Visit www.Markasjudi.com Trusted Secure Online Gambling Agents
New Member 500 Thousand Bonuses 10 Million Parlay Cashback
[FLUTE FOLK MUSIC PLAYING ]
[MUSIC CONTINUES]
SPORTS Comments: Republic of Ireland against Italy
in this group final round World Cup. </ P>
I will say the biggest day
in the Irish international football history,
The Giants Stadium is filled up to capacity.
Lots of Irish proof,
and it's clear here to enjoy a nice day...
[MUSIC CONTINUE]
If you look around the Colosseum, full of Ireland...
... we have to accept it atmosphere. </ P>
[CONTINUE -MENERUS]
[ALL cheering]
Ini Italia nihil, Irlandia satu.
[MUSIC CONTINUE]
That's far Costacurta.
Donadoni Roberto, Donadoni...
[BAGPIP PLAYING]
>
[BIRD CHIRPING]
[THUDS]
[STREAM GUSHING]
[MELANCHOLY MUSIC PLAYING]
[CROW CAWS]
EMMA ROGAN: I remember being at my aunt's house. </ P>
She lived in Downpatrick, not too far from here,
about eight or nine miles, on Sunday morning.
I was upstairs at his house in bed, sleeping,
and woke up from my sleep
to enter the room for Tony, for my brother,
and we were told together.
I always remember < br /> my two uncles were there,
a big, heavy long coat.
I remember thinking,
first of all, why are they here
and why they use it A big heavy coat?
[STAMMERS] That's June.
It was summer, why did they use a big coat?
And I just remember Mother said to us
that bad guys have come to the pub
and they... have weapons
and they shoot six people and Daddy is dead.
He has died.
Nothing I know has died before,
so I really don't know what is going on.
CLAIRE ROGAN: We just returned home </ p >
from Spain while on vacation
and my husband came down here to watch the game.
So I went down to join him around 10 o'clock past 10:00 o'clock.
And when I went down,
I met a local man at the door and he said,
"Don't go in there, there have been shootings."
And for some reason I think
there are some boys around here
will come out and shoot rabbits or whatever
and I think someone goes go there with a gun
and it goes accidentally.
And he says, "No, no, don't enter.
"This is terrible, we need a priest. "
So I entered.
And...
what will greet me haunt me until the day I die.
Only the body lies everywhere.
It smells, The smoke is prolonged,
the glass breaks.
I can't see it, I can't. I have to go, </ p >
I have to run out, I can't.
[MELANCHOLY MUSIC PLAYING]
GREEN ACNE: * Good night to you One and all
* Good luck to you I will say
* I just came here To sing for youse
* Before I go
MOIRA CASE: Barney used to be famous character,
with a pipe and her rosy cheeks.
She cheerful.
ALEX GIBNEY: Night the massacre happened,
where are you, what are you doing?
Some things I remember,
but many blurred.
It was like...
Oh, that's horrendous.
The parish priest came,
and we know that
that Barney...
for sure...
is dead.
[DOG DOGS] [LAUGHS MAN]
[AIDAN O & apos; TOOLE SPEAKING]
GIBNEY: Did you see something?
No.
[SPEAKING]
And...
p>
[SOLEMN MUSIC PLAYING]
[BRENDAN VALENTINE SPEAKING]
You know, neighbors here don't exist...
There is no problem at all. </ P>
To come to this community is not real. </ P>
It's as simple as that. </ P>
The Troubles are something that happened in Belfast.
Yes, we realized they were
you know, people lose their lives,
but that's something that never touches us
and we never, for a minute think
that we will have to live through it.
Brutal, inhuman, barbaric, heartless massacre,
some words used today to describe
overnight cruelty by Loyalist terrorists
in a pub in County Down.
>
Bar O & Apos; Toole is located a few half a mile from the main line
Belfast to the Newcastle road in Loughinisland.
This is a relatively small bar in remote rural areas.
NEWS REPORTER 1: Massacre in Loughinisland,
when they watched the World Cup on television.
Six people died.
NEWS REPORTER 2: Gunmen from Forbidden Loyalist groups,
Ulster Volunteer Force,
walk to Bar Heights and spray it with shots
from automatic assault rifles .
The attack is over in seconds.
NEWS REPORTER 3: All six people who died were Catholics.
The oldest, Barney Green, is 87. </ P>
His niece, Dan McCreanor, who is 59 years old, died with him. </ P>
Other victims are /> father of four children, Eamon Byrne,
father of three children, Malcolm Jenkinson,
father of two children, Adrian Brogan,
and single men Patrick O & apos; Hare.
MAN: The body is stacked on top of each other.
Only under contempt the people
who can carry out such things this.
It's just a nightmare after that. Um...
Then there is a whole grieving process
and funeral.
NEWS REPORTER: Protestants and Catholics walk together
as hearses bring Adrian Rogan,
victim first buried,
passed the Heights Pub in Loughinisland,
where six people were killed.
IMAM: That very plain way
spend a few hours
in a friend's company,
debating the progress of the game,
happy at the destination.
EMMA: I remember walking behind the funeral,
and my grandmother has my hand.
Loughinisland, this is a knitting community that is close.
I remember being...
I guess, when you are small, a child,
it's like thousands of people everywhere.
SIR PATRICK MAYHEW: < br /> For those who have done this,
those who have it killed these people,
my message to them is this.
I think some of you have a family. </ P>
Let's just imagine the future conversation
that you might have with your daughter,
who asks you what you are doing in the so-called war, Father.
And you will say, "I killed a 87-year-old man."
He is sitting behind me.
He was watching World Cup.
I shot him dead.
He won't think of it a hero's note, Will he ?
Now, I want to say this in the end,
you will be caught sooner or later.
The RUC doesn't never give up.
And you will be arrested,
and you will spend years in prison.
Thank you very much.
>
CASEMENT: I have a letter from the Queen...
a letter from the Pope.
This makes the world news.
Former football great, OJ Simpson, and his lawyer,
are preparing tomorrow's charges
on charges of multiple murders.
Meanwhile, police in Northern Ireland
after the worst violence there in a few months.
The men killed six people as they watched
the Irish World Cup match ball.
CLAIRE: I think the police can't let this go.
I mean, the eye the world is with them,
they must be seen do the right thing here.
I clearly remember the police came into the wake.
Some of them really will do it already know my husband.
I will never forget their words.
"We will go no there is a stone missing
Until we get this culprit . "
And those words ring in my ear to this day,
because I don't think they ever lift stones,
it doesn't matter to change it.
GIBNEY: More than 20 years after the massacre,
Bar Heights is still in business.
p>
The bar has been rebuilt,
but Aidan O & apos; Toole, the man shot in the kidney,
still pouring Guinness for local farmers
I first came here to make a short film
about World Cup matches,
but I was haunted by the story Unresolved murders.
Why is this pub? Why is this village?
What is in the heart mystery
the victim's family is trying to solve?
I have moved by their search,
even as I know they are not alone .
[MUSIC ROCK PLAYING]
[PEOPLE EXCLAIMING]
GIBNEY: For almost 50 years,
Northern Ireland has haunted
with what it is known simply as Troubles.
It's fair to say that the origin of the Problem in 1922,
the year of Ireland > declare its independence from Great Britain.
As part of the agreement,
Ireland is divided into two parts.
Republic of Ireland and Northern Ireland,
a province left part of the United Kingdom.
In the late 1960s,
Northern Ireland Tearing up.
An embattled Catholic minority,
victims of law and economic discrimination,
seeking rights civil and union with Republic of Ireland.
Against them stands most Protestant the majority who are called Loyalists,
who want to remain part of the United Kingdom.
[EXPLOSION ]
Overtime, both sides descend into a terrorist campaign,
kill thousands of people innocent civilians. </ p >
[GUNFIRE]
For Republicans, the dominant power of is IRA.
For Loyalists, there are a number of groups,
including UVF,
which will take responsibility for Loughinisland.
[MAN SPEAKS]
NOEL KILPATRICK: UVF, when the Problem started in 1968,
when there was a riot and houses were burned on Shankill Street,
they come forward, as a kind of protector of Protestants.
The heartland will have become Shankill Road,
Belfast east, north of Belfast, Portadown,
it's definitely more or less centers for UVF.
And they are engaged in sectarian killings.
So they will come out and kill Catholics.
The famous Shankill Butcher is UVF.
They come out and take it innocent Catholics
walk home at night < br /> and cut their necks,
tortured them and killed them.
They talked about soldiers in Ulster Volunteer Power.
They are not soldiers.
They are people who come out and kill innocent people.
GIBNEY: You are involved in paramilitary activities
back to the 80s and you were in prison.
What were you? in prison for?
I was in prison for /> become a UVF activist
and get involved in murder.
I am from an environment
known as Shankill in Belfast. </ P>
And I think it's historical significance,
and the best way to describe it
is that true a pro-British community.
Quite a lot of people when I grew up
joined the British Army and went and fought
in conflicts around the world.
So there is a strong relationship with England
and with the royal family.
The majority of them will do it has become a Protestant,
but there are Catholics living in my neighborhood so too.
IRA violence at that time Shankill where I live.
I have watched retirees,
I have watched an 18 month old baby blown out of the baby stroller
by careless bombs. </ P>
[HARD EXPLOSION]
People are being killed on the way.
KILPATRICK: their IRA, at the beginning of
only a group of assassins.
Really that is the lust of blood.
They generally leave afterwards soldiers and police,
but they do it sectarian killings too.
Usually a tit for tat.
If a Protestant is shot dead one night,
then a Catholic < br /> shoot the next die,
and it just goes away forward and backward and backwards and forwards.
Unfortunately there are people waiting in line
on the second side to join become an armed man.
Young children come together and see these people
walk down the road,
These great people who think they are the knees of the bees.
"I want to be like him."
So there is no lack of people < br /> want to pull the trigger.
For a while I work in the world of intelligence,
especially in relation to for Loyalist terrorism.
Previously I was served in west Belfast,
that might be the most dangerous place in the province. </ P>
Murders occur every day, every day.
I think it's like an adrenaline buzz.
You come out every day don't know what will happen.
GIBNEY: So, exactly why did you decide to join the police, RUC?
Um...
I think it's because it is a job for life.
GIBNEY: Nothing there a little the risk at that time
in terms of being on RUC?
That's why I smile.
This is a lifetime job if you live long enough.
[BOTH BOTH]
There is an element of risk, yes, there is a risk.
At that time I had personal protection weapons.
I also have a gun that is stored beside the bed.
I teach my wife how to fire them together.
Give him a strategy that the rifle
will be shot down the stairs,
and if it gets to the gun we are in trouble.
As far as the attack on the RUC is worried,
it seems the IRA justifies all that before
by the accusation yesterday
that the police were torturing suspects.
GIBNEY: To stop increasing violence, </ p >
the British government deployed the Army.
The IRA saw it as an invasion,
and the soldiers were occupying troops.
They also believe that military members
collaborate with Loyalist gangs
by offering access to intelligence and weapons.
JOHN WARE: I arrived in Northern Ireland
as a young newspaper reporter in 1974.
I live in Belfast < br /> for three years
when something like 600 people died.
In those days, the Army was ahead role in security.
Police support Army,
not the others go round.
So it's a classic rebellion.
That really civil war. That is a civil war.
The army is here midway Lenadoon Avenue.
-They come... - [LOUD FIRING]
... after the previous confrontation at the end...
REPORTER NEWS 1: Station the bus is crowded
when a bomb explodes without warning.
REPORTER NEWS 2: It's tragic, dangerous,
and the corner absurd from the United Kingdom.
BARRY McCAFFREY: Violence continues throughout the late 80s
and into the early 1990s.
The IRA has developed its bomb-making ability,
has been developed sniper attacks,
and very much now
fighting in urban areas against the British Army,
police and Loyalist paramilitaries.
People people have just been killed by Republicans, by Loyalists.
Everything really gets out of control.
The Loughinisland Massacre is just something
that always sticks with me.
There have been hundreds of lives
and massacres on all sides,
but for some reasons there are so many
questions that are not answered with Loughinisland.
It never goes away.
It's always on there behind the head.
I remember where I was on the eve of the massacre.
Republic of Ireland football team
was playing in Italy 1994 World Cup .
COMMENTATOR TELEVISION: I will say the biggest day
in Irish international football history.
GIBNEY: There's a reason < br /> everyone in Bar Heights
curled up on TV on the eve of the massacre.
There was a symbolic background to World Cup matches
at the Giants Stadium in New Jersey.
Ireland, this once, has a world class team
that seems to unite the Irish war is torn .
[FOOTBALL FANS CHANTING]
NIALL O & apos; DOWD: One picture I will always remember
going out to Meadowlands , match day,
and see these cars from everywhere.
Alabama, New Mexico, Minnesota, California,
all with the Irish flag < br>> to them,
and realize, do you know what, friends?
This is an home game for Ireland.
JIM GRACEY: When we walk to the stadium
and you enter and look out,
I just saw this ocean green.
You have this din, You have this Irish song,
You have this party is happening,
people dance in the stands, you know...
That's very big national expression.
GIBNEY: There is a feeling greater meaning for game, isn't there?
A feeling that the Problem might end?
Yes. Very much so.
You are always aware of from that fact
the sports arena is reflected Broader Ireland,
especially in Northern Ireland. </ P>
The game is ready currently a true breakthrough
and hope for Ireland the peace process.
GIBNEY: For Irish fans, the game is done feeling moments.
Just a few months before, < br /> Gerry Adams,
political negotiators for IRAs,
invited to America for informal peace talks
without more first abandoned violence.
[REPORTERS CLAMOURING]
O & apos; DOWD: We handed it to the President that the visa for Gerry Adams </ p >
will have a dynamic effect on the Irish peace process,
and he accepted it Despite that fact everyone around him,
included Minister of Foreign Affairs,
CIA, FBI, British government,
everyone strongly opposes that Adams visa.
He granted it visa to Adams,
and it's very big breakthrough.
I believe that by giving Mr. Adams this visa,
This limited visa Come here,
we may have a constructive role
in encouraging peace process.
[REPORTER SPEAKING]
There are a number of armed factions in my country,
the biggest < br /> are the British Army.
They are allies of Loyalist death squads
and the Republic of Ireland Army.
And I want to see the end to all armed factions.
GIBNEY: Seeing Adams being treated as a statesman
sucks into Loyalists and the British government.
They saw Adams as a terrorist,
and the American negotiator as pampering a man
who had blood in his hand.
Did the attack in the bar that night
how to hit on the peace to come?
The killers must < br /> think about the game
and the expectations it offers for people in the bar.
GRACEY: I remember not from anywhere
This ball fell into midfield for Ray Houghton.
He saw opportunities and he let fly.
I thought, "This can't last."
But when the game is running,
Republican grows in strength
and the Italians don't like it.
COMMENTATOR TELEVISION: History has been made at the Giants stadium.
Republic of Ireland has defeated Italy.
GRACEY: In the end, has defeated Italy,
that place went really angry. </ P>
We've dropped to the press center
and I called the office to Speak to the Deputy Editor.
And I said, "This is brilliant, Jim.
" I mean, it must be to be page 1 tomorrow . "
And he said, " This is not page 1 tomorrow. "
And I said," Why not? "
And he said, "We have had cruelty here. "
[MELANCHOLY MUSIC PLAYING]
McCAFFREY: Holiday cars have been found
the morning after the attack by a local farmer
who is watching the car on in its field,
seven miles from the attack scene.
At that time practicing for paramilitaries
carried out such attacks,
they will burn the car to destroy forensic evidence.
Unusual in Loughinisland attacks,
the car is left behind fully intact.
BINNS: I will be honest. I think it's fantastic.
will be able to
do something < br /> from the car.
You have a hair sample, you have fingerprints,
You know, there will be a lot...
Even in those days there will be
a forensic prize, gold mine.
McCAFFREY: Within six weeks,
was August 4, 1994,
rifle VZ58,
that has been used to kill everyone,
found in the field
not far from where it was the car was found .
Nearby with a handle found
containing gloves, pistol, balaclavas.
There are hair follicles found in one of balaclavas.
So there is wealth forensic possibilities.
There is a series of arrests
on July and August, uh, that year,
and there is a hope,
of course the family hopes,
that this all leads to people billed,
people who have do cruelty
charged and taken to court.
[SPEAKING]
[OPENING THE NEWS THEMES]
Good night. Six the week after the IRA said
his violent campaign was over,
Loyalist terrorists in Northern Ireland
had also stated truce called.
So the whole world attention
is in this new future Northern Ireland is facing.
Feelings of this new hope .
Like other cruelty,
Loughinisland becomes something you is not discussed,
because nobody wants > to reopen the past.
Seperti kekejaman lainnya,
Loughinisland menjadi sesuatu yang kamu tidak dibicarakan,
karena tidak ada yang mau untuk membuka kembali masa lalu.
The only people who remember Loughinisland
are family and loved ones.
CLAIRE: Time goes on,
and we choose to remain silent because it's our nature.
That's the nature of this community.
Go up with your life.
So we wait and we wait and,
You know, we shed some information about people, </ p >
the suspect has captured
and we continue to think, "Right, here it is now."
And then after around, I would say, a year, two years,
it stopped, no contact. </ P>
And again we chose just to stay calm down
and hope someday
there will be someone taken to court.
I think I, you know, deserve the truth
to find out what happened.
Like, my father is only 34 years old.
p>
It's not much older than what I am now.
Like, she's still young. For me she's old,
You know , he has a mustache and he is my father,
he is old, I am eight years old, he is, not an old man,
but he doesn't, he's 34 years old.
If I don't defend him
and I don't fight the corner of my father,
who else will do it?
I want someone to be held accountable
for what happened here.
NEWS REPORTERS: They may already
Brother of six men killed by UVF
in Loughinisland 12 years ago this Sunday
never spoke openly about the ordeal,
their sadness, or lack of it progress
in police hunting for the murderers.
But today , family gathered in Belfast
to demand answers.
Ten years with no information,
there is no relationship with family .
We don't know anything.
[O & apos; TOOE SPEAKING]
I can think of there is no reasonable reason
why does anyone make sense the police...
From the first consultation with family,
there are only feelings something that's not right.
Everything they want to know that's what happened.
At the end of 2005,
we had three meetings with senior police officers.
The police said, "We have boiler clothes,
" We have balaclavas,
we have weapons, we have a car. "
I thought," What is the car?
"Where's the car?"
Why don't you have a car?
Where the car?
[MUSIC SINISTER PLAYING]
[BLUNTING]
So where is the car?
"Oh, alright, you know , the car is destroyed.
"And, uh...
" But make sure it's all forensic opportunities
are realized from car. "
The biggest physical shows in this case,
and you have destroyed it?
GIBNEY: That car isn't the only disappeared.
All transcripts from the initial interview with the suspect
were also destroyed.
More than ten years,
even as the police keep it open,
the more entrances for the truth to close.
CLAIRE: To be honest,
we are always suspicious.
And on reflection,
sometimes I kind of feel a little guilty
that we do not speak up,
because it seems now that we are almost...
That's what they want we want to do.
They want we remain silent and this will disappear.
Every question we ask, we are told,
Oh, we don't know you are now,
You have to put it it is in writing.
No, we can't tell you that, that's national security.
We were thwarted all the time.
MAN: I don't know why the car was destroyed,
but the reality was destroyed...
One of the things I remember
it's five o'clock in the morning after the massacre.
My husband, he came out and cut grass.
It looks weird now, but people come and go and...
Those three policemen stand out
and there is a neighbor down,
scrolls down the window from the car and he says,
"You don't need to search further than there is it."
He said that.
That was his direct reaction.
p>
"You don't need to look further than they sound there."
EMMA: Someone came here and killed six people who didn't guilty
is left on the floor to die.
And not even that they did nothing.
Someone on somewhere help these people cover this,
help them go with it.
We want to know how high is this collusion walking?
There are six innocent people.
My father and I want the truth,
and I want to know why it happened,
and there is that question we need answers.
NEWS REPORTER: Last week, the police who had visited
did a new one investigation into Loughinisland,
catch a man and a woman,
but they are fast released at no cost.
The Police Ombudsman office has been confirmed
they have received complaints
from families in Loughinisland,
and they say they take out of the investigation.
GIBNEY: After the ceasefire,
Northern Ireland was founded
office of Police Ombudsman
as a way to try to take into account the past. </ P>
Its mission is not to resolve the crime. </ P>
to see into police mistakes,
includes collusion,
name catch all for corrupt relations
between police, informants and terrorist gangs.
Collusion first appeared in the mid to late 80s,
where the Republicans accused that there was collusion
among the police,
between members Army English
and Loyalist paramilitaries in the murder of the Nationalists. </ P>
NIALL MURPHY: Collusion is a feature
for 30 years conflict,
and the official line is that
every police or British soldier
is involved with Parliamentary paramilitaries
are bad apples. </ P>
WARE: Very much police officers,
collusion is enough poisonous words,
because it is very broad meaning, okay.
And it's not easy enter into some sort of criminal code.
I mean, collusion is feeling where
people give encouragement and wink and nod.
There is no criminal collusion violation.
However, if you worry
that the police were involved
in killing your lover,
or involved in colluding with that
who was killed your lover,
Ombudsman Police office has the responsibility
to investigate your complaint.
GIBNEY: In 2011, Al Hutchinson Ombudsman,
released the first report in Loughinisland. </ P>
Detailed Hutchinson report
some shocking facts about this case .
Some evidence has been destroyed,
Relationship of DNA with weapons mishandling,
and police informants have been involved
in selling vacation cars.
MURPHY: That was the first time those facts
were presented in an evidence-based mode.
However, one word > it will not appear in the report
is "collusion."
Al Hutchinson is carried out factual gymnastics
to avoid conclusions that.
We really, really disappointed with that.
And angry. Very, very angry.
On one stage I will do it have been loved
put my hands together circle his neck.
I remember in the media conference that day
there is one person,
he's a local friend here,
and he says,
there are two words missing from this report,
"Special" and "Branch."
GIBNEY: Special Branch intelligence unit > in the police
charged with watching terrorists
and handling informants.
There are many questions about what they know
and when,
and do they keep
that information for themselves,
or whether it was rubbed from the Hutchinson report.
It almost looked like that
the report started with the conclusion
and cut the pieces < > jigsaw to make it fit.
NEWS REPORTER: Last year, then the Ombudsman of the Police, Al Hutchinson,
published a report that criticized the investigation police,
but found not enough evidence of collusion.
Families strongly disagree with that conclusion
and initiate a lawsuit
to have an Ombudsman reverse findings.
This morning in the High Court,
The current Ombudsman, Michael Maguire,
agree that last year the report must be canceled.
EMMA: We are happy, we are proven right.
Mr. Maguire can now Go back and start again
and hopefully come out with a report
that gives us truth and justice.
NEWS REPORTER: So the way is now open
for the Police Ombudsman to start a new investigation. </ P>
Now more than 18 years </ p >
since the massacre in this bar.
At that time, 16 people had been arrested,
but no one had ever been accused of murder.
The family hoped
> Today's development
will be a step towards discovering the truth.
Chris Page, BBC Newsline, Loughinisland.
DR. MICHAEL MAGUIRE: The Loughinisland case
one of the iconic cases in the history of Northern Ireland,
the history of Troubles.
t is one of the cases that arrived at my desk
shortly after I was appointed in 2012.
What happened with the first report
is that very specifically focused
on the attack on Bar Heights on June 18,
so it looks investigation steps
TKP Management, and then the next step.
There are significant areas
that have not been investigated,
and that includes incidents leading to Loughinisland.
It's important to be expanded investigation
and effective back to the beginning.
[MUSIC PLAY DRAMATICS]
GIBNEY: In 2013, Michael Maguire and his team
started a new investigation to Loughinisland.
Like Hutchinson, Maguire decided not to disclose it
name of the source or suspect.
Police officers identified by numbers ,
possible suspects by letter.
Unlike the first report, Maguire Investigation
looked much deeper into the case
and what caused to the murder.
The report confirmed that UVF,
was a Protestant paramilitary group,
was responsible for Loughinisland attacks.
But his investigation denied the UVF claim
that had been there IRA meeting at the bar.
That had happened a tit for tat killing.
Three days before,
an IRA splinter group shot dead three leaders UVF
stood at the bus stop Shankill Road in Belfast. </ P>
UVF was called for revenge,
with orders from members < br /> to kill Catholics,
every Catholic.
McCAFFREY: People know there will be a
sort of retaliation.
p>
like this when one side attacks another,
there will be retaliation.
[SIREN WAILING]
MAGUIRE: Early police response
to attack that night, you know,
given the chaos that and terror
were around after that event,
as good as possible was expected.
They closed it crime scene,
they went out vehicle inspection points,
they install helicopters.
We check the flight time for the helicopter,
and that makes sense with conditions
the amount of time was in the air.
So the initial response from the police to the attack
seemed to us <
However, there are more serious
fundamental investigation problem
that appears is very fast.
McCAFFREY: In Dr. Maguire,
Police Officer 4,
he is a senior investigative officer
at night from Loughinisland. </ P>
He actually visited the attack scene.
There was a meeting that night from all senior detectives,
but then, in 24 hours,
at most 48 hours,
he goes on vacation
because I think that one month to six weeks.
>
The biggest mass murder in the area...
I will think, you know,
it will be one priority main.
But the first on the agenda is the vacation.
DENISON PHIL: Next day,
June 19, 1994,
the vehicle was found left in a field.
There are some mechanics problems occur with that vehicle
and there seems to be driven from the road,
and from there armed men,
and I include the driver in the description,
but armed people, the three people,
and we have witnesses ,
we see witness statements to describe three people.
So we say the three people,
a driver and two ,
has made them escape perhaps on foot.
what is really frustrating
is a poor person < Investigation practices
are carried out by the police.
There is no forensic examination
from the field afterwards.
And I know that sounds, sometimes sounds like that,
what would have to do with the field?
But actually the potential for harvesting from the field is very good.
You know, relevance of things like
botany, vegetation, soil typing.
If you can take soil samples
from someone shoes or clothes,
what you can do is potentially connect someone to the field.
If you can connect them to the field ,
You might be able to connect them to the car.
You know, this is a scrolling process.
But if you /> don't do that
and you did not collect it in the first example,
you missed the opportunity to do it.
The car itself, was allegedly sold
the day before the crime by a man in Belfast.
Call out to be seen the last registered guard the vehicle,
someone in Belfast,
and an officer assigned to go and investigate.
BINNS: So I was briefed to go to Belfast </ p >
and interview several people.
Most importantly, people who sell cars
just before the shooting takes place.
Because obviously it will be the link
for anyone shooting.
Now, it's not unusual
when you go to different areas
to go to the local police and local links.
They will have it local knowledge,
they will know personality.
They might have it a relationship,
some forms of work relationships
with those people so too .
What's unusual on this occasion is that I'm down,
I was told who I can talk to,
who I can't talk to,
and the people I talk to what they will say.
But just as important, what they will not say.
GIBNEY: By retrospect,
do you wonder about that day
in what matter you notified?
Look back, of course at that time,
I feel... the word I use is "set."
The interview has been set up.
The statement I want take is set.
The meeting is set.
I never speak to the man,
as, if I overall is responsible for the investigation,
who I want want to talk to.
But everything is happy with that.
So obviously there are a lot of things going above my head
that other people are looking for.
DENISON: Later on the day that,
Special Branch Officers met with
senior investigative officers
and senior members of the investigation team,
and spoken verbally those people
they believe will be responsible
for Loughinisland cruelty.
We are talking about the next day.
The attack is 10:00, for the sake of argument,
Ten o'clock on the 18th.
And we talk about
during the course day on the 19th.
This is only a few hours.
They saw in intelligence they had and said,
"These are your people really want to concentrate.
GIBNEY: That day after the massacre,
Special Branch suddenly revealed intelligence
about the suspects that they
> have taken care of themselves.
For the past six years,
the police have been aware of the men of the Loyalist gang
who have been involved
In 1986 in Dundrum, they tried to kill John O & Ros; Rourke,
and possibly involved in the assassination of Jack Kielty.
In November 1992,
they tried but failed to kill Peter McCarthy
at the Thierafurth Inn,
the place that the gang believed be IRA hang out,
eleven miles from Loughinisland.
The gang returns to Thierafurth Inn two weeks later
and kill another man named Peter McCormick.
It's scary like that murder in Loughinisland.
Those people drive used cars from Belfast,
use balaclavas and boilersuits,
and spray the bar with shots.
Three weeks later in Belfast , the same gang killed Martin Lavery.
The weapon used, nine millimeters of Browning,
was later found in a duffle bag
Used in the Loughinisland massacre.
>
No member the gang was ever sued
to do one of the murders.
MAGUIRE: Speak to Special Branch Officers ,
their intelligence efforts in the early 90s,
they started to gather intelligence
around the suspects in the murder.
The problem is that they don't share that intelligence
with the detective who is investigating the murder .
Slow Waltz is a policy used by the Special Branch
which means that the document will be released in a slow time.
So you have this situation where
researchers deal with
a little information,
but don't know < br /> larger images.
And of course, larger images
in the context from Loughinisland,
is the feeling there is this gang in operation,
they are involved in serious crime.
GIBNEY: In Maguire's investigation ,
the five suspects were identified only with letters.
People A, M, K, Me and b.
The leader is Person A.
In 1988, Person A was a member of the British Army,
who lived a few doors down from Loyalist club,
Clough Orange Hall,
where people do investigation Kielty's murder
find a gun, sub-machine gun,
ammunition and photo note Army,
montage, with images of from suspected IRA members. </ P>
One of them was targeted to be killed by a gang. </ P>
A person's fingerprint. is in montage. </ P>
He was arrested and prosecuted, but never punished. </ P>
When Person A is released,
the officer who caught remained concerned
about the threat submitted by Person A.
McCAFFREY: The detective was very concerned </ p >
that this individual
was a soldier during the day and a terrorist at night.
That was him very concerned that he was
p>
so that he gets thrown out out of the British Army.
GIBNEY: How exactly do you characterize Person A?
I will characterize it as < > I will characterize everything,
as cruel. </ P>
Really cruel. </ P>
A serial killer? </ P>
By definition, yes .
MURPHY: So in 24 hours
they have a car.
Special Branches can go down and tell the researchers
the names of the suspects.
However, is Person A arrested that day?
Is the door to his room kicked in the hallway?
Did he follow into a police station
and was asked to be responsible for his movements?
Was his house sought ? No.
Person A was not captured in the first sweep of arrest in July 1994.
In fact, Person A wasn't even captured
until almost two months later.
DENISON: We don't know why he wasn't arrested
in July with other people.
The house was ransacked.
Whether it's true or not a case that he wasn't there
and there was a job came out to find it,
I just don't know.
MAGUIRE: One of the difficulties that we found
in conducting our investigation was a log policy
you will do it expected
with the senior investigative officer,
it will be written,
"I have decided not to do this arrest this person because...
"I want to understand more information,
or because I want to do it, you know, something else."
All documentation Not available to us.
It's no longer available,
because asbestos is a problem with the police station.
They've destroyed a lot < br /> documentation,
includes interview records potential suspects.
DENISON: I have vehicles recovered,
I have potential Forensic harvest.
You know, if I can hit someone quite early
and there's something weak among this team,
they might start falling.
GIBNEY: How come? they don't do it?
Good question.
I don't know .
And I don't know because a senior investigative officer
hasn't spoken to me.
GIBNEY: One key police officer is responsible for the investigation
from Loughinisland has retired,
which means he can refuse cooperate with Maguire.
That leaves the mist of mystery
more than why the police allows key suspects
time to cover their tracks.
LEVEL: This is rotten to the core.
The fact that SIO in the case of Loughinisland
has courage refuses to cooperate.
What do you mean by that?
Something that isn't here. </ P>
You know, that's one thing when people lose their lives. </ P>
Once upon a time there was great cruelty
and no one else is taken to the book.
But it becomes a completely different thing
when there are no people taken to the book
because someone else did not do the job correctly,
or someone else covered it.
GIBNEY: The family suspects
that the investigation may have been mismanaged intentionally,
is possible to protect an informant. </ P>
Throughout the Problem,
the British government used informants, called brokers,
to infiltrate terrorist groups and provide intelligence.
Let's talk about the UK handling government informants.
Yes.
Are there problems balancing the benefits information obtained
with the cost of protecting malicious sources?
That is always a difficult problem,
because it's right through the Troubles period, </ p >
some very brave people stand up and say,
"This is destroying our country, destroying the province.
Many lives people are at risk. "
And so many people courage is provided intelligence
that is seriously prevented anger occurs.
Now, the current question
are they handled correctly,
is that accurate information,
and are they are people
who can be fully trusted
and are working all the time in law.
So you have an informant
who works organized crime gangs.
At what level is individuals allowed to work?
Is he allowed /> lead the organization?
Does he go to a place that is very for the organization?
And what is that danger?
Is he part from operating plans?
And of course, if not authorize them to do it,
their fellow partners and gang members </ p >
would like to know why is this person,
why not take part in this.
This problem was kicked around year officials year after year.
Everyone struggles
how do you make something
real criminal not a criminal?
And no one can do it.
However they try, no one can fix it.
People make decisions at a high level
to continue running the source not good people,
these people, you won't want to walk through your door.
You don't like dealing with them,
p>
but unfortunately they still save lives.
That is a pretty shady world,
but it's one of them you have to accept.
Very frustrating.
And...
The informant is terrible to work with.
[CHUCKLES]
I mean, part of my job as a Detective interviewing terrorists,
even interviewing ordinary criminals,
and to some extent, of course criminal level,
You will run, operate the informant like the Detective will.
They very important.
But what appears
there may be more than that is allowed to continue
than it should.
And who runs it is a different question. </ P>
You have a police officer who will run the informant,
but you also have a military
who will be running the informant.
HUTCHINSON: Organization that I go to prison for,
Ulster Volunteer Force,
people like police and others
have infiltrated them.
People in British security definite service,
you know, recruit people
and put it into the organization.
And on several occasions when the police do this,
they only see so that people give they are information,
is not a large piece of information,
but then if they grow a sizeable person in that organization
then, you know, this is more than just information.
It's about how they do it destroy the organization?
And they do it from within.
They create confusion.
They give wrong information. People start getting killed.
GIBNEY: Dangers of running the informant who is placed very high come
when the agents, under state protection,
start killing people.
One of the most widely known examples
is not from UVF,
but from the IRA.
He is a very placed tout ,
is responsible for the torture and the killing of other brokers.
The name is Freddy Scappaticci,
the code name is Stakeknife.
MORRISON: Scappaticci was imprisoned,
an apprentice in the 1970s.
Then he became an IRA member.
I know him, not really, but I know him.
He is an my acquaintance.
I have seen it on the show Republic, at funerals, etc.
makes them acknowledge that they are informants,
and then submit them to the IRA who killed them.
And the people who are there /> run these agents
know it's another agent involved
in the murder from the agent
who is actually work for the country,
and should be protected by the state
from that point of view.
GIBNEY: How is this? beneficial for the country
to have this person kill all these people
who is the informant on the IRA?
Because I understanding that
the people who Scappaticci are interrogating,
are people who are lower level IRAs
suspected to be an informant.
So the value is to the Special Branch,
or to British Intelligence has run the path.
So they see further advantages
in having their men, Stakeknife,
be the one who said,
"That person is guilty. I have destroyed it interrogated.
He must be executed."
GIBNEY: To be clear,
that is the IRA executing.
But since the British agent is located running the broker system,
the state's moral status can be compromised
by the knowledge of the crimes committed.
That gives the informant the power more than a handler them.
MORRISON: Freddy Scappaticci has been billed.
Freddy Scappaticci will say to the handler,
"Jika saya turun, Anda akan turun. "
And the handler will do it turn and say
to the British government,
"If I go down,
" Number 10 Downing Street < br /> will come down too,
"Because you know all this time about dirty wars,
about what we were asked to do and what we do. "
The paper trail will lead to 10 Downing Street,
and they cannot allow to occur.
WARE : There Scappaticci images
that sort of captures how real
the world secret agent has become. </ P>
He walks behind a man
who is a former senior IRA member,
next to the coffin whose brother, Ruby Davison,
who actually an informant.
So we have Gerry Adams bring a coffin from an informant,
Scappaticci who's is an informant,
and there is more The informant outside the picture
who is responsible for this murder in the first place.
It's kind of madness.
MORRISON: This British government
is involved in killing people.
As if they were sitting in their room in Surrey, or in Kent,
playing war games with our lives here. </ P>
GIBNEY: Are running and protection so many informants, </ p >
all with ulterior motives, out of control?
That is a haunted question the Loughinisland case,
and the murder weapon method makes the way into the hands of the killers.
[MUSIC DRAMATIC PLAY]
DENISON: The weapon used in Loughinisland is VZ58.
This is Czec made assault rifle .
It looks like AK47 people recognize,
and often are called AK47.
If the weapon is used in Loughinisland ,
how can that happen to the province?
GIBNEY: To track how the weapon
goes into hand from the UVF gunman,
you must understand the story of the arms race
between the Loyalists paramilitaries and the IRA.
IRA who first smuggled
powerful weapons from abroad.
They made a deal with Libya Gadaffi
to give them enough military artillery
for two infantry battalions,
including machine guns,
surface to air missiles and Semtex explosives.
[HARD EXPLOSION]
IRAs carry campaigns to the British capital, London.
For several years IRA bombs exploded in cities
and throughout the UK.
From the lower train station land to financial markets.
One mortar attack almost killed Prime Minister John Major.
REPORTER NEWS: courage was from the attack Londoners were shocked.
Apparently the van stopped for several minutes
outside the Ministry of Defense at Whitehall.
The British Parliament is only a few hundred meters away.
McCAFFREY: The IRA is sure to come to the conclusion
that a bomb in London is worth ten bombs in Northern Ireland.
[SIREN WAILING]
KILPATRICK: That's one of them > best strategy IRAs have ever had,
because our opinion in Northern Ireland
is an Englishman the government believes
there is something acceptable level of violence.
A policeman is killed in Northern Ireland,
a young Catholic is killed,
A Protestant killed,
a soldier killed
does not mean much to the British people.
They are right really don't care, To be honest.
You took over the war to England
and you put it under pressure,
and that's what they did with the London bombing.
Some of them, and other bombings later on.
GIBNEY: English IRA campaign
causes escalation threats by the Loyalists.
That raises questions about whether the British government
is trying hard enough to stop the Loyalists
from greater and better weapons.
MAGUIRE: For Loyalist paramilitaries,
there are strategic decisions
to do what they call back to service.
[DISTAN DISORDERS] [PEOPLE SCREAMING]
So by attacking community Catholics
and by terrorizing the Catholic community,
this is the way bring the game,
when they see it, to IRA.
Thus in their view,
put pressure on the IRA to stop their campaign.
[SPEAKING]
And they need weapons to be able to do that.
As part of our investigation,
we found the document that was discussed an informant
that was reported to the Special Branch in the late 1980s.
He said that Parliamentary paramilitaries
were preparing to buy weapons from abroad.
GIBNEY: Does the United Kingdom
bring the weapon to Northern Ireland?
What is it? did you find it?
No, I won't go this far like saying that.
Does the country know that? weapons for Loyalists come?
Does the country know?
Country, clear from what we have seen,
the country knows that there are plans in progress
to bring weapons.
GIBNEY: At the end of 1987,
the British government was watching coastal waters.
The police knew that Loyalist gangs
had robbed the bank to buy weapons from South Africa.
At the end of December, the informant was told
the army, and the police,
that the weapon is approaching Northern Ireland,
hidden under the floor tiles on the container ship.
Then mysteriously, the government lost track of the ship
and the weapons landed somewhere near Belfast.
WARE: That is shipping large enough
to equip the small Army.
I mean, we are talking around hundreds of
automatic weapons,
fragmentation grenades,
rocket launchers, pistols.
Tens of thousands ammunition.
We know from Ombudsman reports
that after sending weapons entered,
they were detained in the farmhouse from one James Mitchell.
Mitchell's farmhouse was in the heart of
what was known as Glennane's gang.
Glennane's gang consists of
from UVF members,
serving the army, serving police officers.
p>
From James Mitchell 's farmhouse,
the most terrible acts of terrorism have been planned,
will return at least until 1974.
They turn around,
machine guns people go to the bar,
disguise themselves as soldiers their uniforms at night
in the checkpoint and fire people.
They are scary, scary.
And they are members of of the Security Forces.
GIBNEY: On the farm,
the weapons are waiting divided into three ways
between the three Loyalist gangs,
one of them is UVF .
On January 8, 1988,
three cars departed from Belfast to be picked up their shares.
One of the cars was followed by police,
who have been given information by Loyalist informants.
MURPHY: Surveillance operations lose sight of these people ,
and therefore, can't
track them locations where
the overall disposal of weapons is being stored.
But after they leave the farm, </ p >
they were picked up, two Ford Granadas,
who were burdened with with dozens of rifles VZ58.
The suspects found driving both Ford This Granadas,
have straw and dirt and carry their boots,
so they know that they have done it the type of farm area.
And the intelligence of the police knows all about Agriculture James Mitchell,
but they don't go there.
I just want to know , "Hmm. A farmhouse near here. </ P>
Now, I wonder, could it be that James Mitchell farmhouse?" </ P>
The idea that it wasn't even happens to them
goes beyond belief.
Especially because shortly after the arrest of
from the Loyalists that cars are full of weapons,
someone informed James Mitchell
that the security forces might be coming soon
to see the farm.
And the rest of the weapon moved very quickly.
So, you got half country
trying to sentence this item,
and you have other parts
in intelligence gathering communities
determined to weaken that effort,
and they succeed in doing so.
This is a terrible story.
A truly horrible story.
[GUNFIRE]
KILPATRICK: UVF, they end with
abilities they didn't have before.
Paintings appeared on the wall
of people standing with VZ58s.
Weapons escaped,
and they were used in murder, more than 70 murders.
At least 70, seven zeros
killed by gun alone.
How many people were killed by bullets
and fragmentation of grenades,
and the rest... we don't know.
Lots of people die as a result
the weapon comes to Northern Ireland .
One of the weapons was left the farm in Glennane
and will reach the conclusion of his murder
on June 18, 1994, in Loughinisland.
There are ballistics special traces.
The serial number the weapon was used in Loughinisland
fell specifically in between two weapons
that were rediscovered after weapons import in January 1988.
[LAUGH] [CAR IDLING]
COMMENTATOR TELEVISION: Well, that's amazing <br a happy start,
and of course the team played
as if they were among the elite, and rightly so.
GIBNEY: And the camera maker. [MARKER CLAPS]
So, about six months after the massacre,
the police have significant < br /> breakthrough
when they receive anonymous calls?
From what I understand,
calls are made to reporting lines secret
managed by RUC,
and basically, basically wants to provide information
for potential identities
of people involved in shooting ,
in the shooting in Loughinisland,
and gave the name in relation to that.
GIBNEY: And are the names that the same name of the suspects?
DENISON: They are all relevant name, yes. Oh yeah.
And it's not that too far then
when followed up with an anonymous letter written
sent to the local councilor,
it is again articulated same information
and calling the same person as involved.
GIBNEY: But you can't be sure
does the police know who is this anonymous source is
Yes, the police know who the source is, yes.
And do you know? How do they know?
Alex, you took me to an area
I don't really want to go to,
because of constraints from where I operate under.
I mean, the police have information
where they can be exploited
and I don't think they did it very well.
I think that's all I am ready to say on this stage.
GIBNEY: How exactly are the police
able identify this anonymous caller,
remember that anonymous?
[SIGHS HEAVILY]
I just, I just took it for a moment to think
about some potential danger in this line.
And I fully appreciate where you want to go with this,
what do you want to pick it up,
but I also really /> be aware of the potential,
the potential danger behind it.
Because I can answer it,
but I know you what the next question is,
and I will go, at that point I will close you at all,
because of this...
because I will ask the same question be in your shoes.
GIBNEY: It's there other proof,
or other information who came...
Of course, I want to know the name of anonymous callers,
and whether that is the same person who wrote the letter.
But the researchers did not speak.
To protect witnesses, they are willing to tell us storyline,
but not the name of the character.
So, Ombudsman Investigation
is a confusing scrub letters and numbers
"Person A, Person M, Police Officer 12." </ p >
Who are these people?
The answers appear on the form other anonymous tips.
In 2011, someone was upset by Loughinisland cover,
leak the document to journalist Barry McCaffrey.
McCAFFREY: Leaked documents come in the mail.
I still don't know to this day
what someone stabbed a conscience to send it.
Maybe that was the fact that. ..
they know we are working on this story
and the family did not get an answer,
or not was given the answer.
The document unpublished report </ p >
brought by Previous Ombudsman
to Loughinisland cruelty.
This report has been preceded Al Hutchinson Report.
It's been 2008.
GIBNEY: The leaked report is a concept,
so it's uncivilized.
It contains the original name < br /> and important details
about existing cases never disclosed.
Anonymous text missing letter,
but report it was revealed the man's name
to whom the letter was sent.
Patsy Toman, a local politician
arrived at the Bar Heights right after shooting. </ P>
[SPEAKING]
PATSY TOMAN: I got this letter on Valentine's Day,
and I said maybe someone sent me a Valentine card.
But when I read it, I found it it was serious,
and very serious. </ P>
And it looks like...
I thought it was the writing of a woman,
sort of writing.
"Dear Mr. Toman, I wrote to advise you facts
"I think it will be so interesting to you
" in your search at home Loughinisland murder.
"When I see you on TV after checking,
"I feel that I have to tell someone what I know.
" People it was captured after the murder
"indeed close to the culprit.
Commander operation... "
No, I'm sorry, I won't read it.
No thanks. </ p >
[SPEAKING]
GIBNEY: Patsy has reasons to be afraid.
Before Loughinisland massacre,
his house was bombed by Loyalist terrorists.
More than 20 years later,
he was still afraid to read that part of the letter
was named < br /> the murder suspects.
[SPEAKING]
Alright?
GIBNEY: Patsy has given an original letter to the police ,
who then lost it.
But Patsy kept a copy of
and was willing to share it years later with Barry McCaffrey.
"The gunman one Ronnie Hawthorn,
"The married man from Clough.
" Gunman two is Alan Taylor, one from Dundrum.
"Holiday car driver is Gorman McMullan,
"Terrorists sentenced from Belfast
" and leading lights in Belfast UVF. </ P>
"I know the info secret this, because I have been
"In the initial planning of of murder.
" I withdrew from the attack because of the previous engagement
"That I can't cover up.
" The police do have interrogated children,
"But as a police officer told me,
& apos; "We know who did it, but we can't prove it.
" and without proof or their statement will be free. & apos;
"Hawthorn and Taylor, they took part in the attack
" at the Thierafurth pub in Kilcoo a few years ago,
"and various other incidents in the area.
"This information will somehow ease my conscience,
" but it will never be fully clean my name .
"But I did this for the family and children
" of the people who were there slaughtered in Loughinisland.
Contribute, may we all live in peace. "
GIBNEY: It turns out that people are called murderers
in anonymous letters <br Also the main suspect
was mentioned in the leaked report.
Is this the same person Maguire focused
on the investigation?
We see both documents,
and with cross references date of capture,
is able to decode and name to all cyphers.
My person Gorman McMullan,
is named after the letter as the driver.
M people are Alan Taylor,
named as the man who holds the door.
Person A, is accused of the gang leader and the gunman,
is Ronald Hawthorn.
Leaked documents reveal something else.
Book author anonymous letters
and people which makes it anonymous phone calls
are one and the same.
Hillary Hawthorn, Ronnie Hawthorn's wife.
We don't know what Hillary Hawthorn looks like.
There is no picture of him or Ronnie Hawthorn online.
We found an article about Catching Ronnie for a photo montage.
We found Ronnie and Hillary marriage certificate. </ P>
They married in Presbyterian church in Clough,
a few miles from Loughinisland,
ten years before the murder.
He was 24, he was 18 years old.
Did he know what kind of person was he married?
p>
We also know that Hillary is close to the local police.
The detective tells me she really works
in the cafeteria Newcastle Police Station. </ P>
That's how they recognize his voice
when he was made anonymous calls. </ P>
The regional police said he did it to punish her husband for having an affair.
What is hard to understand
why was he never accused of crime.
MURPHY: He was indeed arrested,
but we don't know what said in the interview,
because the police happened to be < br /> destroy the note
and we don't know why he is not prosecuted.
But the line in this letter which states,
"I know the secret for this information,
because I'm original planning for murder."
How is this one person not charged fee
before the court with conspiracy to murder,
and who knows what the author of this letter
ingin melakukannya
in the event that even might change the proof of the state.
We don't know, because he was not prosecuted.
GIBNEY: Question why
refers to the man who interrogates Hillary Hawthorn,
Police Officer 4, Detective Inspector Albert Carroll.
Turns out he SIO Deputy in charge of from Loughinisland,
but went on vacation the day after the murder. </ P>
He was also involved > in the other three murder investigations
regarding the Hawthorne gang.
He retired in 2011.
Barry McCaffrey went looking for him.
Where did you find Albert Carroll?
In a small village in France.
It took a long time to convince him even meet us.
We have met him in a small hotel.
Mr. Carroll, he can't explain to us
why isn't he being sued Hillary with a conspiracy. </ P>
I got a different one that impression
p>
Mr. Carroll wants to know more about what we know about him
than what he will do tell us about Loughinisland. </ P>
GIBNEY: Did you show Albert Carroll
the leaked report where was he named? </ P>
Yes. </ P>
What is the reaction
when he saw how much do you know about his role?
He polluted himself.
[CREW LAUGH]
Yes. </ p >
He is very defensive...
Yes, yes.
GIBNEY: Carroll keeps a secret,
but he reveals new details.
When Hillary was arrested, Ronnie was there.
Ronnie knows about the letter and why it was written.
But instead of filling Hillary,
or using him to get to Ronnie,
Carroll releases him with a vague promise
that he will help ensure
that her husband will not kill in the future.
What do you suspect? is the reason
Hillary is never billed?
I suspect
that the author this letter
was not billed to ensure
that the police were wider
the intelligence agenda was not interrupted.
There is a sort of culture
image building.
Requirements for intelligence gathering are
more strategic than that
to serve criminals justice system.
And the intelligence tail starts wiggling the dog. </ P>
GIBNEY: The problem depends on the case. </ P>
What is intelligence and protects the informant
more important than solving crimes?
And just before the murder,
what did the police know and when did they know that?
BINNS: So two, maybe three months after the murder,
on a certain night, late at night,
half hour 10:00, 11 o'clock,
I am in the country bar, that should be
about ten or 15 miles far away from Loughinisland.
And two detectives entered, my colleagues.
They just visited a meeting in Armagh,
which senior > Detective Chief Inspector will become. </ P>
And in that conversation with one of them,
of ear shots from someone else,
p>
what was said to me was that there was a phone call
made at 6:00 a.m. night filming,
and that the shooting < br /> has been canceled.
There have been telephone calls made by the informant
at 6:00 a.m.
said the shooting has been canceled,
because the car is unreliable.
GIBNEY: We know that the murder was not canceled,
that there are plans,
and that the killers have problems with their cars?
[READING DENISON]
GIBNEY: < br /> According to the letter,
Person A is Ronnie Hawthorn, the shooter.
My person is McMullan, driver.
M people are Alan Taylor, the man holding the door.
An informant told the police
that the three of them were on Main Street in Newcastle?
Yes.
"During tea June 18, 1994,
" phone calls were made to Frenchie & apos; s Bar,
"either by Person A or Person M,
asking to speak Person B immediately."
GIBNEY: How can Special Branch knows that?
I can't tell you that.
I know how they know that,
but I can't tell you, I'm sorry.
This is very legitimate how are they know that.
Is there a bug calling?
This is not.
Well, it is one of those people involving an informant?
DENISON: What I will say is that
we have seen intelligence that says
one the legitimate suspect in the investigation
was a police informant
and continued for some time afterwards.
GIBNEY: And that can happened more than one,
or at least one?
At least one.
I mean, we have specifically identified one
uh, inside the suspect that group
for our investigation the purpose is relevant.
But of course there can be more than one in it,
but we only concerned with one.
BINNS: Generally on the ground,
people want to solve crimes and catch criminals.
But in Loughinisland, the informant was involved,
and that's where the line became blurry. </ P>
If the event took place without any informants,
it's only direct murder
nothing can be done about, no one knows about it.
But then when something can intervene and no,
that raises lots of questions.
McCAFFREY: Special Branch has intelligence
on these individuals before the attack
and then the vacation car is found
a short distance from family home
Man A, Ronnie Hawthorn.
But the police never looked for Hawthorns family home.
It was never searched.
MAGUIRE: Another critical piece of information
we found disturbing was that
individuals who were arrested in August,
at the end of August,
were warned the night before
that they will be arrested.
And then for that,
we know that the police then get more information
that the individual who warned them
had become a police officer,
and that was very concerning.
GIBNEY: Of the four suspects warned,
the most important is Person A, Ronnie Hawthorn.
Before going to Loughinisland,
he has been charged connection with one murder
and was involved in another string.
In the case of slaughter,
he was named that day after being suspected of being possible,
and the vacation car was found within walking distance
from his family's home.
Even though the police waited two months
before Hawthorn finally was taken for questioning.
BINNS: We interviewed Hawthorn, huh.
He has been arrested early morning,
maybe five o'clock, six o'clock in the morning.
GIBNEY: Is Hawthorn itself seems arrogant in the interview?
I mean, is he, You know, quite relaxed?
He is not stressed, that is certain.
In my mind he is just a terrorist.
Only a person who is hateful... a hatred...
uh, fanatic you know,
Killing a Catholic to him like wiping his shoes,
flies from his shoes.
That's him for me.
And if I have blocking his way ,
I don't doubt he has shot me too.
GIBNEY: Inside the police station,
the interrogation more than a little strange.
The actual question about Loughinisland
only lasts about ten minutes.
[GATE CLANGS SHUT ]
This is a kind of from plays,
it's like I have to talk to you about something,
but we only pretend to be here?
"We have to be here for two hours, let's chat.
"Okay? We have to do it to be here for two hours. </ P>
You killed these people, You are a gunman. "
" No, I'm not. "
" All right.
"You know, we won't go to get a place here.
"You won't admit it.
It's okay, let's chat. "
GIBNEY: Then the conversation
turned away from interrogating Hawthorn,
to encourage him to commit murder.
To kill an IRA gunman who is a threat to the Detective.
BINNS: So this Detective spends most of the time
telling Hawthorn that if he does not kill this Catholic armed men immediately,
this Catholic gunman will make it.
So you tell the cat turn off the mouse
before the mouse makes you,
because I'm afraid of the mice that killed me.
If that makes sense.
GIBNEY: So he tells Hawthorn,
"You better get this Catholic gunman." </ P>
"Because he left to get you." </ P>
But why did he do that? </ P> >
Because I petrified it the man came for me.
And then Hawthorn was released from Armagh, Gough Barracks,
maybe about six o'clock the next night.
It's just disgusting, first.
GIBNEY: Five years later, Hawthorn is captured again.
DNA tests on hair found in the duffle bag
revealed a match for the Hawthorn family.
But within a day he was released
caused by proof not enough.
I never wanted to believe there was collusion
in one of the murders I was on.
But Loughinisland, You have to say someone is being protected.
And the truth is happening detained from family.
There are no vehicles at all to complete the murder.
[SOLEMN MUSIC PLAYING]
GIBNEY: Hope for the family arrives
with that notification the Ombudsman is near
the end of the investigation.
In the spring of 2016,
I traveled back to Loughinisland for now
in a private meeting with the victim's family
when will Maguire reveal it what did he find.
CLAIRE: What do you think the results of this will happen?
EMMA : I don't know, I almost fear thinking about it. </ P>
I don't want to think about that too. </ P>
It can't be worse < br /> than the last one,
but you can't survive lots of hope.
No.
We have been disappointed Multiplied again,
we don't want to get our hope again.
No but...
It's hard to believe that after so many long time
they might finally admit the truth.
Hopefully.
CLAIRE: My grandchildren are now starting to ask,
"What happened to Grandad?
Has anyone gone to jail? Is there being punished? "
Because children are taught from a height not
if you are wrong you will be punished.
Should you sent to your room or, you know,
you won't get it candy or whatever.
You have to study...
EMMA: Get you Play Station taken from you.
Play your station, whatever. I see...
So, I need an answer for him.
[CHATTER INDISTINCT]
Okay, ready to go?
Good afternoon.
ALL: Good afternoon. </ p >
Um...
Today is the day
we have already waiting.
It's been a long time,
it's longer than it should be already, I think,
and I am of course aware of people
who wants already here,
but can't pass the passage of time,
and my sympathy for those families.
Thank you for following my as we approach
to the publication this report.
I appreciate your patience,
even though I admit that sometimes
we don't deserve it.
But I'm grateful the fact you have work with me
while we have edged towards the publication this document.
I will tell you my conclusion, </ p >
then I go to tell you
how I arrived to that conclusion
based on the information we received.
When I see in all the information,
I will explain this afternoon,
I don't hesitate saying that collusion
is an important element
in relation to murder in Loughinisland.
This report is divided into three areas.
Import weapons in 1987,
events before attack on Loughinisland,
investigation into...
MURPHY: This is 22 years that these families
have waited patiently,
p>
with dignity, they have campaigned fiercely.
Everyone knows the pain and trauma
that you have gone through.
has dignity returned to them.
That's what we want is someone to tell the truth.
Everyone < br /> in this room,
what we want is the truth about what happened.
CLAIRE: It's hard to accept.
There are parts of it You have to park it,
because I can't take it all.
Sorry.
[ HANDBOOK]
This report is one of most burdensome expositions
state collusion in mass murder
ever there has been published.
We have the truth today, 22 years.
Now it's time for justice and accountability.
We all deserve to receive it and demand justice
from the British government who is responsible.
CASEMENT: This is the tip of the iceberg,
but there are still two thirds it is buried below.
Publication the report,
it causes ripples,
that it has happened to many other cases </ p >
and many people hopefully
will get little hope
that they can get answers somewhere along the line,
and just save hammering it.
This is 160 pages.
If you remember the last one reported in 2011 was 63 page,
and the substance may be around 55.
So there is a very large number of details in this case
GIBNEY: Temuan itu kolusi adalah kemenangan untuk keluarga.
But there are a lot of details that aren't revealed to them.
These details I've found.
The names of the murder suspect,
fill in the letter,
the strange role is played by the suspect the wife of an armed man.
Then there's the question <br Why is the police
still denied to charge anyone.
It is connected to the mystery that still haunts the case.
Who is the informant?
MURPHY: There must be an accountability.
Maguire has more information to give us a briefing, </ p >
so what he told us had made headlines and they...
There were others incidents and murders
which is called in the report,
and I have been approached by some of those families,
one of them is the family from Martin Lavery,
who was killed on 20 December, 1992. </ P>
We know from that report
the four people were responsible for his murder. </ P>
People A, M , K and my people. </ P>
The Lavery family, correctly,
feels there is a question
that they have it a decent answer to.
Through a process of legal disclosure
at a meeting with people in a position to know ,
Mr. Lavery's family asked firmly
was one of the people involved
in the Martin murder /> an informant?
We were told that at at the time of Martin's murder,
none of them were informants.
However, one of them individuals was the informant
at the time of Loughinisland atrocities.
GIBNEY: Knowing that one in four people,
I approach the source with access to Special Branch files. </ P>
Nervous, he won't name names,
but he confirms that one of the gangs that night
works for British country as an informant
when Person A, Ronnie Hawthorne,
is reportedly emptying the weapon being a bar full of people
watching the World Cup.
One of the things we have learned,
is not in the Maguire report,
is that among the gangs who killed your husband ,
there is at least one informant.
Have you ever heard that?
No.
Does that surprise you?
Not really.
Nothing is surprising me again.
[Sighs] Um...
I think it's news for me,
but not. No, nothing surprised me.
I just don't know
how really foul this whole system is.
COMMENTATOR TELEVISION: There are shots and This is Ireland's destination.
GIBNEY: I told the family what I learned
about the massacre
that went beyond < br>> Maguire reports.
Suspect names,
and my suspicions that they are still protected
by some parts British government.
People named as second shooters, Alan Taylor,
left Northern Ireland in the late 90s,
and was last seen in the UK.
Gorman McMullan, the man was named the driver of the car ,
living in Belfast.
A member of H and W Welder Club,
he regularly turns out for parades
celebrate UVF,
and appear on social media on the sex club website.
If you drive four miles from Loughinisland ,
you can find village roads
scattered with beautiful houses,
where is Person A, Ronnie Hawthorn, life.
He is still together with his wife Hillary,
who named him as a gunman.
When calls and letters failed get an answer,
we rent private eyes
to see if we can find out what looks like.
[CAMERA SHUTTER SNAPPING]
This photo they both work.
>
They have a small company who cleans the office,
and for companies controlled by pests,
offers destruction services.
[O & apos; TOOE SPEAKING]
Then...
[O & apos; TOOE SPEAKING]
CLAIRE: This is a kind of brand /> I look over my shoulder
that I can meet these people in the course my work,
or go to the store.
I might not know what form is like,
but they will know me.
And that makes me a little,
if not much...
GIBNEY: It's hard to understand why,
more than 20 years after that crime,
when so many things are known about the suspects,
that they cannot be prosecuted.
Of course, even if proven guilty,
they will only serve two years.
To bring peace to Northern Ireland,
that is an agreement made under Good Friday Agreement,
for each murder involved with Troubles.
MAYHEW: For those who have killed these people,
you will be caught sooner or later.
The RUC never gives up.
And you will be arrested and you will spend years in prison.
Thank you very much.
CLAIRE: The government first tried to use us as pawns
to try and bring peace to Northern Ireland.
Protecting informants is far more important
than bringing people to court
that was done this atrocity.
It looks like as if hands tied.
That...
GIBNEY: What do you mean?
I think it rises higher.
I really believe that. </ P>
we believe that
went so far, right up. </ P>
WARE: What happened The country leaving
turns a blind eye for this murder activity?
It is very difficult to appear with an answer.
That must happen pretty good. </ P>
Saya tidak bisa membayangkan apa itu mungkin.
The fact is, I will say further
the prize cannot be possible
according to the consequences of that death.
p>
The reason is important Loughinisland,
because of that other insights
become that kind of compromise
that we as a state are made on moral and legal standards.
Every democracy must make that compromise.
We, I think, are made, uh...
more compromises
than many of us have realized,
because more images hidden pasts are revealed.
GIBNEY: Year after year,
the past was ruled out to make room for the future.
But for the families of the victims, it's hard to accept.
and take into account what happened and why.
Surrounded by mountains notes
with many answers,
government officials Decide every day
What they think is good to remember,
and what is better to be forgotten.
Submitted by: www.subtitlecinema.com