 Walk away. 558 00:34:38,633 --> 00:34:40,480 It's gonna get ugly. 559 00:34:40,605 --> 00:34:42,229 What's the matter, Brinkerhoff? 560 00:34:42,354 --> 00:34:44,914 Afraid I'm gonna air your dirty laundry? 561 00:34:45,039 --> 00:34:48,377 If you air mine, I'll be force to air yours. 562 00:34:48,502 --> 00:34:51,291 And we both know you got a shitload. 563 00:35:12,489 --> 00:35:13,810 Hello? 564 00:35:14,106 --> 00:35:17,554 Well, the good news is you're very photogenic. 565 00:35:18,058 --> 00:35:19,365 What? 566 00:35:19,832 --> 00:35:22,427 You might want to look at the papers. 567 00:35:28,508 --> 00:35:31,266 Motherfucker. 568 00:35:33,448 --> 00:35:34,961 So now you know. 569 00:35:35,174 --> 00:35:36,758 I'm not perfect. 570 00:35:36,772 --> 00:35:39,393 I've made mistakes just like you, big ones. 571 00:35:39,993 --> 00:35:41,939 If you want to get a new lawyer, that's your prerogative. 572 00:35:41,974 --> 00:35:45,270 But I am fucking good at what I do, and I intend to win this. 573 00:35:45,395 --> 00:35:46,940 Not just because it's important to me. 574 00:35:46,961 --> 00:35:48,645 But because I think you're innocent. 575 00:35:48,751 --> 00:35:50,598 And I think you got a raw deal. 576 00:35:50,647 --> 00:35:53,302 But you said it didn't matter if I was innocent. 577 00:35:54,176 --> 00:35:55,533 It matters to me. 578 00:35:56,844 --> 00:35:58,521 Dr. Miranchandi... 579 00:35:58,784 --> 00:36:00,907 Once the carotid has severed... 580 00:36:01,134 --> 00:36:03,345 How long can a person remain conscious? 581 00:36:03,470 --> 00:36:05,503 Without medical intervention... 582 00:36:05,596 --> 00:36:07,094 Typically in matter of minutes. 583 00:36:07,172 --> 00:36:09,496 So, unless Hazel Cole arrived home within minutes... 584 00:36:09,621 --> 00:36:11,648 Of her daughter being attacked... 585 00:36:11,675 --> 00:36:14,560 She couldn't possibly have heard her saying anything, is that correct? 586 00:36:14,617 --> 00:36:15,910 That's correct. 587 00:36:16,237 --> 00:36:20,615 A car with a kind of patchwork paint job came toward me. 588 00:36:20,651 --> 00:36:23,108 Swerving over into my lane. 589 00:36:23,832 --> 00:36:25,481 Looked like he was drunk. 590 00:36:25,580 --> 00:36:27,527 The driver was a man, Miss Claymans? 591 00:36:27,548 --> 00:36:28,912 Yes, he was. 592 00:36:28,983 --> 00:36:30,693 Should I say who he was? 593 00:36:30,721 --> 00:36:32,028 If you know. 594 00:36:32,184 --> 00:36:33,988 It was Rusty Berkhart. 595 00:36:34,066 --> 00:36:36,100 And you told all this to the detectives? 596 00:36:36,130 --> 00:36:37,606 I sure did. 597 00:36:37,628 --> 00:36:41,556 They asked me if I'd be willing to come to court to testify, I said I would... 598 00:36:41,627 --> 00:36:43,459 But they never called me. 599 00:36:43,772 --> 00:36:47,487 Are you aware of Miss Stubbs' claim that she threw a pink garbage bag... 600 00:36:47,543 --> 00:36:50,392 Containing a butcher knife with Rusty Berkhart's fingerprints on it... 601 00:36:50,398 --> 00:36:51,976 Into Dehunger River? 602 00:36:52,075 --> 00:36:55,711 I can't say that I actually heard her saying that now. 603 00:36:55,753 --> 00:36:59,502 I'm reading from Lacey's January 26th statement. 604 00:37:00,084 --> 00:37:02,521 I put the knife into a pink trash bag. 605 00:37:02,563 --> 00:37:06,574 I drove over to Stoneyville bridge and threw it in. 606 00:37:07,753 --> 00:37:09,210 Is that a question? 607 00:37:10,819 --> 00:37:12,901 Did police search the Dehunger River? 608 00:37:13,143 --> 00:37:15,502 I believe so, no bag was found. 609 00:37:15,531 --> 00:37:17,619 And did you participate in that search? 610 00:37:17,634 --> 00:37:19,111 No, I did not. 611 00:37:20,794 --> 00:37:21,873 You didn't? 612 00:37:21,915 --> 00:37:23,521 No, I did not. 613 00:37:24,074 --> 00:37:26,732 This is the tape of the search the police gave to the defense. 614 00:37:26,754 --> 00:37:28,870 Just before Miss Stubbs' trial. 615 00:37:29,254 --> 00:37:30,803 Have you ever seen this tape before? 616 00:37:30,832 --> 00:37:32,202 I'm aware of it. 617 00:37:32,828 --> 00:37:34,796 No pink bag was found. 618 00:37:35,599 --> 00:37:37,623 The police were searching for a pink bag... 619 00:37:37,666 --> 00:37:39,691 Because Lacey have told detectives... 620 00:37:39,719 --> 00:37:42,964 That she had put the murder weapon with Rusty Berkhart's fingerprints on it... 621 00:37:43,000 --> 00:37:44,583 Into a pink trash bag. 622 00:37:44,619 --> 00:37:47,519 And thrown it into the Dehunger River, correct? 623 00:37:47,568 --> 00:37:49,301 But we never found it. 624 00:37:53,293 --> 00:37:54,780 Here's another tape. 625 00:37:54,905 --> 00:37:58,246 This was wasn't shown at my client's trial, 5 years ago. 626 00:37:58,294 --> 00:38:01,276 It contains the exact same footage of the lake search. 627 00:38:01,353 --> 00:38:04,741 Only this one happens to be a minute longer. 628 00:38:04,866 --> 00:38:07,072 Any idea what that might be? 629 00:38:07,100 --> 00:38:08,203 No ma'am. 630 00:38:08,270 --> 00:38:10,927 But you're certain you didn't Participate in the search? 631 00:38:10,966 --> 00:38:12,309 That is correct. 632 00:38:15,691 --> 00:38:18,711 So, Detective Duncan... 633 00:38:20,851 --> 00:38:22,637 That's not you? 634 00:38:24,639 --> 00:38:26,005 That looks like me. 635 00:38:26,073 --> 00:38:28,235 Because it is you, isn't it? 636 00:38:30,290 --> 00:38:33,115 What do you think that might be, Detective? 637 00:38:33,518 --> 00:38:35,457 Looks like something caught in the branch. 638 00:38:35,497 --> 00:38:37,257 A pink bag, maybe? 639 00:38:37,324 --> 00:38:39,371 Oh there you are again. 640 00:38:40,445 --> 00:38:42,988 Would it surprise you to learn that the footage of the pink bag... 641 00:38:43,025 --> 00:38:45,265 And the footage of you waving at the cameraman... 642 00:38:45,302 --> 00:38:50,307 To stop filming were not on the tape given to Lacey Stubbs' counsel before the trial? 643 00:38:50,562 --> 00:38:52,412 I just want to say.... 644 00:38:52,699 --> 00:38:54,173 After seeing this tape.... 645 00:38:54,219 --> 00:38:56,031 My memory is refreshed. 646 00:38:56,156 --> 00:38:59,910 That bag has just.... I think.... 647 00:39:00,190 --> 00:39:01,608 Diapers or something. 648 00:39:01,699 --> 00:39:03,488 So, now you remember the bag? 649 00:39:04,296 --> 00:39:05,388 You just showed it. 650 00:39:05,449 --> 00:39:07,254 Which is why you remember it, right? 651 00:39:07,291 --> 00:39:10,184 Because, your memory was refreshed. 652 00:39:11,207 --> 00:39:14,178 Are you certain that the bag contains diapers and not... 653 00:39:14,217 --> 00:39:16,906 A butcher knife with Rusty Berkhart's fingerprints on it? 654 00:39:16,959 --> 00:39:18,150 I'm certain. 655 00:39:18,484 --> 00:39:20,189 As certain as you were... 656 00:39:20,318 --> 00:39:22,351 That you did not participate in this search. 657 00:39:32,835 --> 00:39:35,193 - Thank you. - You're welcome. 658 00:40:02,340 --> 00:40:05,054 And if the lion comes... 659 00:40:05,145 --> 00:40:09,172 Daddy roars at the lion. 660 00:40:09,430 --> 00:40:13,656 And chase it all the way back to the jungle. 661 00:40:15,663 --> 00:40:19,650 And if the panda comes... 662 00:40:19,893 --> 00:40:22,628 Daddy would... 663 00:40:22,753 --> 00:40:27,896 At the panda, and chase it all the way back to the jungle. 664 00:40:28,021 --> 00:40:29,905 And if the bear comes... 665 00:40:29,928 --> 00:40:32,054 Mommy will grab that bear... 666 00:40:32,084 --> 00:40:33,577 No. 667 00:40:34,555 --> 00:40:36,444 Mommy can't play? 668 00:40:36,663 --> 00:40:39,083 This is daddy game. 669 00:40:43,521 --> 00:40:47,569 This is a photocopy of Hazel Cole's Statement dated December 27th. 670 00:40:47,918 --> 00:40:50,074 The one that you took, is that correct? 671 00:40:51,310 --> 00:40:52,493 Yes. 672 00:40:52,918 --> 00:40:56,966 Do you see any mention of Hazel Cole saying she heard her daughter said Lacey did it? 673 00:40:57,020 --> 00:40:59,120 I remember her saying it. 674 00:40:59,158 --> 00:41:00,737 But is it in the statement? 675 00:41:00,813 --> 00:41:03,337 It's probably in a later statement. 676 00:41:04,361 --> 00:41:08,958 Here's another statement that you took, 3 weeks later on January 25th. 677 00:41:09,572 --> 00:41:11,187 Is it mentioned here? 678 00:41:13,908 --> 00:41:15,023 No. 679 00:41:15,242 --> 00:41:17,513 If Hazel Cole have mentioned it... 680 00:41:17,543 --> 00:41:21,205 As she held her dying daughter in her arms, she had heard the words... 681 00:41:21,289 --> 00:41:22,556 Lacey did it... 682 00:41:22,594 --> 00:41:25,088 Is that something that you would typically include in your report? 683 00:41:25,126 --> 00:41:27,714 She probably mentioned it at a future time. 684 00:41:27,744 --> 00:41:31,834 You mean after you suggested that it may Help you made a case against Lacey Stubbs. 685 00:41:31,901 --> 00:41:33,534 - Objection. - Sustained. 686 00:41:33,694 --> 00:41:35,581 Do you remember Hazel Cole calling you... 687 00:41:35,623 --> 00:41:38,958 To say that she found an earring, several weeks after the murder? 688 00:41:39,019 --> 00:41:40,465 Yes, I do. 689 00:41:40,541 --> 00:41:43,543 And do you remember Rusty Berkhart saying the earring was his? 690 00:41:44,203 --> 00:41:46,082 No, I don't remember that. 691 00:41:46,120 --> 00:41:49,130 Your Honor, defense exhibit number 17. 692 00:41:51,519 --> 00:41:52,982 You recognize this? 693 00:41:53,028 --> 00:41:53,809 Yeah. 694 00:41:53,846 --> 00:41:54,900 What is it? 695 00:41:54,931 --> 00:41:56,313 It's my earring. 696 00:41:56,351 --> 00:41:57,973 Okay... 697 00:41:59,854 --> 00:42:03,012 Detective Welch, do you recognize the two voices on that tape? 698 00:42:03,049 --> 00:42:04,952 Yes, I do. It's me and Rusty Berkhart. 699 00:42:04,982 --> 00:42:07,407 And who did Rusty said the earring belong to? 700 00:42:07,453 --> 00:42:11,663 - If you play the tape further on, he changes it... - I'm not talking about after you coached him. 701 00:42:12,307 --> 00:42:15,708 I'm asking you right there, when you first asked the question. 702 00:42:16,063 --> 00:42:19,477 Did Rusty Berkhart say the earring was his? Yes or no? 703 00:42:22,411 --> 00:42:23,730 Yes. 704 00:42:39,790 --> 00:42:42,416 He held his gun to my throat... 705 00:42:42,810 --> 00:42:45,455 Then he moved it down between my legs... 706 00:42:45,494 --> 00:42:48,044 Then he pushed it inside of me. 707 00:42:49,242 --> 00:42:51,797 I could feel the cold steel in me. 708 00:42:51,813 --> 00:42:54,469 While he moved it, in and out. 709 00:42:55,561 --> 00:42:59,373 Can you remember anything about the gun? What it looked like? 710 00:42:59,941 --> 00:43:02,558 It had letters engraved in the handle. 711 00:43:02,595 --> 00:43:04,570 Could you read what they were? 712 00:43:04,616 --> 00:43:06,663 It said RAW. 713 00:43:07,701 --> 00:43:11,018 Lacey, did you know either of the men who raped you? 714 00:43:11,641 --> 00:43:15,040 One of them was friends with Rusty, Robert Welch. 715 00:43:15,093 --> 00:43:17,315 And what happened then? 716 00:43:18,444 --> 00:43:21,633 He got off of me, and said if I opened my mouth... 717 00:43:21,758 --> 00:43:25,197 They would come back and do the same thing to my kid. 718 00:43:25,781 --> 00:43:30,178 Did you ever see Detective Robert Welch Again after the rape? 719 00:43:31,184 --> 00:43:33,852 He was the one who arrested me. 720 00:43:34,141 --> 00:43:35,794 Thank you. 721 00:43:37,802 --> 00:43:41,000 Mr. Davies, please ask our friends in the Sheriff Office... 722 00:43:41,125 --> 00:43:43,279 To locate Detective Welch. 723 00:43:43,404 --> 00:43:45,649 And invite him back into my court room. 724 00:43:45,694 --> 00:43:48,052 I want to warn the prosecution. 725 00:43:48,082 --> 00:43:52,270 I don't want anyone to discuss with Mr. Welch... 726 00:43:52,513 --> 00:43:54,222 What was just brought up in here. 727 00:43:54,259 --> 00:43:56,079 - Call him. - I'm on it. 728 00:43:56,109 --> 00:43:58,372 Is there a problem, Mr. Barker? 729 00:43:59,904 --> 00:44:04,515 Your Honor, my associate maybe on the phone with Detective Welch right now. 730 00:44:04,538 --> 00:44:05,337 What? 731 00:44:05,360 --> 00:44:07,817 I asked him to call as soon as the rape allegation... 732 00:44:07,840 --> 00:44:08,786 What, a minute ago? 733 00:44:08,825 --> 00:44:10,648 Obviously, this whole thing is coming as a... 734 00:44:10,685 --> 00:44:14,226 God help you if someone coached this witness. 735 00:44:14,852 --> 00:44:16,482 Do you hear me, Mr. Barker? 736 00:44:16,497 --> 00:44:18,210 God help you. 737 00:44:18,642 --> 00:44:21,791 I have an incident report here dated November 29th, 2007. 738 00:44:21,837 --> 00:44:24,782 Would you please take a look at it, to refresh your memory? 739 00:44:28,026 --> 00:44:29,613 According to that report... 740 00:44:29,644 --> 00:44:32,450 Lacey Stubbs met you at the door with a bloody face, saying... 741 00:44:32,473 --> 00:44:35,577 Rusty has a butcher knife, I'm afraid he's trying to kill me. 742 00:44:35,614 --> 00:44:36,979 Is that correct? 743 00:44:37,335 --> 00:44:38,630 Yes. 744 00:44:39,274 --> 00:44:41,381 And do you recall coming back to the same trailer... 745 00:44:41,404 --> 00:44:43,429 Three weeks later on November 29th? 746 00:44:43,437 --> 00:44:46,326 To see if Miss Stubbs was intending to press charges? 747 00:44:46,895 --> 00:44:48,032 No, I do not. 748 00:44:48,062 --> 00:44:51,301 - You don't remember that? - No, it never happened. 749 00:44:51,324 --> 00:44:54,124 You don't remember pushing your way into the trailer? 750 00:44:54,147 --> 00:44:55,402 And forcing Lacey Stubbs... 751 00:44:55,428 --> 00:44:57,430 - to have Anal sex with you? - Objection. 752 00:44:57,460 --> 00:44:58,445 Sustained. 753 00:44:58,468 --> 00:45:01,478 Where were you, Saturday November 29th, 2007? 754 00:45:01,531 --> 00:45:02,783 I have no idea. 755 00:45:02,828 --> 00:45:05,201 But you're sure you weren't Raping Lacey Stubbs? 756 00:45:05,247 --> 00:45:06,861 - Objection. - Sustained. 757 00:45:06,884 --> 00:45:08,518 Dead sure. 758 00:45:14,848 --> 00:45:16,258 Do you carry a gun? 759 00:45:16,297 --> 00:45:18,441 Yes, I do. Always. 760 00:45:18,692 --> 00:45:20,192 May I see it? 761 00:45:34,032 --> 00:45:36,064 Is it engraved in any way? 762 00:45:39,418 --> 00:45:41,480 Yes, with my initials. 763 00:45:41,693 --> 00:45:43,648 RAW. 764 00:45:44,869 --> 00:45:45,830 Damnit. 765 00:45:45,879 --> 00:45:48,693 It's okay, you sucked. That's fine. 766 00:45:51,385 --> 00:45:53,138 How do you like that? 767 00:45:53,147 --> 00:45:56,350 Prosecutor wants to negotiate on Simms. 768 00:45:56,361 --> 00:45:58,268 You can't leave, I'm about to annihilate you. 769 00:45:58,314 --> 00:46:02,517 The wheels are just turning, my dear, climbing down the innocent. 770 00:46:02,554 --> 00:46:03,834 What about my closing statement? 771 00:46:03,863 --> 00:46:06,622 Practice in the mirror till I get back. 772 00:46:19,022 --> 00:46:21,139 The prosecution's case against my client... 773 00:46:21,177 --> 00:46:24,172 Demands that you believe 2 incredible things. 774 00:46:24,297 --> 00:46:27,529 The testimony of a known perjurer and probable killer... 775 00:46:27,568 --> 00:46:29,661 Who says that Lacey Stubbs confessed to him... 776 00:46:29,682 --> 00:46:32,760 And the dubious claims of Hazel Cole... 777 00:46:32,885 --> 00:46:35,997 Who said she heard her daughter say Lacey did it. 778 00:46:36,020 --> 00:46:36,910 Excuse me. 779 00:46:36,941 --> 00:46:39,176 Is that a problem, Mr. Barker? 780 00:46:39,510 --> 00:46:41,560 I'm sorry, Your Honor. 781 00:46:42,492 --> 00:46:45,474 Miss Cole would like a chance to address the court... 782 00:46:45,505 --> 00:46:48,256 During my closing statement? This is highly improper... 783 00:46:48,272 --> 00:46:50,317 I saw Rusty driving passed me... 784 00:46:50,363 --> 00:46:53,053 When I was coming home that morning too, just before I found Jen. 785 00:46:53,091 --> 00:46:54,843 The court should not be considering this. 786 00:46:54,869 --> 00:46:56,600 - All the testimony is in... - Miss McCall. 787 00:46:56,600 --> 00:47:00,402 If this person has information that's Relevant to what actually happened.... 788 00:47:00,440 --> 00:47:01,850 I want to hear it. 789 00:47:02,063 --> 00:47:03,947 Approach the bench. 790 00:47:11,072 --> 00:47:14,871 Are you telling us, Mrs. Cole, that after all this time... 791 00:47:14,997 --> 00:47:16,658 You're only just now remembering... 792 00:47:16,783 --> 00:47:19,965 What happened on the morning your daughter was killed? 793 00:47:20,090 --> 00:47:21,728 No... 794 00:47:21,751 --> 00:47:24,116 I told Detectives at the time... 795 00:47:24,238 --> 00:47:26,184 And they told me I shouldn't dwell on it. 796 00:47:26,230 --> 00:47:29,148 Detectives told you that you shouldn't dwell on it? 797 00:47:29,178 --> 00:47:30,346 Yes sir. 798 00:47:30,471 --> 00:47:34,178 And I guess I put it out of my mind and... 799 00:47:34,572 --> 00:47:37,794 When that neighbor lady said she saw him too... 800 00:47:38,925 --> 00:47:42,268 I'm Christian, I try always to tell the truth and I... 801 00:47:42,335 --> 00:47:45,034 I just felt I should tell you. 802 00:47:45,110 --> 00:47:47,249 I commend you for your honesty. 803 00:47:47,583 --> 00:47:51,511 Something's that in short supply in my court room as of late. 804 00:47:51,852 --> 00:47:56,265 At this point, Mr. Barker, given everything that we've heard... 805 00:47:56,318 --> 00:47:58,515 Wouldn't you say it's time to discuss some relief? 806 00:47:58,568 --> 00:48:00,789 Your Honor, please. I just need a few moments... 807 00:48:00,819 --> 00:48:03,436 We have had police detectives lying under oath. 808 00:48:03,473 --> 00:48:06,335 Altering tapes, suppressing evidence. 809 00:48:06,950 --> 00:48:09,330 And now, we have the victim's own mother. 810 00:48:09,369 --> 00:48:11,322 With no reason to lie. 811 00:48:11,344 --> 00:48:13,610 Telling us she saw Mr. Berkhart... 812 00:48:13,633 --> 00:48:15,804 Fleeing the scene of the crime. 813 00:48:16,426 --> 00:48:17,699 I repeat. 814 00:48:17,768 --> 00:48:19,784 At this point, Mr. Barker. 815 00:48:19,852 --> 00:48:24,095 Don't you think Miss Stubbs is in title of some relief? 816 00:48:26,574 --> 00:48:29,342 I can see how the woman is, yes. 817 00:48:30,585 --> 00:48:32,634 You can make your decision over the weekend. 818 00:48:32,655 --> 00:48:34,595 Whether you want to put on your own witnesses... 819 00:48:34,720 --> 00:48:36,950 And defense this case, or not. 820 00:48:37,076 --> 00:48:42,103 In the meantime, I'm going to release Miss Stubbs into some agreed upon custody. 821 00:48:42,577 --> 00:48:45,261 He's letting her go. Don't you see? 822 00:48:45,359 --> 00:48:47,682 If I saw them, it means I got there within minutes... 823 00:48:47,727 --> 00:48:50,274 It means I could have gotten there when Jen could still speak. 824 00:48:50,304 --> 00:48:54,194 No, Mrs. Cole. If you saw Mr. Berkhart leaving the crime scene. 825 00:48:54,217 --> 00:48:58,722 And told detectives, it means they Withheld exculpatory evidence. 826 00:48:58,847 --> 00:48:59,895 Thank you. 827 00:49:00,020 --> 00:49:02,031 You may sit down. 828 00:49:02,872 --> 00:49:04,388 Let's go. 829 00:49:04,600 --> 00:49:06,238 Mrs. McCall. 830 00:49:06,367 --> 00:49:07,845 Yes, Your Honor. 831 00:49:07,875 --> 00:49:10,112 You're the obvious choice for custody. 832 00:49:10,157 --> 00:49:12,808 I have... 833 00:49:12,838 --> 00:49:14,521 I have plans to see my daughter. 834 00:49:14,559 --> 00:49:16,531 I'm sure you'll work something out. 835 00:49:26,736 --> 00:49:28,730 Welcome to my perfect life. 836 00:49:30,506 --> 00:49:32,727 Because I want to see her. 837 00:49:34,578 --> 00:49:36,727 I don't have a car. 838 00:49:39,070 --> 00:49:41,322 Just forget it. 839 00:49:43,880 --> 00:49:45,632 Are you okay? 840 00:49:48,455 --> 00:49:51,226 I'm out for one weekend and... 841 00:49:51,240 --> 00:49:53,484 My parents won't bring her to see me. 842 00:50:10,501 --> 00:50:13,489 She's so big, I don't even recognize her. 843 00:50:13,614 --> 00:50:15,414 I miss you. 844 00:50:17,772 --> 00:50:20,296 They really gonna let her go? 845 00:50:20,422 --> 00:50:21,971 We'll know on Monday. 846 00:50:21,994 --> 00:50:26,520 But, it looks like things could finally go Lacey's way. 847 00:50:28,917 --> 00:50:31,760 Things always go Lacey's way. 848 00:50:31,851 --> 00:50:34,292 She makes sure of it. 849 00:50:41,104 --> 00:50:42,653 Yeah. 850 00:50:44,693 --> 00:50:46,376 I can't really talk right now. 851 00:50:56,580 --> 00:50:59,943 You just got through telling us you didn't intend to defense this case. 852 00:50:59,966 --> 00:51:01,554 But to claim that she's innocent... 853 00:51:01,679 --> 00:51:03,711 I have never seen a case, in any jurisdiction... 854 00:51:03,836 --> 00:51:06,851 Where there has been as much prosecutorial misconduct. 855 00:51:06,897 --> 00:51:07,906 But my point... 856 00:51:07,928 --> 00:51:12,628 By my count, at least 5 state witnesses perjured themselves. 857 00:51:12,725 --> 00:51:14,731 We have obstruction of justice. 858 00:51:14,754 --> 00:51:17,838 Witness tampering, evidence disappearing. 859 00:51:17,899 --> 00:51:20,189 There is a human being sitting here. 860 00:51:20,219 --> 00:51:21,556 Serving a life sentence. 861 00:51:21,601 --> 00:51:25,301 Based on testimony that your office has seen disavowed. 862 00:51:25,370 --> 00:51:28,158 I find by clear and compelling evidence... 863 00:51:28,181 --> 00:51:32,362 Lacey Stubbs to be actually innocent of first degree murder. 864 00:51:32,431 --> 00:51:34,933 So she shall be immediately released. 865 00:51:34,963 --> 00:51:37,111 And I'm going to add... 866 00:51:37,414 --> 00:51:41,345 She can never be tried in this state again. 867 00:51:41,892 --> 00:51:43,203 No! 868 00:51:43,234 --> 00:51:45,420 Holy shit, we did it. 869 00:51:45,481 --> 00:51:47,384 Great, Cate. 870 00:51:47,793 --> 00:51:49,593 Congratulations. 871 00:51:49,616 --> 00:51:51,595 See you outside. 872 00:51:51,720 --> 00:51:53,463 Thank you. 873 00:52:04,481 --> 00:52:07,581 Ice cream has too much sugar. 874 00:52:08,044 --> 00:52:10,098 Today we're celebrating. 875 00:52:10,925 --> 00:52:11,974 Why? 876 00:52:12,019 --> 00:52:17,417 Because your momma helped a lady out of a real bad situation. 877 00:52:17,447 --> 00:52:20,556 My daddy says she did bad things. 878 00:52:21,579 --> 00:52:24,435 People thought she did bad things. 879 00:52:24,488 --> 00:52:27,658 Because mean people told lies about her. 880 00:52:27,710 --> 00:52:30,940 So your mommy went to court and told the truth. 881 00:52:31,030 --> 00:52:33,487 She made the mean people played fair. 882 00:52:33,556 --> 00:52:35,571 You made the mean people played fair? 883 00:52:35,609 --> 00:52:36,875 Yeah, baby. 884 00:52:36,913 --> 00:52:40,930 Wow, I always knew you're good babe, but you tore them up in there. 885 00:52:40,967 --> 00:52:42,886 - How are you, George? - Good. 886 00:52:43,220 --> 00:52:45,509 Looks like one of us is going back to trial. 887 00:52:45,723 --> 00:52:47,110 I need you back on the team. 888 00:52:47,156 --> 00:52:49,226 I'm not sure the other partners... 889 00:52:49,249 --> 00:52:51,405 Everybody deserves a second chance. 890 00:52:51,451 --> 00:52:54,817 Even the stone cold killer like Lacey Stubbs. 891 00:52:55,787 --> 00:52:57,379 How are you doing, buddy? 892 00:52:57,504 --> 00:52:59,289 I'm fine, buddy. 893 00:52:59,501 --> 00:53:01,010 Call me. 894 00:53:03,117 --> 00:53:05,034 Wow, babe... 895 00:53:05,064 --> 00:53:09,323 If you pay me a half a million bucks, you can call me babe too, babe. 896 00:53:09,448 --> 00:53:12,704 Here's half a million dollars, babe. 897 00:53:14,442 --> 00:53:16,451 Don't encourage him. 898 00:53:17,345 --> 00:53:18,824 Can I brush his teeth? 899 00:53:18,863 --> 00:53:20,602 - Not yet. - He ate so much ice cream. 900 00:53:20,632 --> 00:53:21,928 Sshh... 901 00:53:22,053 --> 00:53:25,165 He's not the one that had ice cream. 902 00:53:26,812 --> 00:53:28,263 He had ice cream. 903 00:53:28,388 --> 00:53:29,658 Okay. 904 00:53:31,402 --> 00:53:33,461 I gotta go now, sweetie pie. 905 00:53:33,856 --> 00:53:36,236 I'm gonna give you the tiny little momma. 906 00:53:37,472 --> 00:53:38,730 Here. 907 00:53:40,376 --> 00:53:43,082 Take good care of it while I'm gone. 908 00:53:53,853 --> 00:53:55,081 Hey. 909 00:53:57,355 --> 00:53:58,727 Stop. 910 00:53:59,236 --> 00:54:01,707 I need to talk to you about Lacey Stubbs. 911 00:54:01,730 --> 00:54:04,104 I am not interested in defending myself or the case. 912 00:54:04,119 --> 00:54:06,490 My daughter is Dorrie Booth. 913 00:54:07,976 --> 00:54:10,573 Do you think that there's any chance that the... 914 00:54:10,698 --> 00:54:12,933 New evidence you dug up might help her too? 915 00:54:13,058 --> 00:54:15,017 I don't actually do criminal defense. 916 00:54:15,054 --> 00:54:18,170 My daughter didn't kill anybody. 917 00:54:18,549 --> 00:54:21,930 But they put her in prison for the rest of her natural life. 918 00:54:23,128 --> 00:54:25,230 What if it was your daughter? 919 00:54:27,269 --> 00:54:30,979 So, the cops basically came up with a story that they wanted people to believe. 920 00:54:31,002 --> 00:54:32,951 And they sold it to the DA. 921 00:54:33,076 --> 00:54:35,363 And the DA sold it to the jury. 922 00:54:35,488 --> 00:54:37,054 And the jury bought it. 923 00:54:37,115 --> 00:54:38,398 Hook and sinker. 924 00:54:38,512 --> 00:54:40,354 Isn't that what you did? 925 00:54:42,992 --> 00:54:46,606 I was under the impression that you wanted to discuss an appeal? 926 00:54:46,732 --> 00:54:47,805 Why? 927 00:54:47,850 --> 00:54:49,006 Because... 928 00:54:49,029 --> 00:54:51,326 I'm gonna lie to save myself. 929 00:54:51,818 --> 00:54:53,729 I did what they said I did. 930 00:54:54,033 --> 00:54:55,359 I held her down. 931 00:54:55,484 --> 00:54:57,643 While Lacey cut her throat. 932 00:54:58,157 --> 00:55:00,888 - Lacey said that Rusty... - Rusty wasn't there. 933 00:55:01,169 --> 00:55:03,366 He'd dropped us off and he picked us up. 934 00:55:03,381 --> 00:55:05,299 But he was never in the condo. 935 00:55:05,329 --> 00:55:07,010 So Lacey can lie... 936 00:55:07,135 --> 00:55:08,725 And say all kinds of things. 937 00:55:08,851 --> 00:55:12,859 And maybe you believe her when she bat her eyes and turns on the water works. 938 00:55:12,904 --> 00:55:15,201 But that's because you weren't there. 939 00:55:15,390 --> 00:55:17,164 But I was. 940 00:55:17,248 --> 00:55:18,909 And I know what happened. 941 00:55:31,555 --> 00:55:33,564 Oh Jesus Christ. 942 00:55:54,897 --> 00:55:57,595 Step out of the car, leave your hands where I can see them. 943 00:55:57,604 --> 00:55:58,869 You've got to be kidding. 944 00:55:59,226 --> 00:56:00,289 Is there a problem? 945 00:56:00,326 --> 00:56:02,350 I need you to step out of the vehicle. 946 00:56:02,442 --> 00:56:04,178 Okay, you've had your fun. I'm gonna go now. 947 00:56:04,192 --> 00:56:07,675 Lady, we haven't even begun to have fun yet. Get out of the car. 948 00:56:08,630 --> 00:56:11,824 I said, get the fuck out of the car... 949 00:56:11,854 --> 00:56:13,181 Now. 950 00:56:21,045 --> 00:56:22,846 Face the car, put your hands behind your back. 951 00:56:22,873 --> 00:56:24,321 I'm not doing any... 952 00:56:24,798 --> 00:56:26,428 I haven't done anything! 953 00:56:26,727 --> 00:56:29,627 I know, but I could say that I found an open container... 954 00:56:29,752 --> 00:56:31,141 In the front seat of your car. 955 00:56:31,266 --> 00:56:34,619 And in the court of law, it'll be your words against mine, right? 956 00:56:38,174 --> 00:56:40,562 Add to that, assaulting a police officer. 957 00:56:40,585 --> 00:56:42,051 Resisting arrest. 958 00:56:42,074 --> 00:56:43,675 You happen to know a good lawyer, do you? 959 00:56:43,727 --> 00:56:44,988 This is bullshit. 960 00:56:45,026 --> 00:56:47,904 No, bullshit is Lacey Stubbs saying I raped her. 961 00:56:48,029 --> 00:56:51,037 That's fucking bullshit. 962 00:56:53,591 --> 00:56:56,793 My client, Your Honor is highly respected... 963 00:56:56,853 --> 00:57:00,305 Well-known attorney in this Jurisdiction for 13 years. 964 00:57:00,320 --> 00:57:03,528 She's charged with assault on Alleo. 965 00:57:03,550 --> 00:57:05,328 She thought her life was threaten. 966 00:57:05,358 --> 00:57:07,777 That won't fly in my court, Counselor. 967 00:57:08,890 --> 00:57:13,160 January 26th, bind is set at $5,000 unsecured. 968 00:57:14,307 --> 00:57:16,658 Let's go, Cate. 969 00:57:20,867 --> 00:57:23,005 I need to talk to Lacey. 970 00:57:23,377 --> 00:57:24,984 She ain't here. 971 00:57:25,007 --> 00:57:26,727 Do you have any idea where I might find her? 972 00:57:26,736 --> 00:57:29,003 Took off a day after the trial. 973 00:57:29,011 --> 00:57:30,883 Ain't heard from her since. 974 00:57:31,183 --> 00:57:32,949 That ain't true. 975 00:57:33,389 --> 00:57:34,545 She called. 976 00:57:34,670 --> 00:57:36,433 Asking for money. 977 00:57:36,558 --> 00:57:38,790 Do you know where she was calling from? 978 00:57:38,915 --> 00:57:41,208 Number came up in Stockton. 979 00:57:41,913 --> 00:57:43,912 She shacked up with some guy. 980 00:57:43,965 --> 00:57:47,377 Said she'd be sending somebody to get her belongings, but... 981 00:57:47,429 --> 00:57:48,837 So far... 982 00:57:48,962 --> 00:57:51,248 No one. 983 00:57:54,792 --> 00:57:57,733 Lacey borrowed a necklace of mine. 984 00:57:57,930 --> 00:57:59,716 You don't got to explain. 985 00:57:59,761 --> 00:58:02,094 Lacey's been takin' things that don't belong to her... 986 00:58:02,219 --> 00:58:04,779 Her whole life. 987 00:58:13,042 --> 00:58:14,854 - Can I have a Popsicle? - No. 988 00:58:14,895 --> 00:58:17,352 - Please, please. - No. 989 00:58:46,844 --> 00:58:48,474 Got it. 990 00:58:53,538 --> 00:58:56,988 Do you happen to know the name of the man she's staying with? 991 00:58:57,113 --> 00:58:59,359 I don't remember his name. 992 00:58:59,548 --> 00:59:02,528 He's one who was accused of raping her. 993 00:59:02,885 --> 00:59:04,022 Detective Welch? 994 00:59:04,097 --> 00:59:06,122 No, not him. 995 00:59:06,247 --> 00:59:07,274 The other one. 996 00:59:07,305 --> 00:59:09,721 That prison guard she was fucking. 997 00:59:09,846 --> 00:59:11,320 Thank you. 998 00:59:50,242 --> 00:59:51,979 Is Lacey here? 999 00:59:56,371 --> 00:59:58,289 What are you doing here? 1000 01:00:02,908 --> 01:00:04,705 Make yourself at home. 1001 01:00:09,145 --> 01:00:10,994 Is he the one you accused of rape? 1002 01:00:11,120 --> 01:00:14,222 I never accuse him. They said I couldn't consent cause I was an inmate. 1003 01:00:14,347 --> 01:00:17,867 So they fired his ass and bust me out to Fornfolk. 1004 01:00:19,338 --> 01:00:21,059 I talked to Dorrie. 1005 01:00:21,529 --> 01:00:23,381 Is she getting a new trial too? 1006 01:00:23,464 --> 01:00:24,338 No. 1007 01:00:24,463 --> 01:00:26,408 She doesn't want one. 1008 01:00:26,922 --> 01:00:28,939 Never was too bright, that girl. 1009 01:00:29,000 --> 01:00:31,714 She still says you killed Jen. 1010 01:00:33,771 --> 01:00:36,030 Dorrie wants to be all sweet and Jesus now. 1011 01:00:36,053 --> 01:00:37,855 But do you know how she killed a girl back in Alaska... 1012 01:00:37,893 --> 01:00:40,330 Who's gonna tell her parents she was a lesbo? 1013 01:00:40,373 --> 01:00:44,202 Yeah, put a rope around her neck, strung her out, and dump her body in a frozen lake. 1014 01:00:44,255 --> 01:00:47,972 Her parents won't let you in... And the cops wouldn't catch her. 1015 01:00:48,097 --> 01:00:50,281 I found this at your parents' house. 1016 01:00:51,308 --> 01:00:54,963 I read a lot of trash when I was in jail. What else you gonna do, right? 1017 01:00:56,032 --> 01:00:58,557 You mind reading this section? 1018 01:01:01,059 --> 01:01:02,726 Okay, I'll read it. 1019 01:01:03,182 --> 01:01:05,721 I could feel the gun against my throat. 1020 01:01:06,161 --> 01:01:07,945 Then he moved it down between my legs... 1021 01:01:07,984 --> 01:01:11,046 And I could feel the cold steel slide inside my cunt. 1022 01:01:11,092 --> 01:01:12,937 The cop was fucking me with his piece... 1023 01:01:12,957 --> 01:01:15,879 As his cock tore me open from behind. 1024 01:01:16,981 --> 01:01:19,124 You said that after Welch raped you... 1025 01:01:19,169 --> 01:01:21,269 He threaten to do the same to your kid. 1026 01:01:21,405 --> 01:01:22,931 You didn't have a kid yet. 1027 01:01:22,970 --> 01:01:25,388 You were still 6 months pregnant when you went to jail. 1028 01:01:25,411 --> 01:01:27,988 He might not have said that thing about the kid right then. 1029 01:01:28,027 --> 01:01:29,550 Welch didn't rape you, did he? 1030 01:01:29,611 --> 01:01:31,946 I knew he was a cop, friend of Rusty's. 1031 01:01:32,181 --> 01:01:34,076 What about the initials on the gun? 1032 01:01:34,363 --> 01:01:35,523 I made that part up too... 1033 01:01:35,569 --> 01:01:36,990 But everything else it true. 1034 01:01:37,115 --> 01:01:40,526 I swear on my daughter's life. 1035 01:01:41,737 --> 01:01:43,761 Who the fuck are you to judge me? 1036 01:01:43,777 --> 01:01:47,002 You try walking a mile on my shoes and see how pretty the world looks. 1037 01:01:47,047 --> 01:01:48,981 What would I see, Lacey? 1038 01:01:49,292 --> 01:01:52,623 Jen Cole's terrified face as I cut her throat? 1039 01:01:54,367 --> 01:01:55,929 The judge said I'm innocent. 1040 01:01:58,115 --> 01:02:00,070 But you're not, are you? 1041 01:02:02,440 --> 01:02:03,775 What do you think? 1042 01:02:05,033 --> 01:02:06,242 Welch is dirty. 1043 01:02:06,287 --> 01:02:07,401 Brinkerhoff's negligent. 1044 01:02:07,424 --> 01:02:09,464 Rusty's a creep and she's guilty. 1045 01:02:09,589 --> 01:02:11,642 Jesus Christ, I did what I accuse them of. 1046 01:02:11,680 --> 01:02:14,197 It's not the same thing, Cate. You know it. 1047 01:02:14,220 --> 01:02:16,213 We won the case, based on a lie. 1048 01:02:16,244 --> 01:02:18,246 Forget about Lacey Stubbs. 1049 01:02:18,306 --> 01:02:21,096 Focus on your custody hearing. 1050 01:02:21,354 --> 01:02:22,570 You did your job. 1051 01:02:22,695 --> 01:02:24,085 You did it well. 1052 01:02:24,210 --> 01:02:26,129 Now move on. 1053 01:02:36,479 --> 01:02:37,678 Thanks. 1054 01:02:47,583 --> 01:02:49,532 Fern, I'll see you up there. 1055 01:02:51,280 --> 01:02:54,611 When you sat on the bench as long as I have, you'd get use to the fact... 1056 01:02:54,618 --> 01:02:58,131 The trial just basically a liar's contest. 1057 01:02:58,176 --> 01:03:00,959 The point is, we set a clear message to law enforcement. 1058 01:03:00,974 --> 01:03:02,688 But she's guilty. 1059 01:03:05,167 --> 01:03:07,108 I heard about your assault charge. 1060 01:03:07,229 --> 01:03:08,951 It's all bullshit. 1061 01:03:09,481 --> 01:03:11,020 Who's the judge? 1062 01:03:13,348 --> 01:03:14,629 Hayes. 1063 01:03:15,350 --> 01:03:16,964 I'll see what I can do. 1064 01:03:17,540 --> 01:03:18,958 What do you mean? 1065 01:03:19,449 --> 01:03:21,298 I'll talk to him. 1066 01:03:23,739 --> 01:03:25,281 Are you free tonight? 1067 01:03:25,917 --> 01:03:28,465 The Renaissance, say 8:30? 1068 01:03:28,852 --> 01:03:32,856 My grandfather used to take me to the Renaissance. 1069 01:03:32,870 --> 01:03:34,970 For lobster. 1070 01:03:35,228 --> 01:03:38,256 In that case, let's make it to Huttington. 1071 01:03:41,501 --> 01:03:43,257 You're a good lawyer, Cate. 1072 01:03:43,923 --> 01:03:45,698 You can even be a great one. 1073 01:03:46,129 --> 01:03:48,442 Don't let a thing like this get in the way. 1074 01:03:52,855 --> 01:03:56,615 Dr Wise has submitted a report which I have reviewed... 1075 01:03:56,645 --> 01:04:00,618 It's her opinion that, while the mother Loves and cares deeply for her child... 1076 01:04:00,641 --> 01:04:04,576 She's not able at present to fully focus on the child's needs. 1077 01:04:04,629 --> 01:04:08,396 Seems the father has been a loving stable force of his daughter's life. 1078 01:04:08,435 --> 01:04:11,443 We certainly don't want to deny the child's access to that stability. 1079 01:04:11,478 --> 01:04:13,708 Because the father's compelled to move for employment. 1080 01:04:13,731 --> 01:04:15,785 - Your Honor... - I'm not finished. 1081 01:04:16,165 --> 01:04:17,953 You're going to work for Microsoft. 1082 01:04:18,029 --> 01:04:19,394 Yes. 1083 01:04:19,899 --> 01:04:24,773 I don't see that the child's rights or Welfare will be prejudiced in this case. 1084 01:04:24,803 --> 01:04:26,836 Your Honor, she's 5 years old. 1085 01:04:27,033 --> 01:04:31,660 I may not be the perfect mother, but I love my daughter more than anything in the world. 1086 01:04:31,866 --> 01:04:35,299 Well, looks like you're going to get the chance to prove it. 1087 01:04:37,302 --> 01:04:39,281 - I'll call you, okay? - Yeah. 1088 01:04:46,923 --> 01:04:48,933 Microsoft. 1089 01:04:49,569 --> 01:04:51,874 I should have sued you for alimony. 1090 01:04:52,687 --> 01:04:54,689 I'm not asking you for anything, Cate. 1091 01:04:54,703 --> 01:04:56,659 No, just my daughter. 1092 01:04:56,712 --> 01:04:58,540 What's the difference, Cate? 1093 01:04:59,071 --> 01:05:00,828 You're already right back in the saddle. 1094 01:05:00,953 --> 01:05:02,570 You've got your high profile cases. 1095 01:05:02,696 --> 01:05:04,397 Same old firm, crazy hours. 1096 01:05:04,412 --> 01:05:07,007 Listen, I worked my ass off on that case... 1097 01:05:07,030 --> 01:05:10,428 So I can prove to you, and the judge and everybody else... 1098 01:05:10,458 --> 01:05:12,505 That I was capable of being my daughter's mother... 1099 01:05:12,543 --> 01:05:14,969 You work your ass off because you like to win. 1100 01:05:15,875 --> 01:05:18,453 Augie doesn't need a mother who wins. 1101 01:05:18,771 --> 01:05:19,948 She needs a mother who's there. 1102 01:05:19,986 --> 01:05:23,209 Then why are you taking her a thousand miles away? 1103 01:05:23,697 --> 01:05:24,909 I tell you what. 1104 01:05:25,676 --> 01:05:28,913 Move to Seattle for Augie. I'll share custody. 1105 01:05:29,280 --> 01:05:31,100 I can't move to Seattle, Josh! 1106 01:05:31,115 --> 01:05:33,958 I practice law in California! 1107 01:05:37,218 --> 01:05:38,650 We're... 1108 01:05:39,090 --> 01:05:41,321 We're leaving in the morning, early. 1109 01:05:41,814 --> 01:05:43,300 Maybe you could... 1110 01:05:43,425 --> 01:05:45,794 Manage to stop by and say goodbye. 1111 01:05:50,517 --> 01:05:54,132 Just try and focus on the next right action. 1112 01:05:54,170 --> 01:05:55,610 Like what? 1113 01:05:55,876 --> 01:05:57,526 Throwing myself off of the Sixth Street Bridge? 1114 01:05:57,571 --> 01:06:00,331 - You gotta count the bad blow. - Thank you. 1115 01:06:00,649 --> 01:06:02,561 I want to drink. 1116 01:06:03,936 --> 01:06:05,945 Your feelings, Cate... 1117 01:06:06,400 --> 01:06:07,570 They come and go. 1118 01:06:07,585 --> 01:06:09,390 You don't know shit about my feelings. 1119 01:06:09,421 --> 01:06:11,111 I know you drink. 1120 01:06:11,148 --> 01:06:13,238 So you don't have to feel them. 1121 01:06:13,275 --> 01:06:14,573 Give me a break. 1122 01:06:14,610 --> 01:06:16,536 I've been where you are. 1123 01:06:17,044 --> 01:06:18,641 It gets better. 1124 01:06:18,710 --> 01:06:19,855 Does it? 1125 01:06:19,980 --> 01:06:21,355 You live in your office... 1126 01:06:21,481 --> 01:06:22,989 With a cod and a hot plate. 1127 01:06:23,114 --> 01:06:24,924 You didn't just lose your kid. 1128 01:06:24,961 --> 01:06:28,335 Do you want to play some kind of misery contest? 1129 01:06:28,381 --> 01:06:29,696 With me? 1130 01:06:29,794 --> 01:06:31,796 Alright, let's play Cate. 1131 01:06:31,872 --> 01:06:33,555 That'd be fun. 1132 01:06:33,616 --> 01:06:35,755 But I'm gonna tell you one thing, goddmanit... 1133 01:06:35,771 --> 01:06:39,994 You will lose, you'll fucking lose completely. 1134 01:06:40,711 --> 01:06:43,547 So please, just cut out the bullshit. 1135 01:06:44,373 --> 01:06:45,836 I can't do this anymore. 1136 01:06:45,905 --> 01:06:47,861 No, you can't do this anymore. 1137 01:06:47,884 --> 01:06:49,377 No, you won't. 1138 01:06:49,400 --> 01:06:51,015 What do you want to be? 1139 01:06:51,140 --> 01:06:53,555 An old bag, with a bottle of booze beside you? 1140 01:06:53,680 --> 01:06:57,573 I have heard enough AA bullshit to last me a life time. 1141 01:06:57,876 --> 01:07:01,228 All the cute little sayings, and the stupid rules. 1142 01:07:01,326 --> 01:07:03,389 It doesn't fucking work. 1143 01:07:03,428 --> 01:07:05,057 I'm fucking done with all of it. 1144 01:07:05,072 --> 01:07:06,217 Cate, sit down. 1145 01:07:06,247 --> 01:07:09,048 The A losers and the dirty cops... 1146 01:07:09,116 --> 01:07:11,603 And the defendants lying off their asses... 1147 01:07:11,728 --> 01:07:13,414 Go and fuck yourself. 1148 01:07:13,428 --> 01:07:15,945 Fuck myself, sit down. 1149 01:07:16,196 --> 01:07:18,884 I put a man in prison for 11 years... 1150 01:07:18,921 --> 01:07:20,954 Because I follow the rules. 1151 01:07:21,325 --> 01:07:23,842 I just let a murdered walks because I follow the rules. 1152 01:07:23,880 --> 01:07:26,428 And now I lost my kid because I follow the rules, you know what? 1153 01:07:26,473 --> 01:07:28,103 Fuck the rules! 1154 01:07:28,354 --> 01:07:31,201 Fuck you and fuck the fucking rules! 1155 01:07:34,457 --> 01:07:36,420 Ow shit. 1156 01:07:48,588 --> 01:07:50,950 I'm meeting Jameson Sumnter. 1157 01:07:50,996 --> 01:07:52,444 Are you Cate? 1158 01:07:52,570 --> 01:07:53,741 Yeah. 1159 01:08:08,068 --> 01:08:09,426 Thanks. 1160 01:08:21,140 --> 01:08:24,539 I wanted to say I'm sorry. 1161 01:08:26,298 --> 01:08:28,607 I spent a life saving... 1162 01:08:29,327 --> 01:08:32,063 Fighting those awful charges. 1163 01:08:33,064 --> 01:08:35,179 But if you love someone... 1164 01:08:35,566 --> 01:08:37,651 You have no choice. 1165 01:08:38,360 --> 01:08:41,347 But to hold on to what you believe about. 1166 01:08:42,045 --> 01:08:45,580 Even when people say terrible things... 1167 01:08:47,202 --> 01:08:49,685 You can't go with the evidence. 1168 01:08:50,427 --> 01:08:52,520 You gotta go with your heart. 1169 01:09:01,736 --> 01:09:04,207 I really wasn't trying to hurt you. 1170 01:09:05,488 --> 01:09:07,230 I thought... 1171 01:09:07,692 --> 01:09:09,853 I truly thought. 1172 01:09:10,134 --> 01:09:12,648 I was doing something good. 1173 01:09:20,254 --> 01:09:22,407 A guy I know. 1174 01:09:23,459 --> 01:09:26,470 Did 27 years for something he didn't do. 1175 01:09:27,167 --> 01:09:29,431 He said you can hang on to the hate. 1176 01:09:31,335 --> 01:09:33,737 All these years, I thought... 1177 01:09:34,562 --> 01:09:37,913 I thought I wanted to hear you say you're sorry. 1178 01:09:40,306 --> 01:09:42,293 But this is better. 1179 01:09:45,310 --> 01:09:47,675 I like watching you cry. 1180 01:09:50,543 --> 01:09:52,294 You know why? 1181 01:09:53,766 --> 01:09:56,154 The hate is all you left me with. 1182 01:09:59,222 --> 01:10:01,315 Hate is all I got. 1183 01:10:43,657 --> 01:10:45,613 Shit... 1184 01:10:54,963 --> 01:10:57,959 Sorry baby, I totally overslept. 1185 01:11:00,686 --> 01:11:02,710 - Hey... - Hey. 1186 01:11:04,592 --> 01:11:07,162 I'm gonna give you the tiny little momma. 1187 01:11:08,314 --> 01:11:11,365 - Daddy... - I know you're mad at me. 1188 01:11:11,896 --> 01:11:13,430 I know you are. 1189 01:11:13,476 --> 01:11:14,818 It's okay, baby. 1190 01:11:14,864 --> 01:11:17,441 No matter what anybody says, I... 1191 01:11:17,724 --> 01:11:18,769 Love you. 1192 01:11:18,831 --> 01:11:20,992 - Alright that's it. - More than anything in the world. 1193 01:11:20,999 --> 01:11:23,550 And I always will. 1194 01:11:24,838 --> 01:11:28,824 When people say really bad Things about a person... 1195 01:11:29,332 --> 01:11:31,242 If you love them... 1196 01:11:31,599 --> 01:11:33,161 You have to hang on. 1197 01:11:33,177 --> 01:11:35,921 Do what you believe about them in your heart. 1198 01:11:36,035 --> 01:11:38,128 You can't just go on evidence. 1199 01:11:38,189 --> 01:11:40,987 Cause evidence get misrepresented. 1200 01:11:41,009 --> 01:11:44,993 And twisted until it's all a fucking lie. 1201 01:11:45,046 --> 01:11:46,365 That's it. 1202 01:11:46,649 --> 01:11:48,158 You need to get yourself some help. 1203 01:11:48,188 --> 01:11:50,411 I got help! 1204 01:11:51,510 --> 01:11:54,270 This is the new improved me. 1205 01:12:12,665 --> 01:12:14,151 I slept. 1206 01:12:15,230 --> 01:12:17,239 So I see. 1207 01:12:25,387 --> 01:12:27,480 I got a call from the DA. 1208 01:12:27,890 --> 01:12:30,323 The assault charges are dropped. 1209 01:12:31,725 --> 01:12:33,128 I see. 1210 01:12:34,007 --> 01:12:37,675 I actually am the piece of shit of the center of the universe. 1211 01:12:37,851 --> 01:12:40,678 You're half way right anyway. 1212 01:12:42,551 --> 01:12:45,858 You want to keep feeling the way you're feeling right now. 1213 01:12:45,880 --> 01:12:49,426 Well, just keep on doing what you're doing. 1214 01:12:50,215 --> 01:12:52,307 If you want to feel better... 1215 01:12:52,550 --> 01:12:56,881 Figure out how you can serve something other than your own ego. 1216 01:13:00,626 --> 01:13:01,702 So you made a mistake. 1217 01:13:01,732 --> 01:13:03,013 I didn't make a mistake. 1218 01:13:03,051 --> 01:13:04,934 So Lacey pulled one over on you. 1219 01:13:04,964 --> 01:13:09,175 The custody judge thought Josh was a better parent, okay. 1220 01:13:10,032 --> 01:13:11,917 What are you gonna do about it? 1221 01:13:11,932 --> 01:13:13,577 You're gonna drink yourself to death? 1222 01:13:13,600 --> 01:13:15,423 So Augie has no mother at all? 1223 01:13:15,437 --> 01:13:17,409 For god sake, I had a few drinks. 1224 01:13:17,447 --> 01:13:18,738 Save it, Cate. 1225 01:13:18,776 --> 01:13:23,300 Save it for somebody that can't smell your bullshit from mile away. 1226 01:13:23,346 --> 01:13:24,718 You're drunk. 1227 01:13:24,734 --> 01:13:27,448 And not because the world did it to you. 1228 01:13:27,573 --> 01:13:30,260 Or because Wilson George turned out to be innocent. 1229 01:13:30,298 --> 01:13:32,777 Or Lacey turned out to be guilty. 1230 01:13:32,838 --> 01:13:37,481 You're drunk because it's the way you choose to handle it. 1231 01:13:38,643 --> 01:13:41,145 And if you don't change. 1232 01:13:41,350 --> 01:13:42,851 Guess what? 1233 01:13:43,132 --> 01:13:45,428 Nothing changes. 1234 01:13:56,610 --> 01:14:00,416 You're a great and special person, Cate. 1235 01:14:00,726 --> 01:14:03,488 But not for any of the reasons you think. 1236 01:14:03,685 --> 01:14:06,073 Not because you're a great lawyer. 1237 01:14:06,339 --> 01:14:07,906 Or you're pretty. 1238 01:14:07,937 --> 01:14:10,893 Or because you win in court. 1239 01:14:16,277 --> 01:14:18,051 What's so great about me? 1240 01:14:20,340 --> 01:14:23,705 It's something you need to figure out for yourself. 1241 01:15:43,097 --> 01:15:44,462 I need 5 minutes. 1242 01:15:44,507 --> 01:15:45,607 We're appealing Stubbs. 1243 01:15:45,637 --> 01:15:47,237 Everybody knows you're appealing. 1244 01:15:47,305 --> 01:15:49,670 I know how you can put her back in jail. 1245 01:15:51,845 --> 01:15:54,824 Our case can be made that she feels to exhaust your state's appeal. 1246 01:16:01,017 --> 01:16:02,929 I can have you disbarred. 1247 01:16:03,262 --> 01:16:06,594 If you have me disbarred, you can't take credit for my idea. 1248 01:16:16,787 --> 01:16:17,637 Can I talk to you? 1249 01:16:17,652 --> 01:16:18,850 Go fuck yourself. 1250 01:16:18,933 --> 01:16:21,185 I know she lied about the rape. 1251 01:16:21,549 --> 01:16:23,671 I didn't know it then, but I know it now. 1252 01:16:24,027 --> 01:16:25,672 You know your problem is? 1253 01:16:25,741 --> 01:16:27,861 You can't tell the good guys from the bad guys. 1254 01:16:27,891 --> 01:16:30,643 Used to be a lot easier to tell the difference. 1255 01:16:30,969 --> 01:16:32,462 You're no better than me. 1256 01:16:32,546 --> 01:16:34,521 I don't think I'm better than you. 1257 01:16:34,801 --> 01:16:36,438 I think I'm just like you. 1258 01:16:37,091 --> 01:16:40,518 I want to get the bad guys too, and right now I don't care how I do it. 1259 01:16:42,277 --> 01:16:43,933 They found a technicality. 1260 01:16:43,963 --> 01:16:45,146 They're exploiting it. 1261 01:16:45,169 --> 01:16:47,565 Maybe you didn't notice, but I'm back in jail. 1262 01:16:47,602 --> 01:16:50,838 As soon as the state denies the appeal we go right back to federal court. 1263 01:16:50,876 --> 01:16:53,678 Sumnter's all over the news saying he'll set you free again. 1264 01:16:53,724 --> 01:16:57,545 Why would you want to represent someone you think is guilty? 1265 01:17:00,119 --> 01:17:02,113 I don't make mistakes. 1266 01:17:02,734 --> 01:17:04,630 This case will come around again. 1267 01:17:05,053 --> 01:17:06,578 And when it does... 1268 01:17:06,699 --> 01:17:09,936 I intend to see that this poor abused woman is set free. 1269 01:17:09,974 --> 01:17:11,501 Once and for all. 1270 01:17:11,865 --> 01:17:13,594 Douglas is moving over to Exxon. 1271 01:17:13,639 --> 01:17:16,373 I want you with me in DC quarterbacking Waterford. 1272 01:17:16,472 --> 01:17:18,632 That's fucking fantastic. 1273 01:17:18,663 --> 01:17:20,104 We'll head out tonight. 1274 01:17:20,210 --> 01:17:21,990 Oh, I'm... 1275 01:17:22,118 --> 01:17:24,173 I'm with my daughter in Seattle this weekend. 1276 01:17:24,188 --> 01:17:26,243 Sorry babe, you're in DC. 1277 01:17:26,478 --> 01:17:29,215 Play your cards right, and you're right back on the fast track. 1278 01:17:36,058 --> 01:17:37,267 Then we'll put on Henkle... 1279 01:17:37,312 --> 01:17:40,018 Said DBCP was well below the damage causing level. 1280 01:17:40,059 --> 01:17:43,064 And that workers refused to wear protective gear. Sorry. 1281 01:17:43,474 --> 01:17:46,265 Hey, I'm gonna miss my connection to Seattle. 1282 01:17:46,326 --> 01:17:48,312 Can you see if there's any later flights? 1283 01:17:49,275 --> 01:17:52,637 Everything you want to know about Arthuro Juan Gonzales. 1284 01:17:54,251 --> 01:17:56,504 That's not the same guy. 1285 01:17:58,199 --> 01:17:59,602 Isn't it? 1286 01:18:05,299 --> 01:18:07,596 Okay, so check another airline. 1287 01:18:22,369 --> 01:18:24,189 A cellphone? 1288 01:18:25,943 --> 01:18:29,042 I've entered myself remember? 1289 01:18:29,369 --> 01:18:31,330 So if you ever need to talk to me... 1290 01:18:31,360 --> 01:18:33,567 You just press that. 1291 01:18:37,696 --> 01:18:39,970 And that way I'll always know it's you. 1292 01:18:41,070 --> 01:18:42,258 Hello? 1293 01:18:52,780 --> 01:18:54,648 Okay bug, we gotta go back to bed. 1294 01:18:54,701 --> 01:18:56,430 Could you give us a minute? 1295 01:19:12,242 --> 01:19:14,509 I'm sorry I missed your party. 1296 01:19:15,310 --> 01:19:17,387 I really wanted to be there. 1297 01:19:18,910 --> 01:19:22,285 I know I let you down, and I'm really sorry. 1298 01:19:24,264 --> 01:19:26,682 Blue dog doesn't feel good. 1299 01:19:26,808 --> 01:19:27,836 No? 1300 01:19:27,961 --> 01:19:29,511 Is he sick? 1301 01:19:30,459 --> 01:19:32,946 He ate too many cupcakes. 1302 01:19:39,889 --> 01:19:42,572 I'm not gonna make you any more promises. 1303 01:19:43,816 --> 01:19:45,613 I'm just gonna do better. 1304 01:19:45,738 --> 01:19:47,045 Okay? 1305 01:19:54,290 --> 01:19:57,525 I don't want the tiny momma anymore. 1306 01:20:17,104 --> 01:20:19,747 Make this go away, you'll make full partner by the end of the year. 1307 01:20:19,786 --> 01:20:21,635 You have my word. 1308 01:20:22,883 --> 01:20:24,733 Shall we? 1309 01:20:26,416 --> 01:20:30,425 Mr. Gonzales, would you mind reading the first paragraph of this article? 1310 01:20:47,698 --> 01:20:49,900 Arthuro Juan Gonzales convicted of a brutal crime... 1311 01:20:49,928 --> 01:20:52,153 In Chapas Mexico, in 2003. 1312 01:20:54,034 --> 01:20:55,150 This isn't me. 1313 01:20:55,174 --> 01:20:58,082 Mr. Gonzales, I'm looking at your rep sheet. 1314 01:20:58,820 --> 01:20:59,887 The lists... 1315 01:20:59,940 --> 01:21:00,887 Murder. 1316 01:21:01,084 --> 01:21:01,994 Kidnapping. 1317 01:21:02,040 --> 01:21:02,935 Assault. 1318 01:21:08,533 --> 01:21:09,799 Sorry. 1319 01:21:19,192 --> 01:21:20,436 Cate. 1320 01:21:22,249 --> 01:21:24,061 Mrs. McCall. 1321 01:21:36,600 --> 01:21:38,586 I know you didn't kill anybody. 1322 01:21:44,077 --> 01:21:47,085 We're just trying to make him look bad. So that you won't give him what he deserves. 1323 01:21:47,124 --> 01:21:49,163 Your Honor, we need a recess. 1324 01:21:53,158 --> 01:21:54,932 Just give him what he deserves. 1325 01:22:10,447 --> 01:22:12,501 Nice piece and the Times. 1326 01:22:15,152 --> 01:22:16,684 Sure it's justice you want? 1327 01:22:16,707 --> 01:22:18,906 Not a sit on the court? 1328 01:22:20,498 --> 01:22:22,454 What are you worried about, Cate? 1329 01:22:23,061 --> 01:22:24,921 That your client will go free? 1330 01:22:25,027 --> 01:22:27,476 You can't sit on this case. 1331 01:22:31,664 --> 01:22:33,643 You need to reused yourself. 1332 01:22:35,145 --> 01:22:36,934 All rise. 1333 01:22:42,684 --> 01:22:44,185 Who is that? 1334 01:22:45,218 --> 01:22:47,462 Looks like Justice Tanaka. 1335 01:22:47,736 --> 01:22:49,267 Please be seated. 1336 01:22:51,194 --> 01:22:53,468 Before us today, after a lengthy journey. 1337 01:22:53,491 --> 01:22:56,367 Up and down the states and federal justice system... 1338 01:22:56,420 --> 01:22:58,998 We have a Habeas Petition of Lacey Stubbs. 1339 01:22:59,036 --> 01:23:01,253 I'd like to give both parties an opportunity to... 1340 01:23:01,276 --> 01:23:03,884 Request additional testimony... 1341 01:23:03,930 --> 01:23:06,994 On topics that the court has not sufficiently addressed. 1342 01:23:07,025 --> 01:23:08,624 Where the fuck is Sumnter? 1343 01:23:08,761 --> 01:23:11,265 Did you ever socialize with Lacey Stubbs? 1344 01:23:11,319 --> 01:23:12,440 No sir. 1345 01:23:12,494 --> 01:23:14,531 Did you have sex with Lacey Stubbs? 1346 01:23:14,561 --> 01:23:15,775 No sir, I did not. 1347 01:23:15,805 --> 01:23:17,989 Did you rape Lacey Stubbs? 1348 01:23:18,056 --> 01:23:19,709 Absolutely not. 1349 01:23:19,969 --> 01:23:23,494 Do you know where you were on November 29th, 2007? 1350 01:23:23,556 --> 01:23:27,044 Yes, I was in Chicago with my wife and son. 1351 01:23:27,255 --> 01:23:29,113 So now you say you're in Chicago? 1352 01:23:29,159 --> 01:23:31,259 November 29th, 2007? 1353 01:23:31,384 --> 01:23:32,633 Yes, that's correct. 1354 01:23:32,831 --> 01:23:35,097 And we're supposed to take your word for that? 1355 01:23:35,145 --> 01:23:37,192 You could, or you could... 1356 01:23:37,238 --> 01:23:39,482 Check my credit card receipt. 1357 01:23:39,831 --> 01:23:43,247 So it's still your testimony that Detective Welch raped you? 1358 01:23:43,315 --> 01:23:44,969 She said I wouldn't have to go through this again. 1359 01:23:44,999 --> 01:23:46,718 Answer the question. 1360 01:23:47,833 --> 01:23:49,190 Yes, he raped me. 1361 01:23:49,236 --> 01:23:51,259 Reading from the record now... 1362 01:23:51,313 --> 01:23:52,832 Welch got off me... 1363 01:23:52,885 --> 01:23:55,349 And said if I open my mouth... 1364 01:23:55,683 --> 01:23:58,989 They'd come back and do the same to my kid. 1365 01:23:59,255 --> 01:24:00,801 That's still your testimony? 1366 01:24:00,870 --> 01:24:01,681 Yes. 1367 01:24:01,696 --> 01:24:05,022 But on November 29th, 2007... 1368 01:24:05,121 --> 01:24:07,122 You didn't have a child, did you? 1369 01:24:07,247 --> 01:24:07,895 He said... 1370 01:24:07,948 --> 01:24:09,835 It's a simple yes or no question. 1371 01:24:12,088 --> 01:24:13,489 He said he was gonna rape my kid. 1372 01:24:13,542 --> 01:24:16,780 Maybe he meant the one inside of me. I don't know what he was thinking. 1373 01:24:19,128 --> 01:24:21,986 Your Honor, I'd like to mark this State 12. 1374 01:24:24,811 --> 01:24:27,040 Do you recognize this book? 1375 01:24:29,375 --> 01:24:30,782 Not really. 1376 01:24:35,135 --> 01:24:38,827 Would you mind reading the underline passage here? 1377 01:24:39,054 --> 01:24:42,862 Starting with "I could feel the gun against my throat". 1378 01:24:42,907 --> 01:24:44,098 She's trying to fuck me! 1379 01:24:44,128 --> 01:24:44,902 Miss Dubbs. 1380 01:24:44,925 --> 01:24:47,672 That cocksucker got him that in the first place. 1381 01:24:47,756 --> 01:24:49,434 You fucking bitch! 1382 01:24:49,465 --> 01:24:51,041 I'm gonna kill you! 1383 01:24:51,087 --> 01:24:52,838 Get the fuck... 1384 01:24:52,853 --> 01:24:55,237 I'm gonna fucking slice your throat! 1385 01:24:55,297 --> 01:24:56,996 I'll kill you! 1386 01:24:57,019 --> 01:24:58,247 I'll cut you! 1387 01:24:58,285 --> 01:24:59,463 Court order! 1388 01:24:59,493 --> 01:25:01,283 Clear the room! 1389 01:25:01,336 --> 01:25:03,292 I'll fucking kill you! 1390 01:25:03,314 --> 01:25:04,381 Hurry! 1391 01:25:04,411 --> 01:25:07,049 I'll kill you! 1392 01:25:27,063 --> 01:25:30,164 One of my sponsor's favorite saying is... 1393 01:25:30,914 --> 01:25:33,138 You can't change the wind. 1394 01:25:33,229 --> 01:25:35,656 But you can adjust the sail. 1395 01:25:36,635 --> 01:25:39,001 It's been a pretty rough year recently. 1396 01:25:39,485 --> 01:25:40,698 Somedays it's... 1397 01:25:40,728 --> 01:25:42,089 All I can do to... 1398 01:25:42,142 --> 01:25:44,015 Hang on and hold my head up high. 1399 01:25:44,030 --> 01:25:47,198 So I can see the damn sails without getting my head knocked off, but... 1400 01:25:48,551 --> 01:25:49,992 I'm here. 1401 01:25:50,408 --> 01:25:51,735 Again. 1402 01:25:52,676 --> 01:25:54,125 Still. 1403 01:25:57,037 --> 01:25:59,698 Graditute's always been really hard. 1404 01:26:01,912 --> 01:26:03,694 But I want to say thanks. 1405 01:26:07,847 --> 01:26:09,993 I won't be here without you. 1406 01:26:16,801 --> 01:26:19,401 Call me, as soon as you land. 1407 01:26:19,527 --> 01:26:20,758 Yeah. 1408 01:26:21,869 --> 01:26:24,530 And, don't forget you're starting over. 1409 01:26:24,576 --> 01:26:26,077 Every single day. 1410 01:26:26,153 --> 01:26:27,881 One fucking day at a time. 1411 01:26:27,911 --> 01:26:28,896 Yeah... 1412 01:26:30,901 --> 01:26:32,501 Okay... 1413 01:26:35,212 --> 01:26:36,964 You're an asshole. 1414 01:26:38,495 --> 01:26:40,273 Did you figure it out yet? 1415 01:26:41,699 --> 01:26:44,041 The great and the special? 1416 01:26:44,473 --> 01:26:46,012 I'm still working on it. 1417 01:26:46,058 --> 01:26:47,134 Oh. 1418 01:26:47,362 --> 01:26:49,060 Maybe that's it. Maybe... 1419 01:26:49,144 --> 01:26:51,108 I never give up. 1420 01:26:51,844 --> 01:26:53,724 That's not nothing. 1421 01:27:31,002 --> 01:27:32,822 Is this my room? 1422 01:27:32,905 --> 01:27:34,262 Yeah. 1423 01:27:35,363 --> 01:27:37,743 I have a rainbow room in daddy's house. 1424 01:27:37,868 --> 01:27:40,344 Well, now you have one at my house too. 1425 01:27:42,527 --> 01:27:44,385 A fish. 1426 01:27:44,948 --> 01:27:46,920 Hi boy. 1427 01:27:47,534 --> 01:27:50,400 I'm gonna name you Rainbow. 1428 01:27:50,525 --> 01:27:52,798 Is that okay?