I drove him to school That morning like I always do,
and expected to pick him up around 5:30 from the track training.
He sneaks out of the house
friends to back-to-school parties.
They end at Hardees
not too far from where I live
That afternoon,
around four o'clock, I got a phone call from one of his friends,
and he said that he had a note for me,
says that he loves us
and he must go and go find himself.
Someone returns home,
other young women get into a car with several men,
and M.A. don't want to get into the car
And that's when a woman approaches her,
tell him that he will go to help him return home
And what he does is he...
Takes him into the life of hell.
Putri Kubiiki, M.A., who is 13 years old,
and daughter of Nacole, J.S., aged 15,
now includes 1.6 million homeless people
and runaway children in America.
Within a few hours after releasing radar,
thousands of them will be traded sex.
A polite term for repeatedly raped
Here's the story the girls and their parents,
and their struggle against a legal and political system
that protects website earnings millions of dollars a year.
A website where children are bought and sold,
with a little more than click the mouse
That is the third link from above.
It has a star and a heart.
And that said, "Young and new."
But that star and heart attract my attention
So I clicked it and...
There is a photo of my daughter.
I call and ask to buy the service itself.
We return it, But he is addicted to drugs.
He is very abused.
He ran away twice more.
I said, "Why did you run away?"
And he said, "Okay, mother, I have to go and take this pill."
And I'm like, "what pill?"
And that's when I learned about other things,
You know, that he shot him...
The next thing you know, boom.
My daughter was stabbed and burned,
and his head is shaved,
and he was beaten.
Drug dealers are tried.
He was given a five-year sentence.
He is responsible for the part of his crime.
As soon as I told him
about all the pain and suffering I experienced
and I want revenge, he also did it.
For companies that are assisted by
My 13 year ad children for sale,
they are not responsible
Visit www.Fastbet99.club Trusted Trusted Online Gambling Agent
We use it for buying and selling sofa, TV, video games.
I never knew
that there are also humans sold.
Visit www.Fastbet99.club Trusted Trusted Online Gambling Agent
He calls them repeatedly,
ask them to delete the picture from his 13-year-old daughter,
that is still online
They refuse.
This makes Kubiiki a collision Of course with a Federal Judge,
special interest groups, and company money,
all stick to the law which has been interpreted
to provide a safe place for many things online,
including buying and selling children.
Because the photo of her daughter is still online,
Kubiiki then takes the immediate goal Visit www.Fastbet99.club Trusted Secure Online Gambling Agent
Pedroli and Gauthier, how can I help you
I believe we the first person to demand Backpage
on behalf of traded parents.
I was thinking so everyone who plays
in damage to my child must be responsible
And that means everyone.
We will find pornography pictures of sexual acts,
and everything is open and clear.
Not much common sense
to find out what the actual deal is.
The amount is fair the tip of the iceberg.
This is a crime that occurs against children
in every environment, in every place cities and states in this country.
I think I like that other person heard about it for the first time.
There is that distrust.
There's no way this is true,
because this is the United States.
This is very profitable,
just as horrible as saying, business.
This is the economy.
You are a drug dealer, You can sell medicine once.
You are a human trader,
You can sell small children repeatedly.
A lot of underage data trade is very difficult
And there are numbers everywhere.
We think it's around 100,000 marks.
Twelve to fifteen percent of the children we serve
are victims of human trafficking.
There are estimates out there 1.6 million homeless children
going out on the road at a certain time.
You can speak about 100, 150,000 children
who have been victims of human trafficking
Our children are not seen. The amount can be even higher.
These children, who Once seen on the corner,
now fast, efficient, and anonymously sold online.
Wherever you look, you cut it,
very large numbers
And the request is very large.
The majority of children we see are traded online
has been traded in Backpage.
Throughout the country in Seattle, at almost the same time,
Nacole is very trying look for her own daughter, J.S.,
who is 15 years old
Forty-five days into it, I got a call from him.
It was my birthday.
He called to tell me he loved me.
This is rather vague. I just...
shock. I can't believe what happened
My first instinct as a father, You want to go out and see.
You feel out of control.
Desperate.
I go out and start looking every day
I get angry and angry.
I can't stop the tape In my mind,...
I can't stop thinking about what might happen to him.
I was really scared of him and I was determined to find it.
He told us that he was injured,
that he is not a good child,
he is not a good person,
and that we don't want it.
You don't know whether he is alive or dead,
You don't know what happened to him.
I go to every bad thing environment and I go to the motel.
I investigate where I think they can have it
That's very difficult.
I remember a detective named A few moments after the 45 day mark
and request dental records,
and you can only assume
that they try to identify the body.
Every day continues, I become more angry.
Then I go to the liquor store
I grabbed a bottle, and I started drinking.
And that's how I handle it.
He began to advocate, and do advocacy work.
And pray.
I'm just the opposite. I am angry.
I want to hurt a pimp. That's what I want to do.
I want to get even.
In September 2010,
a few months after filing a lawsuit,
Kubiiki's lawyer, Robert Pedroli,
accept phone calls from Village Voice Media,
parent company Backpage.
They contact me to feel me out,
and to tell me what Their great people,
and how the founder is actually Cool guy from Greenwich Village,
and what I know about that
Conversations rocking to, you know,
"What are you looking for? You are looking for a little solution?
" We might be able to to make you a little settlement
to help the girl come out. "
And I told him," I doubt it will work. "
It's not about money, it's just about anger We want to prevent it from doing what they do
by having a decision given to them
I don't even recognize it. choppy
He wears different clothes.
On the way home he told us about it he had been raped and sold.
As bad as missing,
it's very traumatic hear these words come
of your 15-year-old child.
That is very devastating.
It takes a long time to realize
that I am innocent for what happened to me
I don't think everyone lives a life thinking
about the child sex trade in the United States.
I know I didn't do it until it happened to my family.
I always believe it is something That happens in foreign countries.
You hear it on the news.
But to find out about that happened in the backyard of my own house
and that can happen for the most normal family
and the most normal children,
and how fast it can happen.
That's when I decided to fight
and trying to catch up Visit www.Fastbet99.club Trusted Secure Online Gambling Agent
I am on a mission.
The most popular internet site for Visit www.Fastbet99.club Trusted Online Safe Gambling Agent
And in the last few weeks, we have been reported at increasing pressure by law enforcement officials and the anti-sex trade group
so that Backpage is turned off the adult service section,
which part the authorities say is underage
Girls are sometimes sold for sex.
In October 2010, Craigslist closed its adult part
and the number of sex ads in Backpage skyrocketed.
Backpage offers to meet
with the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children,
or NCMEC,
to discuss this problem child trafficking.
Well, there is a period of years
where is the NCMEC representative and the Backpage
representative meet often enough.
We want to suggest that they can improve the site
and try to get rid of human trafficking.
Backpage will always ask us what else they can do,
always in discussion explore that choice with us.
One of the Backpage solutions is to employ a moderator.
Their plan is to review every sex ad, every adult ad,
to filter potential illegality.
We have a list of the words we went through
it's not supposed to be to be used in advertisements.
Moderation and prohibited rules the term list often changes.
On an average day of eight hours,
I will go through seven for eight hundred ads.
Many times, I feel like we fly with the seat of our pants.
on St. Louis,
The Kubiiki case against Backpage was finally decided,
eighteen months after that is first submitted.
Backpage argues that Kubiiki & apos; s cases must be terminated
based on Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act, or CDA,
a law passed by Congress in 1996.
CDA, put in place when Internet has just begun,
protect websites are demanded for content
that may be posted by a third party.
Some courts have decided this immunity also includes illegal content.
I am very aware of its immunity made by Congressunder Section 230,
although not yet applied against cases of sexual trafficking.
The law only says, as the website operator,
I am not responsible as the publisher of
from what people wake up on my site
We argue, even if it's true, we don't sue you which facilitates prostitution.
We think anyone can understand this.
We lost this case,
and that is because of the Communications Act Act.
Judge determines this matter United States policy
He was torn apart.
At the same time Backpage wins his case on St. Louis,
Nacole takes steps file his own lawsuit
against Backpage in Seattle.
I know there is already a trial in Missouri,
so I thought first to contact the lawyer
and see how it goes there.
He will not appeal this case.
He said that I should try contact a different lawyer.
At that time, I took out the telephone book
and I started to contact a lawyer.
I was rejected by some people.
They say it's too big.
I believe they might be afraid of with what happened in Missouri.
Do not want to accept it.
When I first arrived at the Erik office,
This is small, small, Things that look like home.
I remember walking in and I sat on it, like, a little side of the chair,
and my mother is nervous.
And I think,
"Hmm, what kind of lawyers operate
from what looks like a house turns into a law office?"
What is Erik's first impression?
He is short.
Everyone thinks and tells me that we will lose,
99 to 1, we will lose
He doesn't just think of it as an answer.
Well, at first I thought, this can't be overcome
And I just don't agree with them, completely How is it legal? made by the company millions of dollars annually help pimps sell victims of sex trafficking,
including children.
Why does Congress permit immunity
to a moving company in doing this?
And he said, "Let's do this.
Let's stop Backpage for what they have done to you. "
And he's on the ship from day one.
He's really out of seventh grade,
and he's been traded for a long time.
And it's very heavy. with more than 20 adults every day,
has these seventh graders
according to their wishes
And that happens. And it's real.
Of the children we serve,
Nearly half of them meet their exploit online
They use the famous
and sophisticated recruitment and treatment tactics.
Love, charm, and violence. by violence.
They will have scouts.
Maybe at the mall.
Fast food places like Burger King and McDonald's
If they see low self-esteem,
or they hold their heads
they are running, and they don't make eye contact,
That's what they are after.
Frankly what we see most often is seduction
You use seduction, you use love.
Are you...
I will not say love, but I use seduction
Until he feels like This person is all over the world.
The easiest way to control these girls is
through the use of narcotics.
And what we see is meth and heroin
What they call rope.
We usually see recruitment The process occurs at the methadone clinic.
We see economic instability,
we see housing instability.
What did you tell him to watch out for?
A man who talks about him will solve all your problems
Who in the world can do that?
For many people selling sex,
very often that's the most annoying
of many shittier choices.
How much money does this woman make?
- How much did you make? - Not their money, it's mine.
I generate an undetermined amount of money
That's not their money.
Don't play with my money.
Ever.
When you step back and you see dynamics,
This is no less than modern slavery.
You are just a product
Backpage is Walmart human trafficking
This is a public square.
Turn it off! Turn it off!
Turn it off!
In the spring of 2012,
some anti-trafficking groups start installing
public pressure on Backpage.
My name is Liz McDougall,
and I am here on behalf of Village Voice Media Holdings,
Visit www.Fastbet99.club Trusted Trusted Online Gambling Agent
I did not join Village Voice and Backpage
and to retain companies to engage in illegal activities to gain profits.
I come with their commitment that I have the power and free government
to find out the best way to combat online trade...
I think the missing hat is that You are an important part of this problem.
I do not deny that Backpage is part of the problem, but
the problem is the internet.
You make a profit from this pimp,
put these girls on your site.
I have to tell you this is something...
This is the fourth trial I have,
and I've said this this afternoon
Each of my hearings, Backpage is mentioned.
I want to dialogue with you,
not confrontation and not an argument...
This is a hearing, so I question you
Now, we do more than anyone else to help in battles...
I want to stop
You are talking about being a native.
You must be transparent and responsible.
If you don't do that, then you are really dishonest.
Do you think about setting up riding the medicine section
from the Backpage.com site?
I refuse to answer that question.
What about weapons trading or arms trading section.
I'm sorry, are we here to have sarcastic back and forth,
or want to be exchanged useful information?
So far has not given us information
on the volume of what Visit www.Fastbet99.club Trusted Secure Online Gambling Agent
You have not given us anything information about your benefits
You wake up and make a statement.
How to work hearing is that we ask difficult questions.
Yes, that's how it works.
You can ask difficult questions,
but you have to give me opportunity to reply completely,
and you have interrupted me twice.
I appreciate it if you let me answer completely
I mean there is a
protocol with National Center for Missing and Exploited Children.
We are actually very proud.
We have been praised by the organization,
CEO of that organization,
for 2600 reports that we have made.
NCMEC has a slightly different view from its interaction with Backpage.
My impression is that is more interested in using
It becomes clear to us at NCMEC
it's possible that Backpage won't adopt
one of the actions we recommend
Discussion with Carl Ferrer, CEO Backpage,
Often surrounding facts that the moderator
is making a report about ads
which is described as possible children exploited
I see an advertisement for a young woman
It seems like he can do it have been 14 or 15 at least once a week.
And we will ask repeatedly, "Why is the ad still online?"
There are so many activities that people do
to try to mobilize a response to Backpage.
Good night all. this ten o'clock in the morning on the East Coast,
and we start tonight with Keeping Them Honest on the internet corner
it was charged a market for pimping
to sell prostitution and exploit young women.
Fifty-one attorneys general in the United States want to be turned off.
So do 19 US senators, 600 religious leaders,
and almost a quarter of a million people who signed the petition
Pressure on the website has been built for months.
We do everything to inhibit prostitution,
to block exploitation women, children, sex trade.
The internet is, unfortunately, the vehicle for this
We try to be sheriffs.
If you see your daughter in this case, like this, what...
I will be horrified,
and I'm horrified for those mothers,
and my heart goes to them mother and daughter.
I want to know how he feels who should be responsible
So, if it's his child,
Who do you think should be responsible?
If that's the case your child's photo you saw?
He puts the same information out there,
Gathering salaries, and somehow sleeping at night.
And I don't know how he did it.
I just want to shake it and make it understand.
But I know maybe the and dollar coins might fall.
We are here to sue the end of the sex trade
and we will not leave.
Voice of the Village has a strong reputation,
You know, because of eradicating corruption,
and for them now to do this,
and in some ways promote sex trafficking
because you allowed this ad What happened was unfortunate.
Sound plays a role in New York City journalism is unequaled.
Everyone on the left in New York reads It is the Bible about a movement.
As the press should be, this is part of our _ mandate to feed politicians
and check their strength.
That's what we have to do.
That is paper handled the problem you care about
Visit www.Fastbet99.club Trusted Trusted Online Gambling Agent
Not enough until recently, I have to say it.
In 2005, the Village Voice was sold to the New Times based in Phoenix,
alternative newspapers chain co-founded
by Michael Lacey and owned by Jim Larkin.
The New Times, like The Village Voice, has a progressive tradition,
anti-formation report
I call them cowboys from Phoenix.
But I don't understand how they business operations succeed
When we study Backpage, it is on the Internet.
It's not something we can see, it's not in the paper.
Incoming income really from the book
in terms of what we can see.
We always have personal advertisements and display ads
which is a massage parlor.
Some of them are for prostitutes,
But many of them only people offer invitations to sex.
Adults and their sexual practices and preferences are one thing.
When we find out about Backpage,
There is something else fully happening there
Real people, apparently, young girls trade
Immediately, Lacey and her people
start talking about how they believe in prostitution
The owner of Backpage can talk about this all day
That is freedom of speech.
They seek journalism cover what they do
But it's illegal sell children for sex.
Period.
This is child abuse.
My father, Norman Mailer,
is one of three people who started this writing.
And this is very difficult for me to get here today
because I always love Voice of the Village.
So, for the owner Desa Suara Media,
You hold an inheritance from this article is in your hands
Please do the right thing.
Take it.
In the same month in Seattle,
Nacole starts a telephone campaign to his state senator
on behalf of Senate Bill 6251,
who will need a website for get age verification for sex ads.
The aim is to make sure children are not advertised online
I am the mother of a teenage victim Visit www.Fastbet99.club Trusted Secure Online Gambling Agent
I hear you say about the First Amendment,
and I ask "who Sound we protect?"
Do you protect the website it makes millions?
These girls need sound and I ask that you become his voice
Washington State is enacted a first law of its kind
because of the many reports we have underage girls
Visit www.Fastbet99.club Trusted Trusted Online Gambling Agent
And when the bill passes, I'm very proud of
I am proud of the state of Washington.
Backpage.com is making something like $ 30 million a year.
They will retreat.
But let them push.
There is a new battle line Visit www.Fastbet99.club Trusted Secure Online Gambling Agent
Washington State issues a law It will take effect today
it will require Backpage to verify age
people advertise in the section of adult services
This is designed to prevent children from being advertised online
That's something that we've explored
for months and continue to explore.
When you talk about internet...
What does it mean, "continue to explore"?
You've been doing business for a very long time
There are many people who you want you to do this before.
This is not the first time you have done it ever considered this idea
So why can't just say, "Yes, we will do this"?
This will cost money, but if so that's the right thing to do.
Money is not a problem.
The problem is how are you functionally applying this
If you have knowledge and understanding of how the internet works,
This is a practical impossibility in the internet world.
Now, I'm definitely not the internet Experts, but I'm not an idiot.
Obviously for me, it seems this is a matter of money
Visit www.Fastbet99.club Trusted Trusted Online Gambling Agent
will do everything in their power to
make sure that this bill is not signed
Backpage argues that Senate Bill 6251
will violate Section 230 of CDA.
That they are not responsible for third party posts.
The court agrees, and the bill dies.
♪ There is a woman ♪
♪ A woman like ♪
♪ With perfect etiquette ♪
♪ He can cook eight dishes ♪
♪ And never sweat ♪
♪ Good luck to you God's blessing for you ♪
Mama! Mother!
I want to blame myself for drinking my father,
for my mother to cry all the time
and emotional disturbances.
There is no handbook to tell you
what happens when your daughter is raped,
and all this happens.
I also want to blame myself for the man who has taken me
You know, I want to do it blame myself for that
You walk around the house with 800 pounds of elephants in the room
no one talks about it
All the time my daughter trauma is imagined.
And we have experienced trauma.
We don't know how to handle it.
And we don't know how to help it overcome it
I just tried to hold it together as well as possible.
Try wrapping my head around how you take children
That is a soccer star, violinist,
and 36 hours later, he is being sold on the
website My favorite hobby is soccer and violin.
My favorite song is Crank That by Soulja Boy.
When I grow up, I want to be a doctor.
There is something missing a piece of his soul is lost.
In September 2012,
Village Voice Owners, Michael Lacey and Jim Larkin
decide to turn off Backpage to a separate company.
They leave The Village Voice, but choose to stay with Backpage.
They can't just leave of real money
These are the people who have present themselves to us like,
"We are very concerned about journalism. We are very concerned about the news."
And they decided to go with this money
for this really terrible
sex marketing operations that they are running
The fact that Visit www.Fastbet99.club Trusted Secure Online Gambling Agent
who have forever tried to say,
"We fight for media rights and we fight for freedom of speech,"
when they decide to divert from Village Voice, they say,
"We live with Backpage."
Don't say I'm not in it for money.
Dealing with Lacey and listening to all this
about how he is like a hard-nosed journalist.
"We solve many stories," things like that,
and then see it go
from one of the most distinguished the name of the newspaper
in history 20th Century Journalism
to enter sex ads just looks like,
"wow, man, this world More chaotic than I thought."
It is also possible to see this, Really, just in a slightly different way,
which is just as sad, maybe even more sad.
It is possible that Mike Lacey indeed believes in good journalism
and that is why he created it an alternative newspaper kingdom
But what's really sad in the end,
he prefers to have Backpage rather than have a real newspaper.
It must be difficult to release it
because you have been running for a long time, for a decade.
Well, I think is hard to let go,
but believe me, the person we are doing is happy to let us let go.
At the end of 2012,
public pressure on Backpage seems to evaporate,
although it continues, dominates the market for sex ads.
There is a feeling of despair that starts to be arranged in a little.
And so far great facilitators exist,
we fall short like a field from where we need to get to.
In March 2013, The back page file was a
ask the court to ignore the Nacole case.
I will not say that I am an expert today,
but one of the problems we face
is Section 230 of the Communication Decency Law of 1996.
Somewhere in the bill,
Visit www.Fastbet99.club Trusted Trusted Online Gambling Agent
The reason Congress applied it Section 230 in the first place
is because the lawsuit was submitted by Stratton Oakmont,
boiler room securities operation was founded by Jordan Belfort,
better known as The Wolf of Wall Street.
- The show continues! - yes!
This is my house!
They will need damn destroyers balls to take me out of here
Damn them!
A bulletin board, with the name Prodigy,
this is the early days from the internet,
accept a post from one of its members
which basically says that Belfort, Axis and people at Stratton Oakmont
manipulate stocks and that they are criminals.
The court finds that Prodigy is responsible
because of its failure to delete comments posted about Stratton Oakmont,
and the Belfort firm wins this case.
This decision means that the court, before the CDA is promulgated,
find that a website can be responsible
for third party content posted on their site.
If Facebook is sued at any time
fifth graders say something bad about their teacher,
there will be many unnecessary lawsuits
And the law creates a safe port
for people who act as channels for internet content
Especially for the benefits from most websites
that has nothing to do with illegal content
The most ironic thing is that posting is correct,
because of Belfort and others Stratton Oakmont pleaded guilty
to manipulate that security.
And who is chasing Belfort?
Well, that will be me.
One of the theories we have
is the Backpage, actually, in conspiracy with pimps,
that posting rules are not designed to prevent
or to stop human trafficking,
but actually, designed to be a guide for pimps
to enable them to design which ads help them avoid law enforcement.
So instead of saying, "Come here, and we will sell sex for $ 100,"
This ad will say something more dangerous, like
"Face down, lift up, Come see Tasha, $ 80 special."
There is a whole system of code words
like "fresh" or "off the boat"
which should show that someone under age
Everyone in the industry and who buys
knows exactly what the signal means.
Emojis is a new visual language.
So, roses are not roses,
and umbrellas have nothing to do with rain
That code
You can't have 30 minutes.
However, you could say HH, which means half an hour.
Without saying it's okay,
it's basically known this code is okay
You know, EMU is a new one a way to get words.
So, the small watermark, "no umbrella," is permitted
And what does that mean?
There are no condoms
I don't think many of us stop
and think, "This can be our sister or our brother."
That doesn't hit the house for me too much until I start to realize that this might be me.
Yes.
I drove him to his friend's house
and he must be at home Right after the mall closes.
I contacted the police, I contacted the FBI.
I started calling several numbers in the phone log
and I told two men to tell me
that they get my daughter the phone number of Backpage.
Our three clients are about 15 years
when they are first Visit www.Fastbet99.club Trusted Secure Online Gambling Agent
We say that they are engaged in affirmative action
which directly violates a criminal law,
Law on Protection of Trafficking Victims.
They say they are not responsible
for what people put on their site.
This is much deeper than that.
What is on their site affects and hurts,
and trauma to many people.
Currently the ad involves children posted,
responses from potential customers start to enter in seconds
Ads will live until approved,
anywhere from 30 seconds to two hours.
There are customers who see the children
before moderation ever happened.
It's easy to use Backpage because you sit alone at home,
in your own free time, and indeed is almost like shopping on Amazon.
One of our plaintiffs told us, "People used to order me in Backpage
as easy as you can order pizza."
I've been addicted to watching porn.
It's like a gateway drug.
Have you ever bought sex from minors?
No, I agree.
That's what I got arrested.
Because you were arrested, I suspect your wife knows.
- Yes. - What about your children?
My youngest child ran in the bathroom and vomited.
In America,
one in seven men
say that they have bought illegal commercial sex
They are white. They are married.
They live in the suburbs and they have children.
They are not people you suspect.
I am already from the priests,
from lawyers to politicians.
Many men buy unconscious sex the danger they cause
I want that to be clear and known My daughter, Jane Doe, was raped.
Three of Jane Doe's victims entered Boston was represented by Ropes & Gray,
one of the oldest and most prestigious law firms in the country.
Our goal is to set the Backpage
responsible for what has happened to these children
There are several things The backpage does it
that allows these pimps more successfully victims of traffic
Let them use prepaid credit cards,
and to send a telephone number not as a digit digit
but by spelling a certain number out.
Like 251 it could be T-W-O and then number five and O-N-E.
And what it does is obstruction law enforcement capability
to track phone numbers
Another thing they do is to let Bitcoin.
Also, we accused him Backpage starts a scheme
to deceive law enforcement
while they increase their markets share to become a dominant player.
One of the things they Is as part of that strategy,
is that they employ general advisor, Liz McDougall,
to describe themselves as a moving company
in an effort to internet police.
And they employ it to be, in effect, the face of the company.
I met Liz McDougall when I was Deputy Mayor for New York City,
and he is very beautiful, and he is very credible.
When he told me all these things they did to protect children.
I think they call themselves, "Internet Sheriff."
Well, boy, pleasure is over.
Now, I just got a new iPad
and then I stop and I say,
"I thought I'd buy a 13-year-old child.
" How do you explain this? "
And he looked surprised
when people accuse companies facilitate human trafficking.
Especially child trafficking.
And he, "Oh, me, let me see that.
That's wrong. Something is wrong.
We will fix it."
That's nonsense.
Unfortunately I have to say it
Backpage's legal strategy has been very effective This is a mystery to me Backpage continues to win,
and Backpage continue win with such a big style.
A very expensive lawyer,
cloaking yourself in First Amendment and Section 230.
As far as legal strategy, I think it's brilliant,
Because it has succeeded.
But is that right? No. That is not true.
In Seattle, an trial is scheduled in the case of Nacole,
almost two years after that was originally submitted
Washington Supreme Court
will decide whether Section 230 of CDA must protect Backpage.
NCMEC, which is no longer entered discussion with Backpage,
short file in support of the Nacole case,
together with Covenant House, Shared Hope, and others.
Do you have short archival ambivalence,
remember your history with Backpage?
No.
He reached out for us and asked whether we were willing to help him Visit www.Fastbet99.club Trusted Trusted Online Gambling Agent
This is probably the most important case that we handle in our legal career.
We see CDA to find out, You know, how can we overcome this?
There are 300-plus cases out there going the other way.
Everyone wants to do oral arguments,
That is always the type of cherry on ice cream there
Initially, I thought it was more experienced Appellate lawyers had to do it.
Basically I am a street lawyer when I get there.
Erik insisted that he wanted to refute this case,
and we talk about it.
He is stubborn.
A stubborn man.
They finally decided that, you know, I Can advance and make oral arguments.
I remember being in the courthouse,
and there are people outside holding the sign
and I think, you know, how fun having all this support.
I mean, this is the Supreme Court. I mean, this is very big.
I am trained
Tom and I go alone, and pray.
J.S., S.L., and L.C. against Village Voice Media Holdings, LLC.
Hopefully it can please the court, my name is Jim Grant,
I am here on behalf of the applicants,
Village Voice Media Incorporated, Backpage.com and New Times Media.
Congress makes clear policies choices in enacting Part 230 of
Communication Agreement Act, and the choice
is to preserve free speech on the internet,
Congress decides to provide online services provider of immunity for their actions
for content posted by third parties.
The point is when that third party posts are online,
You can't sue a website.
Lawyers for Backpage do their normal arguments
that they are here to protect children,
and they are protected under CDA
Your client will not say it a straight face that is not realized
The companion service is really something else most of the time.
I will say that...
Surely we all know it's haram things happen through the internet
and that has happened when other things have happened.
Type of protection given 230,
This is a blanket immunity, and this can feel extreme in some cases.
You know, the more extreme you take hypothetically,
the more questionable it can be seen.
If you make life from tobacco films
because you pulled it as your content to your website,
and that's how you make your money do
It's like a partner crime, if you want
Hopefully please court.
My name is Erik Bauer, and I represent small respondents in this matter.
When Erik stands up to argue, I feel happy.
We have prepared it for so long, and it's only time.
I've never seen it so is emotionally involved in a case
This is not the size building or ad size,
it's determination and passion is put into battle
My client is in class seven and nine
when they are controlled by adults professional sex traders, pimps
So why is Backpage responsible?
Backpage claims that they have immunity
to help pimps sell children on their site.
Our assessment is, Your Honor, that is they are responsible, at least in part,
for the second creation of this ad
and for the development of these ads.
This post rule called is on the Backpage.com site,
they are actually instructions for pimping on how to post successful ads
One of their rules says, Don't advertise increase in time in 15 minutes.
Hey, it's a bit short.
Where can you escort someone in 15 minutes?
They don't want that to happen Obviously, there are many red flags.
Backpage says that, "Legal escort services
and if someone wants to do something illegal, it's not our fault."
What is your response to that?
This is prostitution in disguise as a companion, whatever the companion.
I mean, what are these people? wholesale children
in Washington State or not?
Do they do it on purpose?
And I remember leaving there thinking,
we have this, we get this
It has been like a hard struggle, because on every occasion they have won.
Then we start waiting.
In December 2014, Backpage, which now operates in 88 countries,
reportedly sold to Dutch companies.
According to a Dallas newspaper, Backpage CEO, Carl Ferrer,
will continue to run the company.
With a long question list,
we are looking for a Backpage CEO, Carl Ferrer brings us here
Carl Ferrer has refused some of our interview requests
so we came here to Amsterdam.
- Carl? Carl Ferrer? - Yes.
Hi, we've been looking for you
- Oh yeah. - do you have a minute?
I am Gloria Riviera from ABC News.
We just want to ask a few questions.
There are no comments.
You know, law enforcement tells us
underage girls traded on Backpage.com, your company.
There are no comments.
We see real life examples of this past week...
It takes a while to realize that I am not a prostitute I don't like that word.
I'm still small
At first I was like, "Why did I run away?"
The reality is that children all over America
is sneaking out of the house all the time.
I'm just a child and shouldn't be No one has done this to me.
Has been traded has caused my daughter has anger problems
He becomes very closed.
Children at school find out what happened,
so we go to school at home.
Friends, they call me horrible names, "prostitutes" and "prostitutes," and...
and that is only a lack of information from their side.
There must be people who feel it's your fault
And that's another reason why don't you talk about it
And that's why I don't want to speak about that if I don't need to.
It has been struggling to keep it safe and keep it alive and to keep him away from life.
He is stuck at my side when no one else does it.
I lost my virginity and was raped,
and me... I don't know
I definitely see...
Sex is different now, I don't know.
Children in high school are so crazy about with sex all the time, and I just...
I don't know
I only saw it is completely different now
That's not everything everyone will feel it.
I don't want anyone to go through
what my daughter must go through.
Given the opportunity to talk with Backpage,
I will tell them that on April 7, 2010,
they change our family life forever.
We will never be our family before my daughter is gone,
and before he was sold on the site.
CDA has given them The most recent in this case,
and I'm here to tell them, As a parent, I'm not okay with that.
I will only ask the same thing questions my daughter asks you
What will you do if it is your child?
In April 2015,
The US Senate starts investigating online sex trafficking Their investigation takes them to Backpage.
The more you hear about this
and increasing incidence of sex trafficking
more and more Backpages appear.
We live in a border country
where many of these cross borders Trade in sex takes place.
So when we say, "How can this happen?",
we realize this is coming from ads in Backpage.
We don't deal with prostitution, we deal with human slavery.
Is Backpage an innocent facilitator
or do they really have a more active role? in making the type of ad that is actually being placed?
Do they have clean hands here?
The court said that the Congress could protect children who were exploited
or can protect the internet.
And that's what chooses to protect the internet.
Now that statement really pisses me off,
because I don't think Congress does something like that.
He is frustrated, because he feels as if
The judge does not understand what he is trying to argue.
The fact that Ropes & Gray The missing is actually revelation
How many court systems need to be trained
about child sex trade.
So, the decision is not very surprising,
it's very much disappointing, though
You think he will say, "I already have it"?
Not possible.
- He will never give up. - He won't give up
Net Income for Backpage reaches the highest level of all time in 2015.
That is, until Sheriff Tom Dart in Chicago,
frustrated with the number of victims of sex trafficking he found
decide to take the problem into his own hands
More and more sex industries
has been moved from to the internet
We answer ads after ads, after ads,
and we found it every case, everyone,
Actually, someone who is is a prostitute herself,
someone who is traded.
We will respond to an advertisement, That is always a crime.
Crapshoot is whether it is an adult or a small child.
Sheriff realizes that something that needs to be done
Sheriff Dart sends to stop and stop writing
to MasterCard and Visa
inform them that they have done business
with companies involved in human trafficking.
And as a result, both Visa and Mastercard
stop doing business with Backpage.
Backpage loses all income from credit card companies,
a temporary blow to his income.
Then start offering free adult ads,
with upgrades that must be paid by personal checks or Bitcoin.
The important thing is that the action is
it is a number of Fortune 500 companies
say that business, which they believe there is illegal action happening
and they will not support it.
Backpage sues Sheriff Dart
claim that his actions are a _ First Amendment violation.
Now in the trial and the court will decide
where it will go
He put his neck on the cutting block.
He does what he thinks right in every way.
Back to Seattle, it's been three years now
since the Nacole case was first filed.
He is waiting for a decision from the Supreme Court of Washington.
Time goes on, and you have the day you like,
"You know, I don't think this can go towards us.
You know, the first month passed, and then the second month passed,
and then the fifth month passes.
And I remember working at on September 3.
My heart stops. I'm like...
Limbo is fine, because we have not won or lost.
And I walked out, and I prayed.
And ten minutes later I got a call...
that the court has supported us.
The court decides that if active Backpage helps
to develop sex ads on the site,
and not just a passive host,
then the Backpage should not be protected by Section 230 Cases are allowed to proceed to court.
I really triggered it.
We wait almost a year to get that decision,
and that means we can continue with this case
And I am very grateful.
I almost destroyed my car.
There is a sense of optimism that progress is being made
and that is not in vain.
There are no losses across the board.
That is a blessing and god is watching us that day
when they make that decision
And that is to help those people cannot be helped.
You know, actually we actually have a voice that will do something I know this will help me and my daughter,
and that will help many other girls out there,
they don't know what's coming out until it's too late
Difficult, this fight.
They know what they are doing wrong,
and they know the children are traded on their site,
and they failed to do anything to fix it.
And we will change it.
Two months later, on November 3, 2015,
summons of the senate subcommittee Carl Ferrer, CEO of Backpage,
to testify at the trial in Washington DC
On the same day, Backpage puts it from the majority of the moderator,
advise them to call the company Lawyers if contacted by investigators.
I googled the lawyer and it looked It seems like he's a criminal lawyer.
This establishes the fact that there is the underlying situation occurs
it's illegal
- Are you afraid? - Yes.
The e-mail is circulated to Backpage employees are fired
comes from someone named Visit www.Fastbet99.club Trusted Secure Online Gambling Agent
But the sign line is not doesn't really say "Backpage."
It says, "Website Technologies."
Texas Search State Secretary Record
reveals that the president of Website Technology for 2015
is Jim Larkin, the owner of the original Backpage,
contrary to the widely held assumption
that he is no longer active is involved with Backpage.
In the same month, Seventh Circuit Court of Appeal in Chicago
agree to hear the Backpage case against Sheriff Dart.
The problem here is whether Sheriff Dart has been trampled on First Amendment Rights Backpage
by sending stops and stops letters to Visa and MasterCard.
Seventh Circuit Court Appeals hold hearings.
It was heard by three judges, including Judge Richard Posner.
Judge Posner might, I think, be considered one of the highest legal experts
at least in our generation or generation.
Our first case for the argument is Backpage versus Dart.
Hopefully please court.
Sheriff Dart forms an task force for this specific purpose
Visit www.Fastbet99.club Trusted Trusted Online Gambling Agent
You know, there is a police officer to be very careful in what he says
Your Honor, the Visa action was taken from the concern that their brand...
Look, this tone is very unprofessional He talks about the violence industry.
Is sex phone full of violence?
- Contents of... - Is sex phone violence?
- Could be. - really
- Of course you can. - How?
And what about parents,
parents who want look with young women?
That is the aspect of companion service. Not all sex.
I'm not so sure Hakim Posner has a strong grip
Visit www.Fastbet99.club Trusted Trusted Online Gambling Agent
It feels a bit like a dusk zone.
The part that really annoys me
is the part where he shows that,
"Sometimes a man just wants to be seen in a younger woman company."
I mean, in my case, I have children
pose with, you know, in underwear,
with the camera handle on the camera.
I mean, you want to be seen in the company
with a child dressed inside him underwear, well, what is that?
I remember seeing My little girl in her underwear.
I see my child...
in different poses...
Looks like he was sedated.
When you get the call your daughter's word is in Backpage,
what is your reaction
I fell to the floor.
I don't know if the owner website has children,
but I hope that doesn't happen to them.
When the CDA is interpreted by the court
Visit www.Fastbet99.club Trusted Trusted Online Gambling Agent
to be involved in the human sex trade,
then we have a problem With that law, I think.
Or we have a problem with the judge.
Either way, we have a problem.
And if the judge is too blunt
and if they don't get it,
then I think it is necessary made clear
The Congress does not support human sex trade
Two weeks later, a senate subcommittee convenes
about the child sex trade in Washington DC This trial will now be ordered.
In the bipartisan staff report released today,
we have explained some initial findings
and further questions that require answers.
The report reveals that Backpage has it
an editing practice some ads
by deleting words and images before being published
This editing practice may occur serves to hide evidence
of illegality from the underlying transaction.
National Center for Missing and Exploited Children
reported an increase of 846 percent
in the alleged report child sex trade
According to an industry analyst, eight out of every $ 10 is spent
about commercial sex online advertise in the United States
go to Backpage.
Fair market value of the company,
consider lack of marketing,
around 430 million.
We are here to talk about profitable sales online
American children for sex,
which in our experience occurs most prominently
Visit www.Fastbet99.club Trusted Trusted Online Gambling Agent
Can you explain your testimony
that there are more rigorous posts Rules for selling motorbikes
rather than selling 12 years?
I really don't have an explanation For that, Senator.
The main lawyer Backpage has describing the moderation process
as a key tool for disrupting and finally ending human trafficking.
Backpage was initially told the moderator outside
that they must "fail"
ads that contain references to certain sex and words,
includes "girls," "teenagers,"
and "Y-U-N-G."
Two days later, Backpage reverses the policy.
What's important, the guide from Backpage Emphasized in all uppercase letters,
"If in doubt about underage,
the process must now be done to receive ads
Only delete if you really People who are very confident are underage."
It is on all caps.
I want to contact the CEO of from Backpage, Carl Ferrer.
We hope Mr. Ferrer is here.
He just doesn't appear.
Certainly not something that you don't display.
Absolute ignores not to appear.
Chairman, I have been a member of from this subcommittee for many years.
I never knew a witness refused a court call
And I'm sure you will do it
take necessary actions to ensure that it is not done with impunity.
He called me and said, "You won't believe me." I said, "I saw it".
I've never seen anything like this.
I have never seen a witness reject to appear in a court call.
Backpage, at every opportunity,
have tried to protect anyone
from getting information behind the screen.
What do they hide?
I think we will find it they have tipped the scale
towards acceptance of ads
which is clearly designed to get customers
who want to have sex with children, to explain it clearly.
We want to find out, you know, how they do business,
whether they are editing their ads or not
They refuse to participate.
Not just a problem human trafficking,
But this is a direct attack, The failure to appear,
in constitutional responsibility
United States Congress.
It is very unusual for someone to say, "No, I will not show up."
And with that, this hearing is delayed
Seventh Circuit decides that, Such government pressure
to the website with the purpose of censorship,
violates the First Amendment.
"Also not a Sheriff Dart..."
"... on solid ground in shows that everything..."
"... everything in the adult section The Backpage website is criminal."
"Fetishism? Call sex?"
"Performances by striptease artists?"
"Vulgar is not violent."
One ad in this category, & apos; Dom and fetish... & apos; "
"... is for services from & apos; professional dominatrix & apos; "
" A woman who is being is paid for whipping or vice versa... "
"... embarrass customers in to arouse them sexually."
"It's not clear like that do harm women or children..."
"... or violating any law."
Interesting.
To read something like that, Frankly, it worries me.
I think it's read like a cheap and dim novel.
This victim is dominated by women, underage girls
And I wonder if some are missing
when the issue is happening is decided by a male judge.
The court is completely unknown
with the crime of child trafficking
and with some ads posted on Backpage.
In the case of advertising for trafficking people,
I mean, it's not so freedom of speech,
You know, it's criminal activity.
You know, Pretty Woman. I have to take a Pretty Wom item We have created this kind of myth in our culture
From you know, Julia Roberts is in Pretty Woman.
And the reality is far, far different.
Can't watch it
Love the movie.
Because Pretty Woman is not a scenario
What we have done before or after the lawsuit
go out and we try to get people who is trafficking in children
This is a very difficult thing do because of its nature.
In Boston, John Montgomery prepared his case, Doe versus Backpage,
hoping to convince the first Circuit of the Court of Appeal
Section 230 should not apply to protect Backpage.
Hopefully please court. My name is John Montgomery
What are the charges, exactly, Unauthorized activity by Backpage?
It operates an online market
who then trains the traders
who will go get involved in that activity
This is a very important case The three young women we represent
and many others, As a result, they represent.
There are only a few cases, Maybe two or three,
where internet service providers allegedly have participated
in federal crime.
Getting there at 9:00 will be great.
Because it allows us at that time type to walk back and forth
in front of the courthouse nervously.
On January 6, 2016
First Circuit Court in Boston hears oral arguments on Doe versus Backpage.
Amazingly, Judge David Souter, previously a Supreme Judge,
will be one of three judges hear the case
Mr. Montgomery, just go ahead.
Our main claim is the Backpage
involved in intentional criminal actions.
They intend to go further the sex trade trade.
Are your complaints coming in? The next step tells the truth,
they participate in efforts to sex traffic, contrary to advertising?
Why is it different from what newspapers
When it's special the ad section for
Washington Birthday Car Sales?
They host off-line communication
between illegal sex sellers,
including with children and buyers.
That happens on their site.
They participate in that effort That is the point.
Hopefully please in court, Jeffrey Pyle...
Mr. Pyle, at some time you will respond
to the last argument made by Mr. Montgomery,
that there is something more than the advertisement going on?
You are responsible, if we let it go forward,
to become an participant in the sex trade effort.
The ad is created by
plaintiffs themselves or by their pimps.
Visit www.Fastbet99.club Trusted Trusted Online Gambling Agent
I bring you agree that is possible for the publisher
to also be a participant in the sex trade business,
where the pimp himself runs a website.
Yes.
Publishers usually don't go out and participate in federal crime,
Especially the sex trade business.
And it's true, if we can get two the judge agrees with that,
I think we might have three judges who would agree with that,
That is very important for us.
Right. The question is, where it brings us
- Right - Right
When Justice Souter is launched analogy of the car ad,
That's kind of, "why do we compare it? girls who are traded to cars?"
There might be better answers to some questions
A panel prepared in a difficult state means that you can wait a while.
I think we have a good shot,
and I can't wait to contact Jane Does and tell them how it goes.
- I think we're in the game - Yeah.
First Circuit Argument
certainly one of the most active benches I've ever seen.
All judges have clearly read the shorts.
That makes me feel a little optimistic what is the decision?
I think Ropes & Gray will win.
I don't want to sound like Debbie the Downer,
but no matter how many times you come against the Labor Law Communication
it will always close you.
Because my daughter was sold in Backpage
He's a completely different person.
He is traumatized.
That spark and fire first see in his eyes missing
Well, it's forever changing it.
He blames himself. This affects him every day.
Guilt and fairness feel ashamed of yourself,
I have struggled a lot with that.
Do you know how many mentors I have?
Do you know how many therapists do I have?
Do you know how many "friends" I have?
He feels that his childhood has been lost, destroyed.
He still suffers From the dissociative,
dysfunctional part of what happens.
Every time I think about it, I become sad and depressed,
and I experience flashbacks.
Violin, football, songs, friends, eh...
memories with my sister and sister playing.
I mean, all that just goes.
This is one of those things
I honestly don't want to my worst enemy
I have to live every day in my life now
with everything that happened to me.
And my parents must live with grief
in knowing that I passed it every day
I think I've been crying more this year than I have cried in my life
Oh my God.
Yes.
We are now continuing with an insult to this Congress,
which unfortunately, we are forced to do that,
because Backpage refuses to give us information
We really know through some evidence
Backpage really instructs people to edit ads,
including to take proof of illegality
But I think that's why they work it's very difficult to avoid our court calls.
What will I recommend to the subcommittee
is that we have an insult to Congress submitted against Backpage.
And I think the committee will go with us
We'll see later. I hope so.
Senator McCaskill and I today as a result
ask the committee to report the resolution to authorize
civil enforcement and humiliation
against Backpage and against its CEO, Carl Ferrer.
I'm happy that Senator Portman is calm,
because sometimes I am ready to do McCain to these people.
No, that's not it!
I think McCaskill will be good enough. I've seen it in operation.
Frankly, I don't remember
when witnesses refuse to testify in this way.
I don't know if your staff has...
- It's been 20 years, John. - It's been 20 years.
If there is no further debate or amendment,
the question is at the end of from the original resolution
directs the Senate Legal Counsel to be taken a civil action to enforce a court call
from this Permanent Subcommittee about Investigation.
- Senator McCain - Aye
- Portman Senator - Aye
- Senator Paul - Aye
- Senator Langford - Aye
- Senator Ayotte - Aye
In this selection yay is 15, nays is zero,
and the motion was agreed.
What we do today is that we pass the committee The first step in holding individuals in Backpage
in an insult to Congress.
Well, that hasn't happened in 20 years.
Have a unanimous vote.
By the way, it's hard to get anything unanimously around here
Subcommittee senate takes yet Other steps to investigate Backpage.
One day we are happy, then become nervous. But we are quite confident.
I will put money for us.
This person manages 1400 people a law firm from Boston.
You must be a enough lawyer ride a flock of 1,400 other sharks.
Thank you to everyone for gathering
and, you know, especially for Yiota coming from Washington DC
and Erik, along the way from Seattle, Washington.
We can call this our first ever peak person Backpage.
The first thing I thought about would be Interesting to talk about
is to get everyone's reaction,
for the latest decisions we have about Backpage.
I am not impressed with the thought of the First Circuit.
I agree with you. I think it's fair
Visit www.Fastbet99.club Trusted Trusted Online Gambling Agent
to overcome what really happened This is the sale of children.
The decision seems like really disarmed the
activities and really said there are several publications here,
which triggers CDA, this case is over.
There are only a few real academic distances between your federal appeal our court judge and our plaintiff.
In other words, these people must do it out of their ivory tower
I will stay for them to continue Visit www.Fastbet99.club Trusted Secure Online Gambling Agents
I will tell you, two out of three of the judges did not use the internet.
These people don't know how their VCR works.
We will evaluate our approach to the US Supreme Court.
Because our case is in the process of
and we will be tried and we intend to win,
I don't want to broadcast our strategy is also pretty good
and give Backyard a blueprint what we will do.
I think the decision is misdirected.
And they will not hold back the Responsible Backpage very disturbing me.
There is this high discussion about Section 230,
and at the end of the day, rape is hardly discussed.
They are discussed in passing.
There is a line that says something Like, "So, here's the story."
And this is not a fairy tale. There is a child who is raped a thousand times.
That's outrageous.
They think Congress should improve this, not court.
And we think it's actually theirs job and they don't do it
What I know is I want to Visit www.Fastbet99.club Trusted Secure Online Gambling Agent
or congressman think that this situation,
the status quo is quite satisfying.
It doesn't make sense if you can sit
and you can hear testimony or, You can see all the evidence
and you can't feel certain amount of responsibility
to improve the situation.
We need someone give us a chance to fight
I hope every American will also be angry and other times federal state judge or judge
accuses that somehow this practice can be accepted in America,
then speak up
This is a matter of inheritance for these judges.
The judge made this decision
will be read in history.
This judge will be judged alone.
This can't happen again.
It doesn't matter what the CDA says.
Calendar number 375. SRES377,
direct the legal Senate advice to bring civil action
to enforce a court call from the Permanent Subcommittee on Investigation.
Backpage and Chief Executive Officer, Carl Ferrer,
we will send messages to others, I say to my colleague from Ohio,
they can run away, but they can't hide.
During our November 19 trial,
I promise that while subcommittee will move forward
Careful and careful,
We will not go quietly until night.
And one day in the near future,
we will use Senate & apos; s law enforcement actions
to force cooperation from Backpage.
Today is that day.
The officer will call him.
Mr. Johnson, aye.
Miss Herono, aye.
Mr. Heller, aye.
voting supports, no one opposes. Resolution Senen 377 is approved.
That is a unanimous decision, 96 votes.
I am very proud and very happy.
We will win. We will sink the ship.
I guarantee that.
Weapon Resolution 377 only authorizes Senate to file charges against Backpage
to enforce his subpoena.
But this sound might be The first step in a long battle is protracted,
not only with Backpage, but to change Section 230.
David Boies, fresh, from won the Supreme Court case
about same-sex marriage,
decide to get into the fray.
He, with others, starts preparing a new lawsuits against Backpage.
Good afternoon, Boies, Schiller & Flexner.
If you have a clear organization
understand that they facilitate
this illegal action,
It seems like I am a very important case to do Our legal strategy is to show that Backpage is everywhere.
So, we will go file some lawsuits
and mobilize the community have been touched by Backpage.
Judges must be educated,
society needs to be educated,
The Department of Justice needs to be educated
exactly what happened here
The idea that Backpage is only trying to fulfill parents' fetishes,
not also involving minors,
I don't think they will be able to make it in court
with a straight face.
The witness stands is a quiet place to lie.
We will bring them to court
and they can tell the story under cross-examination.
Let's see if they can defend it.
I don't think they can.
State and federal authorities have been arrested
Carl Ferrer is 55 years old in Houston, this afternoon.
Ferrer will face charges related to pimps...
If Backpage is immune from responsibility,
that means that This immunity is actually
extends to intentional criminal actions.
and the first circuit actually agrees with that argument
Maybe, you know, the courtroom won't be the end of everything-everything
when it comes to solving this problem.
Congress must absolutely act.
Once we get the information,
pull back the curtain, see what really happened here,
then I think the legislative response is the next logical step.
I think you will see a lot of opposition
with the idea of changing Section 230.
Center for Democracy and Technology,
and Electronic Frontier Foundation,
two high-powered organizations dedicated to internet freedom,
Both have filed lawsuits pants that support Backpage
in his case against J.S. and Jane Doe.
Google search for donors to Center for Democracy and Technology
read who is like technology company.
Their larger donors include Facebook, Microsoft and Google.
This means that the funds are from these companies is being used to support Backpage
in this case involves underage sex trafficking
Silicon Valley breaks in cold conditions sweat when we talk about changing CDA,
but there are several ways we can do this
it can be in child trafficking.
The government cannot only censor which does not agree with or dislike.
Money and lobby prevent change,
even though that is a reasonable change,
as if we have to go there First Amendment altar,
and ask forgiveness.
Many voices are taken, but nothing happens.
So many people are not interested
in changing the law in terms of internet.
Whatever action must be taken taken to overcome this problem,
needs to be taken
Well, if that requires compensation the Decency Act, then fine.
I would love to do it.
Last night we issued a report.
This shows evidence of criminal activity
and we have to spend 18 months and go all the way to the Supreme Court
to get this information
More than 20 months ago, this subcommittee
launch a bipartisan investigation about how sex trafficking is used internet to exchange their trade.
Visit www.Fastbet99.club Trusted Trusted Online Gambling Agent
Backpage refuses to cooperate with investigation subcommittee.
They oppose our court call,
failed to appear at the hearing in November 2015,
or provide the requested document.
We now want to contact our first panel witness for today's trial
This is the custom of this subcommittee to swear on all witnesses.
Do you swear that your testimony is will give before this subcommittee
will be truth, all truth, and nothing but truth,
so please help God
Please sit down.
Last night, Chairman Portman and I received news from Backpage
that in response to our report,
the company has been closed the adult part
throughout the United States effective immediately
I'm sure it's pure coincidence.
Only time will tell
if this action is fair a cheap publicity action.
Backpage intentionally edit words shows child sex trafficking.
"Fresh," "innocent," "school girl" and even "Amber Alert."
These children are still being sold.
Shameless.
Shame on you for hiding behind the First Amendment.
If an underage girl is being sold for sex
and the germany put the word "Lolita" in the ad,
stripping the term from ads
doesn't magically change the age of girls, right?
I refuse to answer your question.
Based on the rights granted by the First and Fifth Amendments.
Mr. Lacey, I understand from your response
you will call you the fifth amendment is correct
in response to anything and all questions submitted to you today
Obviously.
This ends with questions from this panel.
You are forgiven panel based on
your affirmation The five amendments to rights.
You are listening to the hearing today,
Backpage has been pulled down their companion site
That is a publicity action in the Backpage section.
That is showmanship.
I think it's a ruse.
And the next Backpage will join
unless we fix CDA.
How long can you be to continue to proceed with the court proceedings
on your own source?
As long as needed.
Straight up, provided it is needed. I can do this.
Will you sell the furniture?
I will sell the furniture.
Apart from all the legality about what is permitted,
the question is what's right
There are questions for What kind of society are we going to be,
whether we will tolerate sexual trafficking in children.
That is an insult everything we believe in
And questions for Backpage, I think, what is this?
Do you protect children from human trafficking?
or do you benefit from their suffering?
That's the question.
How can this be a part of the legacy of Suara Desa
sad for me
This kind of operation will be right
What sounds do you want to express?
Today's companies
make a decision to post these images
even without taking the time to find out if they are children.
They make mistakes in allowing my daughter
to be sold 20 times a day on the site.
What if it's your daughter?
How did you feel at that time?
Other M.A., J.S., and Jane Does
are standing and reclamation of their voices,
not only for themselves
but for thousands of others children across the country,
challenging the law has been interpreted so broadly
to oppose common sense,
talk and fight.
Demand that we answer the question
What kind of society do we want?
He is precocious,
nosy, opinionated.
Geez, He is cheerful and friendly.
He always wants it in all mixes
What I like best My daughter is that she has a big heart.
I am Jane Doe.
I will tell myself who is 12 years old,
"Don't settle for lacking You are far more than that.
I promise you."
He only has real spices for life.
Even with him being broken he, he shares so much love
I am Jane Doe.
He doesn't have to let anything have happened in his past to hold him back.
I want my daughter to raise her head up high,
and know that All this is not his fault.
Mother changes this is more than anything
It's time for us all to stand up and be strong.
They save their children, take to the streets
They bring this case to court.
This is often where the actual movement begins.
And that's the only way to make changes,
is to make your voice known.
I am Jane Doe.
If I can talk to another Jane Is in this case,
I will tell them, don't give up the fight
They open the way for others.
I just don't want it happened to my sister,
or your children, or the next child.
I will tell Jane Does, You vote literally...
I don't know how many thousands, I don't know how many.
I am Jane Doe.
I am a victim of sex trafficking.
I am Jane Doe.
I'm smart, I'm beautiful.
I'm strong, sharp, loving.
I am a survivor.
Submitted by: www.subtitlecinema.com